PTL 2019-11-11

Agenda

START RECORDING

Duration

Agenda Item

Requested byNotes / Links
1 hour

Cross-project discussions


Java 11 and Alpine versioning proposal for Frankfurt Amy Zwarico

  • Recommendation from SECCOM
    • Java 11.05
    • Alpine 3.10.3
    • SECCOM requesting feedback from PTLs
    • Pre-built image recommendation vs JDK v recommendation?

Java 11 transition

  • Note that projects with ODL dependencies must remain at Java 8 for Frankfurt.  
    • ODL Sodium (Feb/Mar) supports Java 11.


Dependency on oparent

  • oParent is led by the Integration Team
  • Current version 2.2.0-Snapshot and 2.1.0-released)
  • Java 8 projects use the 2.X version

  • Java 11 projets use the 3.X version

  • JBB Jobs support Java 11

Moving to Java 11:  2.x ==> 3.x

Not on 2.x: 1.x ==> 2.x

Staying on 2.x:  2.x ==> 2.2+ (likely)

LF IT Support


https://jira.linuxfoundation.org/servicedesk/customer/portal/2/IT-18172 via Pamela Dragosh(Related to CSIT problems)

  • Problem is understood now.  ETA based on Jessica's availability over the next week or two.

Morgan Richomme - did you send an email notification to warn community about Dec 3 deletion of disabled Jenkins jobs?

  • Email sent last week.

Jessica Gonzalez : pylint implementation in all the projects as an informational tool (similar to checkstyle for JAVA) for the PTLs/Committers about the quality of submitted code.It will be part of the verify Jenkins job but it will not return verify -1 by default except if PTL will raise the request to block the code. No action for the TSC.

Maturity dashboard issue:

Jessica Gonzalez to send a note to onap-release, onap-tsc mailing list to provide guidelines in order to avoid this behavior in the future (not discard update?)- problem captured as IT-18144

  • Ticket closed

IT-18078 integration/xtesting

  • Jessica says e-mail sent to TSC mailing list. Waiting for TSC approval.
  • ACTION: Kenny to review issue and determine need for TSC vote.

ACTION:  David to follow up with Kenny.  Do we need to add this to the TSC agenda?

IT-17739/RELENG-2422 - new open ticket to address the template changes for docker tagging. Its pending on LF update.

  • Waiting for feedback from Vijay

RELENG-2517 -ONAP JIRA has invalid resolution type resulting in confusing behavior - OJessica Gonzalez to send a note to onap-release, onap-tsc mailing list about this limitation?

  • Need TSC approval to move forward.

SONAR Threshold - "Passed" Threshold will be set to 55% and "Warning" Threshold will be set to 50%

  • Completed
  • Note that current version of SONAR no longer includes "warning" parameter
  • Recommendation is to move to SONAR cloud
  • Discuss upgrade in TSC meeting

IT-17899 - APPC code coverage down from 80% to 5% (with sonar cloud migration)

  • Still investigating
  • Possibly related to using older version of Sonar

SUPPORT-690 : Integration with gitlab

  • Roadmap for support has been created

Should we move to one mailing list per project? https://www.surveymonkey.com/r/53WFQD9

Testing EnvironmentAny update?

Sharing Best Practices


  • El-Alto Retrospective - please submit your feedback by Nov 15th - these will be reviewed during the PTL Call on 11/18.

Krzysztof Opasiak - did you setup separate meetings with MSB, Logging, and CLI projects (In that order) to discuss security maturity and open OJSI tickets?

cl664y@att.com  -  The invitation has been sent to MSB PTL waiting for response. Aiming to have a call somewhere between 12 and 15 of November

IF TIME ALLOWS ....
20 minRelease status
10 minsRemaining Action ItemsPTL Weekly ONAP12, Mon UTC 13:00
10 minsAAF and Service Mesh Support
  • M3 Security Checklist item to ensure AAF integration can be enabled/disabled
  • Consistent Helm Chart configuration value supporting AAF and Service Mesh:  OOM-1986 - Getting issue details... STATUS

Incoming EventsKenny Paul
  • PTL call is now planned @3pm CET, 9am EST, 6am PST, 8am CST, 10pm China Time, 7.30pm Indian Time
  • TSC Election - Ballots distributed. Voting ends Nov 19, 22:00 UTC
  • ONAP/CNTT F2F Event in January 13-16th, 2020 - Prague - Registration https://events19.linuxfoundation.org/events/lf-networking-ddf-plugfest-2020/
  • ONAP 2 day event before or after ONES North America (April 20&21) - Los Angeles (TBC)
  • ONAP DDF planned in June - under planning
  • ONAP 2 day event before or after ONS North Europe - Antwerp (TBC)
  • Survey coming from LFN for Dec OR Jan for steady-state full DDF meetings to all LFN communities & locations
  • TSC Meetings will be canceled on Nov 28th, Dec 25th, 2019 and Jan 1st, 2020
  • Linux Foundation office holiday closures
    • Nov. 28th & 29th
    • Dec. 23rd through Jan 3rd, 2020 - Shall we cancel PTL calls on 12/3 and 12/30?

Zoom Chat Log 

06:10:46 From Jonathan Gathman : FROM openjdk:12-jdk-alpine
06:12:53 From Adrian O'Sullivan : in NBI we had used openjdk:11-jre-slim in El Alto
06:13:49 From Jonathan Gathman : I couldn’t get that pulled down anymore.
06:14:03 From Vijay Venkatesh Kumar (AT&T) : https://lf-onap.atlassian.net/wiki/display/DW/CIA-+Container+Images+-+Best+Practices+and+Tools
06:14:03 From Jonathan Gathman : If someone else is able, that’s great.
06:17:15 From Vijay Venkatesh Kumar (AT&T) : Recommended base image from CIA team -https://wiki.onap.org/display/DW/ONAP+Normative+container+base+images. This is based on Dublin; need to be relooked by CIA team.
06:24:12 From Morgan Richomme : @Adrian do you use oparent in NBI? (as the version supported Java 11 has not been released yet..)
06:25:06 From Mike Elliott : Unfortunately need to drop temporarily. Will rejoin call in 35 minutes (top of hour).
06:25:42 From Adrian O'Sullivan : we use oparent 2.1.0 in the NBI pom
06:27:58 From Morgan Richomme : @adrian and you did not get any dependency issues using the jre11 for el alto (2.1.0 is related to Java 8)
06:29:27 From Adrian O'Sullivan : @morgan No issues that I know of
06:46:30 From Dan Timoney : At some point on this call, I’d like to confirm the process for requesting a new repo.  I sent an approval request to infrastructure-coordinator@onap.org 2 weeks ago and and still haven’t gotten a response

Action Items 

  • Amy Zwarico- recommend pre-built image instead of JDK version.  Also consider Java 12+ vs. Java 11.
  • David McBride - follow up with Kenny regarding 18078 and infra coordinator. Add to TSC agenda.
  • Jessica Gonzalez - send email regarding SONAR