PTL 2019-02-11

11 Feb 2019	PTL Recordings	Zoom Chat Log

Duration 60 minutes

Zoom Bridge https://zoom.us/j/283628617

Duration	Agenda Item	Requested by	Notes / Links
START RECORDING
5min	Casablanca Maintenance Release	cl664y@att.com	Incomplete release notes? UsecaseUI, Modeling Need support from the Documentation project - changes have been made but are not reflected in the release note: AAI, Integration and Logging => Potentially missing to update the git submodule in the doc project in the Casablanca branch to publish the changes. See this as an example: https://gerrit.onap.org/r/#/c/78201/ Release announcement
10min	Dublin Release M1 Follow-up (if any) M2 preparation	Former user (Deleted)	Project conditionally passed M1: Documentation Review list of action items on Dublin requirements Locale/Internationalization language support Tao Shen xNF communication security enhancements Linda Hornto be followed-up with Security Subcommittee SOL 004 (VNF Package Security) Samuli Kuusela to be followed-up with Security Subcommittee S3P- Geo-Redundancy djhunt Security by Design Amy Zwarico - Proposed Updates to Release Templates (Dublin) - Security Questions. If no feedback from PTL by 2/12 noon CET then M2-M4will be sent to TSC for vote. CI/CD Michael O'Brien Global Optimize (Shared DB) Eric Debeau Mike Elliott Global Optimize (Component/Memory) Eric Debeau Mike Elliott Container Optimization Adolfo Perez-Duran - Some debate on commercial support of Alpine (need vote). Dublin Testing Strategy to be defined - which container type will be used by the Integration Team. E2E process automation Eric Debeau Bin Yang Alexis de Talhouët Modularity Seshu Kumar Mudiganti Change Management - Flexible designer/orchestrator Ajay Mahimkar Consistent ID of a Cloud Region Bin Yang S3P - Ugrade Capabilities djhunt CCVPN use case LIN MENG
	prioritize rest of agenda	Former user (Deleted)	extend PTL meeting? focused topical meetings?
5mins	Don't break the build	Yang Xu	Discussion on the procedures and resource to enforce it Current blockers reported by the Integration Team: Dublin Release Integration Test Blocking Issues
5min	oParent scope and schedule overview Checkstyle - Some work has been done regarding checkstyle - optional for PTL's.	Amy Zwarico Pamela Dragosh	oParent communication plan to PTLs still open - likely a Jira notification TSC-71 - Getting issue details... STATUS - more draft pages of coding styles coming in the next couple weeks
15mins	Upgrade Casablanca to Dublin - a demo	Mike Elliott	Interactive session - at TSC
10mins	Multi-CPU Detailed Strategy Plan/Resource Plan	Paul-Ionut Vaduva	Focus on the test strategy and any additional resources - DEFER
5min	ONAP CLI	Former user (Deleted)	AAI, SDC, SO, Policy, APPC, SDNC and MSB CLI commands in Dublin release?
10min	Datalake approved as a POC Start to discuss project impact either as producers of for example Elasticsearch as a Service or as consumers of for example multitenant MySQL/MariaDB/PostregSQL aaS and for new services like Containerized Hadoop as a Service	From TSC meet Vijay Kumar Michael O'Brien (as collaborator only)	Project APIs please add Collaboration jiras below ONAPARC-264 - ONAP DataLake IN PROGRESS LOG-930 - POMBA/LOG Integration with Datalake as a Service platform - TSC 20190117 - via DCAE OPEN
	Locale/Internationalization language support	Tao Shen	Need to confirm testing resource to Yang Xu and what they will be able to test - to be concluded on 2/4
5min	Samsung ONAP penetration test ongoing results	Krzysztof Opasiak	Requested outcome: Scheduling of a sponsored ONAP code base third party audit
	Using non-root user in containers	Jonathan Gathman	Best practice review in prep for M2

Action Items

Security M2-M4 to be voted by TSC and integrated into official Checklist templated
Dublin Testing Strategy to cover Footprint Optimization, Global Optimize (Shared DB & Component/Memory): Eric/Adolfo/Mike + TSC
Testing Strategy: https://lists.onap.org/g/onap-tsc/message/4605
Project teams to document the change in image size from Casablanca to Dublin as part of the changes they are making
Owners to provide feedback on the YELLOW items by 2/18 otherwise their features/non-functional requirements will be descoped from the Dublin Release
15 mins Demo on TSC Call (2/11)

Zoom Chat Log

06:01:03 From Keong Lim k00759777 : calendar pages are always off due to timezone changes
06:02:51 From Keong Lim k00759777 : is it fixed on Eastern US time?
06:09:50 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : I would like to see all ONAP meetings fixed to UTC since it doesn't change. Right now most other than the TSC meeting are fixed to US time zones.
06:13:38 From Catherine Lefevre : @Jason - i have updated https://lf-onap.atlassian.net/wiki/display/DW/Dublin+Release+Requirements
06:13:48 From Catherine Lefevre : based on your feedback - let me know if youa re nok
06:18:52 From Keong Lim k00759777 : host not root
06:19:15 From Jason Hunt : @Catherine - Thanks, I tweaked it slightly
06:19:55 From Catherine Lefevre : ok jason
06:22:08 From Michael O'Brien(Amdocs,LOG) : for the C doc index change to pull in the RN - do we put the repo name or the name of the project - I would expect a non-linkable name since the other projects are capitalized different from the repo
06:22:08 From Michael O'Brien(Amdocs,LOG) : https://git.onap.org/doc/tree/docs/release/index.rst
06:22:49 From Amy Zwarico : https://lf-onap.atlassian.net/wiki/display/DW/Proposed+Updates+to+Release+Templates+%28Dublin%29+-+Security+Questions
06:24:55 From Catherine Lefevre : @Michael o'brien - i think I can turn to green on https://lf-onap.atlassian.net/wiki/display/DW/Dublin+Release+Requirements
06:25:05 From Catherine Lefevre : based on your today's feedback - are you ok?
06:27:57 From Michael O'Brien(Amdocs,LOG) : Yes green
06:28:02 From Catherine Lefevre : ok done
06:29:11 From Brian : alpine as the container base is different from the host OS system
06:29:15 From Michael O'Brien(Amdocs,LOG) : Agree with alpine standard - just need to work out migrations of the non-alpine container - I would like to stop using the tomcat image for example
06:29:55 From Michael O'Brien(Amdocs,LOG) : each of use will reduce the footprint by a 400mb minimum per images this way
06:30:47 From Michael O'Brien(Amdocs,LOG) : +1 Eric - the JAX-RS 2.0 to Spring controller migration is container independent - it needs to be done first
06:31:35 From Michael O'Brien(Amdocs,LOG) : or find a way to swap out spring-rs with the jersey RI
06:32:37 From Catherine Lefevre : be cautious JAX-RS 2.0 not really recommended by Linux IP
06:33:24 From Catherine Lefevre : preference is Sprint Boot
06:33:24 From Michael O'Brien(Amdocs,LOG) : For the C RN - posted a review to link in the RN - please merge - doc team - thank you https://gerrit.onap.org/r/#/c/78218/1/docs/release/index.rst
06:33:54 From Michael O'Brien(Amdocs,LOG) : +1 agree - move to spring boot (1.5 currently - but 2.x preferred)
06:34:08 From Catherine Lefevre : what does it mean all teams will support testing?
06:34:16 From Catherine Lefevre : Integration will support both????
06:35:16 From Pamela Dragosh : Looks like we are going from every single image now having to create 4 images due to Multi-cpu and alpine/ubuntu requirements.
06:35:38 From Catherine Lefevre : well I think we need to select one container type
06:35:48 From Catherine Lefevre : multi-archi not committted for Dublin
06:35:49 From Yang Xu : Integration can not certify both
06:36:09 From Catherine Lefevre : extactly that's my point, that's why we need to have a clear Testing strategy
06:37:09 From Pamela Dragosh : If a company needs a certain cpu and/or base operating system, they should create/build those images internally and test those images themselves.
06:37:10 From Keong Lim k00759777 : this POC is changing all the Dockerfiles, I don't think there is a separate branch
06:39:27 From Michael O'Brien(Amdocs,LOG) : pomba is on alpine at around 250mb, logging is on tomcat at around 450mb
06:49:05 From Michael O'Brien(Amdocs,LOG) : until the full CD system is running without false-positives - do the following minimum short/long regression
06:49:13 From Michael O'Brien(Amdocs,LOG) : kubectl get pods --all-namespaces
06:49:30 From Michael O'Brien(Amdocs,LOG) : to list all your 1/1 2/2 3/3 pods - no 0/1 1/2 partial pods
06:49:47 From Michael O'Brien(Amdocs,LOG) : then ./ete-k8s.sh onap health (make sure the robot container is up)
06:50:07 From Michael O'Brien(Amdocs,LOG) : post PASS healthcheck as well to oom gerrit review
06:50:40 From Michael O'Brien(Amdocs,LOG) : ideally bring up the entire 225G system and do above for major changes - or possible conflicts with other pods - like nodeport changes
06:52:42 From Keong Lim k00759777 : is it expired because it's not pulled or because it was not rebuilt recently?
06:55:41 From Michael O'Brien(Amdocs,LOG) : +1 delivered is fully tested after merged - submitted is for review "in pre-merge review"
06:57:08 From Michael O'Brien(Amdocs,LOG) : right no dependencies - these are partially defined in the oom yamls - but need to be moved up into the pipeline https://lf-onap.atlassian.net/wiki/display/DW/Log+Streaming+Compliance+and+API#LogStreamingComplianceandAPI-DeploymentDependencyTree
06:57:36 From Michael O'Brien(Amdocs,LOG) : dropping in 120 sec for 10am meet
06:58:38 From Pamela Dragosh : https://gerrit.onap.org/r/#/c/78070/
07:00:48 From Yang Xu : @keong lim, expired after 25 days is LF rule to save disk space
07:00:50 From Pamela Dragosh : https://jira.onap.org/browse/INT-868
07:05:30 From Catherine Lefevre : Team - I need to drop -I will follow-up with the ONAP TSc about Testing Strategy for to cover Footprint Optimization, Global Optimize (Shared DB & Component/Memory); M2-M4 Security
07:07:33 From Keong Lim k00759777 : is it structured like the documentation sub-repo?
07:12:19 From Keong Lim k00759777 : is the cli part of the integration testing?
07:24:28 From Adolfo : @Pam. There will be only one image, regardless of the base image used to minimize footprint.
07:25:53 From Adolfo : Ubuntu base image has security vulnerabilities and is 900% larger than Alpine.