PTL 2019-10-21

zoom bridge: https://zoom.us/j/283628617

21 Oct 2019	PTL Recordings	Zoom Chat Log

Duration 60 minutes

Duration	Agenda Item	Requested by	Notes / Links
START RECORDING AntiTrust Message
10mins	Change PTL Call format	cl664y@att.com	Initial feedback from PTLs Focus on More fine-tuned dependencies between the projects discussed Prioritized for PTL activities Focus on their road blocks PTL Topics Template Cross-project discussions LF Infrastructure/Rel process Testing Environment Testing Improvement CSIT Review ToolChain Improvement Other Improvement suggestion Subcommittee Updates for PTLs Sharing Best Practices ONAP release cadence
5mins	Cross-project discussion	Pamela Dragosh	New Policy API - need feedback from SO, SDNC. Need to follow-up with Seshu - Byung is taking the action for SO Dan T should be OK
5mins	Cross-project discussion	David McBride	Request PTLs to estimate the effort to migrate to the following version as part of their M1 - could be tracked as part of their Release Planning Template Python 2 → 3 Java 8 → 11 except CCSDK/APPC/SDNC concerning ODL dependencies? Need to also assess the impacts on the toolchain i.e. JJB jobs using some Python 2 scripts
10mins	Subcommittee Updates for PTLs - Security	Amy Zwarico	Security Subcommittee to provide their recommendations for the versioning of common technologies etc. Versioning for K8S, Database etc. Security Subcommittee also created additional JIRA Release Management tickets for M1 i.e. Python3 Migration, Java11 Migration ACTION (David): need to check if everything was created for OOM, DCAE, Logging + R6 M1 Planning JIRA Ticket
5 mins	Release Improvement	cl664y@att.com	Shall we add back the following wiki page: Release Planning Template ACTION (David): Create a new Release Management JIRA ticket per project to track the completion of Release Planning wiki page as part of M1 ACTION (PTL): Review the Release Management Template by next Monday (10/28)
IF TIME ALLOWS ....
10min	CSIT review	Morgan Richomme Lasse Kaihlavirta	Currently few failing jobs - please direct attention to getting these tests functioning correctly. Useless CSIT test elimination
20 mins	El-Alto Release	Former user (Deleted) djhunt Paweł Pawlak Brian Freeman Morgan Richomme	Project Status: Project Status in El-Alto Release Integration Status: Marco Platania Discussion about SDNC-949 - fix in Gerrit and provide information in the SDNC release note Change Management (80%) - issue with SDC that will be documented in the release note (to be followed-up with Ofir) 2x Multicloud issues - need the latest status from Bin and documented in the release note Integration\benchmark will be locked 72H Stability Run #1 issue with Robot but not with ONAP. #2 PDP/PAP synchronization issue identied and word around documented DCAE – - ACTION (Vijay): to follow up and update Integration Team Orange labs is back - Yoohoo Owers to document readthedoc based on Integration Status (2: El Alto Release Integration Testing Status) https://docs.onap.org/en/latest/submodules/integration.git/docs/ https://gerrit.onap.org/r/gitweb?p=integration.git;a=tree;f=docs;h=56e645979e34d7c7e52dd921f76bc0f5ff8b3f58;hb=refs/heads/elalto Release Note Status: Sofia Wallin / Eric Debeau APPC not reflecting the latest gerrit - https://gerrit.onap.org/r/c/appc/+/97276 Composite Release Note - re-use what we are collecting from the highlights - El Alto Release Key Updates ACTION (Amar/Brandon): Follow-up with them to get the consolidated version that will be included in the RTD Some projects still need to work on their release note - they will be contacted by the Documentation team UUI status is still unknown - propose use Dublin container for UUI (descope from El Alto if no insight by PTL 21 Oct 2019 ) - ACTION: Lingli Deng to notify UUI PTL CLI - IT Showstopper License Status: ACTION: Remove proprietary notice (CSAR)-DONE and Search guard (CLAMP)-DONE Security Status: Paweł Pawlak -ACTION: Amy Zwarico provide risk assessment from a Security perspective <AMY TO ADD HER PRESENTATION> ACTION (Jonathan): provide guidelines about AAF to SO (Byung) Marketing Highlights:El Alto Release Key Updates El Alto Remaining Milestones Completion of Integration Testing: Oct 17th, 2019 (Completed -Well Done) El-Alto Sign-Off on: Oct 24th, 2019 (on Track) El-Alto Marketing Launch: Oct 31st, 2019 (on Track)
10min	Frankfurt Planning - Focus on the subcommittees	David McBride Paweł Pawlak djhunt Alla.Goldner Stephen terrill Hui Deng Andy Mayer Pamela Dragosh	Frankfurt Release Requirements Feedback from the Architecture Review: Stephen terrill Feedback about S3P: djhunt , Paweł Pawlak Feedback from TSC: cl664y@att.com
15min	DockerHub Migration update	cristinapauna	Cross project dependencies onap-discuss message: https://lists.onap.org/g/onap-discuss/topic/dockerhub_migration_and/34447632?p=,,,20,0,0,0::recentpostdate%2Fsticky,,,20,2,0,34447632 wiki: Migration to DockerHub From TSC Chat: "The proposal is to generate the release tag only by the release Jenkins job (now it's also generated by the staging job). I will not be able to join the PTL meeting next week, so I will go to the OOM and CSIT meetings next Wednesday to discuss it. I will come back next week at the TSC meeting with the result." Feedback from OOM: Each helm chart will reference to a specific version of a docker file (=traceability & configuration management purpose).
5min	LF Infrastructure/Rel process	Jessica Gonzalez Kenny Paul	Self-releases - progress report How to get support: http://support.linuxfoundation.org (DO NOT use helpdesk@onap.org) WhiteSource parallel execution
10 mins	Remaining Action Items	Former user (Deleted)	PTL Weekly ONAP12, Mon UTC 13:00
15min	ONAP release cadence	Chaker Al-Hakim	Explore release process cadence

Zoom Chat Log

06:23:41 From Catherine Lefèvre : Team - doing my best to track all the discussions
06:23:54 From Catherine Lefèvre : if I am miscapturing anything then please correct the minutes
06:24:29 From Catherine Lefèvre : the wiki page is https://lf-onap.atlassian.net/wiki/display/DW/PTL+2019-10-21
06:26:27 From Eric Debeau : We also need to evaluate impcat on JJB jobs using some Python 2 scripts
06:49:18 From Catherine Lefèvre : @Bin yang -are u there? can u hear us? you are muted
06:54:44 From Marco Platania (AT&T) : https://lf-onap.atlassian.net/wiki/display/DW/2%3A+El+Alto+Release+Integration+Testing+Status
06:54:54 From Marco Platania (AT&T) : https://docs.onap.org/en/latest/submodules/integration.git/docs/docs_scaleout.html
06:55:25 From Marco Platania (AT&T) : https://gerrit.onap.org/r/gitweb?p=integration.git;a=tree;f=docs;h=56e645979e34d7c7e52dd921f76bc0f5ff8b3f58;hb=refs/heads/elalto
06:56:06 From ONAP Meeting 8 : https://gerrit.onap.org/r/c/appc/+/97276

Action Items

Amy ZwaricoSend revised text for Python3 requirement for MS1 to David McBride
David McBride make sure that DCAE, OOM, and Logging projects received M1 JIRA ticket for Frankfurt
PTLs (ALL) review release planning template and provide feedback on Oct 28 on what should be updated, removed, or added
David McBride add requirement to M1 to complete release planning template
Former user (Deleted) Add David McBride as project co-host for CII badging for Frankfurt