PTL 2019-03-11

Owned by cl664y@att.com
Last updated: Jul 12, 2019 by Former user (Deleted)
5 min read

zoom bridge: https://zoom.us/j/283628617

PTL RecordingsZoom Chat Log

Duration 60 minutes

DurationAgenda ItemRequested byNotes / Links
START RECORDING

Review Action Items

Former user (Deleted)



M3 checklist update - TSC approves

"Has the Project team provided links to Data Models (e.g, JSON, YANG, Swagger, etc.) for all Shared Information (e.g., APIs, API Payload, Shared Design Model)?" (non-blocking)

Deliverables for API Freeze Milestone Checklist Template

Former user (Deleted)

cl664y@att.com

M3 Checklists are due by March 13th, 10am EST/4pm CET/8.30pm Indian time/11pm Beijing Time. TSC reviews M3 on 2019-03-14. 15 out of 30 submitted.

10min

Certificate expiry for Dublin

Action for Casablanca

Expired certifs in Casablanca AND some Dublin certs that will expire before the release is done.

9a Central time 2019-03-12 AAF meeting Jonathan will demo method of getting certif at install time.



Brian Freeman

for server in aaf-service.onap:8100 aai.onap:8443 vid.onap:8443 portal-app.onap:8443 sdc-fe.onap:9443 sdc-be.onap:8443 clamp.onap:8443 pap.onap:8443 ;

do

    host=$(echo $server | cut -d ":" -f 1)

echo | openssl s_client -showcerts -servername $host -connect $server  2>/dev/null | openssl x509 -inform pem -noout -text  | grep -E "Not After|Not Before|Issuer:|Subject:"

done

Recommended model in the comments section.

5minoParent contents and delivery plan

Amy Zwarico

Paweł Pawlak

Please provide the plan to deliver the oParent contents BEFORE M3

Latest releases of the libraries in the oParent changes merged once. Ready for distribution - use 1.2.3 for Dublin. May be additional updates - Amy Zwarico to followup.

Not clear what the latest release? Need a process for making this clear - where can the integration team publicize this info? Recommend oParent documentation on the Integration team wiki

10 min

oParent issues with current release 1.2.3 compilation per ChrisC and need for a strategy to address JDK 11 upgrades.

Pamela Dragosh

ChrisC

Gary Wu - can you please attend?

Can this be combined with what Amy and Pawel are presenting in previous agenda item?

JDK 11 conflicts with oParent - may need 2 versions? Defer to El Alto/Dublin maint rel.

Arch subcommittee and developer assist.

AI: CL to convene a task force on this topic

10minHelm chart migration planJessica Gonzalez

Discuss the options for transferring history out of OOM and back into a project subdirectory

DEFER – no presenter

10minglobal-jjb updateJessica Gonzalez

Snapshot dependencies prohibited

DEFER – no presenter

5minFollow-up from Footprint Optimization call - any question from PTLs?

Adolfo Perez-Duran (Deactivated)

Sylvain Desbureaux

Container Image Minimization Guidelines
See pointer in action items for video log of last guidelines discussion.
5minWhere to find the containers to be certified by the Integration Team?

Mike Elliott

Yang Xu

Follow up from 2019-03–04 meeting

q) the meeting involving?

Eric Debeau

Adolfo Perez-Duran (Deactivated)

Mike Elliott

Know the direction - but no conclusions yet.

5minProposal: Wind River lab VM deletion - VMs > 100 days old to be deleted

eddy.raineri

Former user (Deleted)

Exceptions to deletion plan need to be sent to Former user (Deleted) eddy.raineri before 2019-03-18

Would like a mechanism to understand if the cluster is active. Open Lab subcommittee will tackle setting limits for resources.

5min

TSC Policy on ONAP Maintenance Release


Request to provide final feedback about v5 before March 11th EOD

https://jira.onap.org/secure/attachment/13434/Prosal%20for%20a%20TSC%20Policy%20on%20ONAP%20Release%20Maintenance-pa5.pptx


e-mail reference: https://lists.onap.org/g/onap-tsc/topic/onap_release_tsc_policy_on/30323903?p=,,,20,0,0,0::recentpostdate%2Fsticky,,,20,2,0,30323903

cl664y@att.com

TSC-34 - Getting issue details... STATUS

Feedback to Stephen terrill

For Casablanca Dmaap fix - can a component release be issued (expired certs)? Not yet - let's understand all the impacted projects and determine the course of action.

TSC-119 - Getting issue details... STATUS

Need a clear owner and due date.

5min

Jeopardy of Integration blocking issues for M3 approval

Yang Xu

Dublin Release Integration Test Blocking Issues

Appears that pairwise testing is not being performed. May be a result of not having an E2E env. Pamela Dragosh notes that pair-wise is not required until M4. Marco Platania notes that a some code has not be written due to blockers.

Action Items

  • Krzysztof Opasiakto provide vulnerability procedure overview next week 2019-02-25
    /* Vulnerability Management Procedure is being updated so I'd like to delay this till the procedure is approved by TSC to avoid confusion. Hopefully the overview will be delivered next week. */
  • 2/11: Migrate Docker image releases from Nexus3 into Docker Hub (Architecture Independence) by Dublin M4. 
    <2-15-2019> Preparing a preso for review of all known infrastructure change requests for review at PTL meeting 2-25-2019
  • Oom values.yaml or integration repo manifest ( TSC-86 - Lock down docker image tag name source of truth - oom values.yaml or integration repo manifest - A: both but manifest is the source SUBMITTED ) Michael O'Brien

    if not covered - see TSC 2019-01-10

    Quick discussion on nailing down whether we need a yaml override of the deployable

    docker image tags in the oom repo (understanding is no) - with the integration docker manifest

    (manifest is currently a copy of the oom values.yaml tags - not the reverse)

    If not - then we need a documented procedure wiki/RTD on running a derived values.yaml override for the entire system before deployment

    AAF is only an example here

    https://git.onap.org/oom/tree/kubernetes/aaf/charts/aaf-service/values.yaml?h=casablanca#n28

    image: onap/aaf/aaf_service:2.1.8

    drives

    https://git.onap.org/integration/tree/version-manifest/src/main/resources/docker-manifest.csv?h=casablanca#n11

    onap/aaf/aaf_service,2.1.8

    <1-7/2019> Integration team to document the procedure.<01/13/2019> Answer from Integration team: docker manifest under integration repo is the source of truth, and is used by Integration team to override OOM values.yaml when deploying ONAP in Openlab. See the instructions at the bottom of page https://onap.readthedocs.io/en/casablanca/submodules/integration.git/docs/onap-oom-heat.html#onap-oom-heat-template
    <1-21/2019> Procedure should include Timers, dependencies, etc.
    just need to define all the --set and -f overrides like the following 

    sudo helm deploy onap local/onap --namespace $ENVIRON -f $DISABLE_CHARTS_YAML  -f $DEV0_YAML $APPENDABLE_ENABLED_FLAGS --verbose

    <1-28-2019>: Document how to handle the latest 3rd party image from github.
    <2019-02-19>: One over-ride that will be shared, parent over-ride for docker versions, Michael O'Brien to modify TSC-86 to reflect process. Still looking at tool to institute changes for all projects (single commit). Mike Elliott FREEMAN, BRIAN D Gary Wu Sylvain Desbureaux to follow up offline. 
    It should also consider the problem identified with the Casablanca Maintenance Release:https://lists.onap.org/g/onap-tsc/message/4641
    <2019-03-01 - Need a date for the delivery of the procedure >


  • Helm Chart Transfer: 4 projects have been identified for trial: A&AI, Log, Policy, APPC, CLAMP and ONAP CLI. Mike Elliott will work with PTL to gather/transfer knowledge and create training materials. Training to be done the week of Jan 14 and PTL to provide their commitment or not by M1 on Jan 24.
    <1-7/2019>: Work in progress. Schedule might shift to another week. Michael will follow-up with Mike. Training will be open to everybody. The objective is that each team will take over the management of their Helm Charts. 
    <1-28/2019>: Meeting is organized on 1/29 with LF. Training will be organized early in February. Additional information on the next PTL call (2/4)
    <2019-2-19: Meeting on this topic today - review the process - develop training material. OOM subcharts complete - A&AI this week>
    <2019-03-04: Ready to do the first project A&AI; after testing on the first project make video on process flow, several others will follow Jessica Gonzalez Mike Elliott>
    <still working out the A&AI details - in progress; once the POC is complete the other repos will follow>
    https://gerrit.onap.org/r/#/c/79580/
  • What is the plan for the June ONAP Developers Forum - dates/location/etc  Kenny Paul
    <includes outreach to education - looking at universities>
  • Propose a process for Casablanca security updates Former user (Deleted)Kenny Paul

    <need to provide any more feedback to Terrill and vote on 3/14 TSC>
  • PTLs - to review TSC Webcast on footprint optimization from 2/28 starting from 30th minute - https://r.lfnetworking.org/lfn-zoom/ONAP/TSC-Meetings/TSC-2019/tsc-2019-02-28.mp4
  • Modify code freeze checklist to include a certificate expiry check Former user (Deleted)Brian Freeman
  • Document the current version and any related use notes of oParent on the ONAP wiki Yang Xu

           Gary has updated oParent wiki with the information O-Parent (oparent)