19 Feb 2019	PTL Recordings	Zoom Chat Log

Duration	Agenda Item	Requested by	Notes / Links
START RECORDING
15min	Dublin M2 Preparation M2 Date: 2019-02-21 Missing wksheets: AAI, AAF, CCSDK, DMaaP, Doc, ExtAPI, Holmes, Integration, Logging, MSB, MultiCloud, MUSIC, CLI, OOM, SDNC, SDC, SO, VID, VNFSDK, VNFRQTS, VVP	Former user (Deleted)	Complete the Dublin status page Take the latest template including Security Checklist Don't forget to articulate your known risks Since Feb 15th 1pm EST, we have also reworded the following item to reflect the Dublin non functional requirement about Additional functional tests delivered per project on OOM - See Yang/Morgan's presentation below Modeling Checklist: M2 will not be part of this release since TSC/Modeling team are still under discussion. Target is to get Modeling M3 Checklist as part of Dublin
15min	Version management enhancement - Long term vision Dublin Expectations: Additional functional tests delivered per project on OOM Add integration basic sanity test (pod deployment, healthcheck, model distribution, vFWCL) to milestone checklist POC Gating Project (Morgan's presentation)	Yang Xu / Morgan Richomme cl664y@att.com
10min	Review previous action items from 1/21 till today	Former user (Deleted)	Helm Chart Transfer: 4 projects have been identified for trial: A&AI, Log, Policy, APPC, CLAMP and ONAP CLI. Mike Elliott will work with PTL to gather/transfer knowledge and create training materials. Training to be done the week of Jan 14 and PTL to provide their commitment or not by M1 on Jan 24. <1-7/2019>: Work in progress. Schedule might shift to another week. Michael will follow-up with Mike. Training will be open to everybody. The objective is that each team will take over the management of their Helm Charts. <1-28/2019>: Meeting is organized on 1/29 with LF. Training will be organized early in February. Additional information on the next PTL call (2/4) <2019-2-19: Meeting today - review the process - develop training material. OOM subcharts complete - A&AI this week> Oom values.yaml or integration repo manifest ( TSC-86 - Lock down docker image tag name source of truth - oom values.yaml or integration repo manifest - A: both but manifest is the source Submitted ) Michael O'Brien if not covered - see TSC 2019-01-10 Quick discussion on nailing down whether we need a yaml override of the deployable docker image tags in the oom repo (understanding is no) - with the integration docker manifest (manifest is currently a copy of the oom values.yaml tags - not the reverse) If not - then we need a documented procedure wiki/RTD on running a derived values.yaml override for the entire system before deployment AAF is only an example here https://git.onap.org/oom/tree/kubernetes/aaf/charts/aaf-service/values.yaml?h=casablanca#n28 image: onap/aaf/aaf_service:2.1.8 drives https://git.onap.org/integration/tree/version-manifest/src/main/resources/docker-manifest.csv?h=casablanca#n11 onap/aaf/aaf_service,2.1.8 <1-7/2019> Integration team to document the procedure.<01/13/2019> Answer from Integration team: docker manifest under integration repo is the source of truth, and is used by Integration team to override OOM values.yaml when deploying ONAP in Openlab. See the instructions at the bottom of page https://onap.readthedocs.io/en/casablanca/submodules/integration.git/docs/onap-oom-heat.html#onap-oom-heat-template <1-21/2019> Procedure should include Timers, dependencies, etc. just need to define all the --set and -f overrides like the following sudo helm deploy onap local/onap --namespace $ENVIRON -f $DISABLE_CHARTS_YAML -f $DEV0_YAML $APPENDABLE_ENABLED_FLAGS --verbose  <1-28-2019>: Document how to handle the latest 3rd party image from github. <2019-02-19>: One over-ride that will be shared, parent over-ride for docker versions, Michael O'Brien to modify TSC-86 to reflect process. Still looking at tool to institute changes for all projects (single commit). Mike Elliott FREEMAN, BRIAN D Gary Wu Sylvain Desbureaux to follow up offline. It should also consider the problem identified with the Casablanca Maintenance Release: https://lists.onap.org/g/onap-tsc/message/4641 (PTLs): Review ONAP codebase license scan, Feb. 2019 sent by Steve Winslow on 2/18. (reminder) 2/11: Migrate Docker image releases from Nexus3 into Docker Hub (Architecture Independence) by Dublin M4. <2-15-2019> Preparing a preso for review of all known infrastructure change requests for review at PTL meeting 2-25-2019 (Mike Elliott) will work with PTL to gather/transfer knowledge and create training materials. Targeted projects: A&AI, Log, Policy, APPC, CLAMP and ONAP CLI. (Jimmy Forsyth): Identify projects impacted by AAI-1989 <2019-02-19>: Clients that cannot migrate in the Dublin timeframe can continue to use the old method - but all are urged to adopt new method. Closed loop merged this week. Projects potentially impacted: APPC, CCSDK, VID?
5min	Samsung ONAP penetration test ongoing results	Krzysztof Opasiak	Requested outcome: Scheduling of a sponsored ONAP code base third party audit
10min	Using non-root user in containers	Jonathan Gathman	Best practice review in prep for M2
5 min	Breaking change on pnf object in AAI	James Forsyth	The Pnf object will be changed to use the pnf-id as the key instead of the pnf-name. pnf-name will still be indexed and can be searched for with ?pnf-name={pnf-name} Since it's a breaking change that impacts the graph, all versions of the API back to v11 have to changed. Clients who use a previous version will have to update in Dublin See: pnf-id change AAI-2148 - Getting issue details... STATUS
2min	ONS NA	Former user (Deleted)	Register here Propose topics for an unconference here!

Notes

Paweł Pawlak Please make sure to review your vulnerabilities in the Casablanca Maint Release

Amy Zwarico Update your info in the Vulnerability space as well

Action items

Krzysztof Opasiakto provide vulnerability procedure overview next week 2019-02-25
/* Vulnerability Management Procedure is being updated so I'd like to delay this till the procedure is approved by TSC to avoid confusion. Hopefully the overview will be delivered next week. */
Yang Xu add integration sanity passing in milestone checklist
James Forsyth notify onap-release on the PNF id change & links to use case
(PTLs): Review ONAP codebase license scan, Feb. 2019 sent by Steve Winslow on 2/18. (reminder)
2/11: Migrate Docker image releases from Nexus3 into Docker Hub (Architecture Independence) by Dublin M4.
<2-15-2019> Preparing a preso for review of all known infrastructure change requests for review at PTL meeting 2-25-2019
Oom values.yaml or integration repo manifest ( TSC-86 - Lock down docker image tag name source of truth - oom values.yaml or integration repo manifest - A: both but manifest is the source SUBMITTED ) Michael O'Brien
if not covered - see TSC 2019-01-10
Quick discussion on nailing down whether we need a yaml override of the deployable
docker image tags in the oom repo (understanding is no) - with the integration docker manifest
(manifest is currently a copy of the oom values.yaml tags - not the reverse)
If not - then we need a documented procedure wiki/RTD on running a derived values.yaml override for the entire system before deployment
AAF is only an example here
https://git.onap.org/oom/tree/kubernetes/aaf/charts/aaf-service/values.yaml?h=casablanca#n28
```
image: onap/aaf/aaf_service:2.1.8
```
drives
https://git.onap.org/integration/tree/version-manifest/src/main/resources/docker-manifest.csv?h=casablanca#n11
```
onap/aaf/aaf_service,2.1.8
```
<1-7/2019> Integration team to document the procedure.<01/13/2019> Answer from Integration team: docker manifest under integration repo is the source of truth, and is used by Integration team to override OOM values.yaml when deploying ONAP in Openlab. See the instructions at the bottom of page https://onap.readthedocs.io/en/casablanca/submodules/integration.git/docs/onap-oom-heat.html#onap-oom-heat-template
<1-21/2019> Procedure should include Timers, dependencies, etc.
just need to define all the --set and -f overrides like the following

sudo helm deploy onap local/onap --namespace $ENVIRON -f $DISABLE_CHARTS_YAML -f $DEV0_YAML $APPENDABLE_ENABLED_FLAGS --verbose 
<1-28-2019>: Document how to handle the latest 3rd party image from github.
<2019-02-19>: One over-ride that will be shared, parent over-ride for docker versions, Michael O'Brien to modify TSC-86 to reflect process. Still looking at tool to institute changes for all projects (single commit). Mike Elliott FREEMAN, BRIAN D Gary Wu Sylvain Desbureaux to follow up offline.
It should also consider the problem identified with the Casablanca Maintenance Release:https://lists.onap.org/g/onap-tsc/message/4641
Helm Chart Transfer: 4 projects have been identified for trial: A&AI, Log, Policy, APPC, CLAMP and ONAP CLI. Mike Elliott will work with PTL to gather/transfer knowledge and create training materials. Training to be done the week of Jan 14 and PTL to provide their commitment or not by M1 on Jan 24.
<1-7/2019>: Work in progress. Schedule might shift to another week. Michael will follow-up with Mike. Training will be open to everybody. The objective is that each team will take over the management of their Helm Charts.
<1-28/2019>: Meeting is organized on 1/29 with LF. Training will be organized early in February. Additional information on the next PTL call (2/4)
<2019-2-19: Meeting on this topic today - review the process - develop training material. OOM subcharts complete - A&AI this week>
What is the plan for the June ONAP Developers Forum - dates/location/etc Kenny Paul Former user (Deleted)

Zoom Chat Log

07:14:11 From Victor Gao : VNFSDK M2 Checklist is here: https://lf-onap.atlassian.net/wiki/pages/viewpage.action?pageId=16350231
07:19:28 From Catherine Lefevre : bridge updated on ptl agenda 2/19 and 2/25 to https://zoom.us/j/2731206358
07:22:22 From Martial Ngueko (AT&T) to Jim Baker (LFN) (Privately) : Brian Freeamn
07:22:30 From Martial Ngueko (AT&T) to Jim Baker (LFN) (Privately) : not Hedstrom
07:23:38 From Michael O'Brien : also tag https://gerrit.onap.org/r/#/admin/projects/oom,tags
07:23:56 From Michael O'Brien : with 3.0.1-ONAP
07:26:17 From Krzysztof Opasiak to Jim Baker (LFN) (Privately) : Hi Jim, do you know anything about issues with login to gerrit? I just tried to login and I always get "Authentication unavailable at this time"
07:26:33 From Jim Baker (LFN) to Martial Ngueko (AT&T) (Privately) : I do not.
07:29:22 From Catherine Lefevre : @Mike Elliot - we need to fix this issue - https://lists.onap.org/g/onap-tsc/message/4641
07:29:24 From Catherine Lefevre : thank you
07:29:44 From Michael O'Brien : https://jira.onap.org/browse/AAI-1889
07:29:52 From Michael O'Brien : tomcat users
07:30:19 From Michael O'Brien : wong bug
07:30:30 From Michael O'Brien : https://jira.onap.org/browse/AAI-1989
07:33:12 From Dan Timoney : Something is wrong with LF toolkit this morning …
07:33:34 From Dan Timoney : Can’t login to sonar or gerrit
07:34:01 From Dan Timoney : (I’m logged in to Gerrit in a different browser, and there I can’t +2 anything)
07:34:17 From Catherine Lefevre : i got authentication unavailable at this time
07:34:17 From Jim Baker (LFN) : I just tried Gerrit with success
07:34:29 From Catherine Lefevre : not successful for me too
07:34:50 From Keong Lim k00759777 : Authentication unavailable at this time.
07:35:01 From Catherine Lefevre : ok to access the page but not to login
07:35:13 From STEVEN Wright : Gerri still giving “authentication unavailable at this time “ error for me
07:35:16 From Catherine Lefevre : i will open a ticket
07:36:58 From Keong Lim k00759777 : with helm charts moving out of OOM to ONAP projects, does the gating change? it just becomes part of project patchsets?
07:38:54 From Krzysztof Opasiak : I've already opened one couple minutes ago
07:39:02 From Keong Lim k00759777 : but there would still be cases to rebuild the dockers even if no gerrit on that code
07:39:43 From Mike Elliott : The helm charts will move to a sub repo of the @Keong Lim project teams but will be linked to the current oom repo the same way docs is built today. This means you still build oom in the same way as you do today. Subproject are pulled in as part of the clone.
07:39:51 From Catherine Lefevre : ticket to cover gerrit issue - [ONAP Helpdesk #68788] AutoReply: Gerrit Login does not work
07:56:50 From Keong Lim k00759777 : are these jenkins jobs or are they kubernetes jobs? could they be run as sanity tests on newly stood-up ONAP environments?
07:58:14 From Michael O'Brien : https://git.onap.org/testsuite/tree/robot/testsuites
07:59:53 From Keong Lim k00759777 : should those be moved out to individual project management as well?
08:01:50 From Yang Xu : Integration sanity test is run daily, not per submission
08:02:14 From Yang Xu : But we request to add integration sanity passing in milestone checklist
08:02:15 From Taka Cho : @keong, that is my question as well
08:09:45 From Keong Lim k00759777 : is this including https://docs.docker.com/engine/security/userns-remap/ ?
08:15:25 From Keong Lim k00759777 : pnf-id change https://jira.onap.org/browse/AAI-2148
08:17:05 From Catherine Lefevre : gerrit is back

Browser not supported