Agenda

In the process of promoting Kevin Smokowski as one of committers for the logging project, voting ends on 06 Nov 2019 6pm EST
El Alto was officially released on 30 Oct 2019
The future of logging project

Frankfurt status

M1 is targeted for 07 Nov 2019 , logging is currently behind

type	key	summary	assignee	reporter	priority	status	resolution	created	updated	due

Refresh

update to version 3.x of Python
update to Java 11 ✅Dave Williamsonto reach out Kevin Smokowski to evaluate the effort required

Draft Frankfurt spec ONAP Application Logging Specification v1.3 (Frankfurt) - Continuation
- Is there any components still write log to /var/log/ONAP_EELF? Luke ParkerAny updates? 05 Nov 2019 see below
- We owe Steve Smokowski an answer for his question on August 30, 2018 (Response Code and Response Description) and September 4, 2018 (Invoke and Invoke-return).
  - Sanjay and Dave Williamson to talk with the AT&T Ops team for the use of Response Code and Response description.
  ✅- Prudence Auto reply to Steve on invoke and invoke-return and add a JIRA ( LOG-1174 - Update reference library to include a sample invoke-return marker OPEN )to update the sample implementation to include invoke-return marker
- What is needed for Michael's TODO on November 21, 2018 regarding X-FromAppId?
  Prudence Au to include X-FromAppId as one of the option for PartnerName
- Still need to address the issue with 2 test environments and only 1 log instance? Dave Williamson reported it on December 6, 2018
  Sanjay and Dave Williamsonto investigate. This might be resolved by the tenant isolation feature.
- The description for p_message should be updated to "standard attribute - defined in logback.xml - Message - used for %msg%" as suggested by Lorraine A. Welch on July 3, 2019?
  ✅Agreed to update the description as described by Lorraine.
- Removing "VirtualServerName" as mentioned by Dave Williamsonon July 23, 2019?
  ✅Agreed
- Still need a description for ServiceInstanceID, any taker?
  ✅Suggestion: An unique identifier of a newly instantiated network service instance.
  ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
- Any feedback on Kevin Smokowski's comment on August 6, 2019 regarding the use of User-Agent as PartnerName?
- Any feedback on Kevin Smokowski's comment on August 5, 2019 regarding the value of ServerIPAddress in the case of docker & kubernetes deployment?
- Any updates needed for TargetEntity and PartnerName? Mentioned on August 15, 2019 (a conversation between Dave and Kevin)
- Any feedback on composite RequestID or NOT composite RequestID (from October 2, 2019)?

Attendees

Notes

Compliance Report

Where:

Files whose path suggest they're for testing are skipped.
XML is sanitized first:
- To remove XML comments.
- To fix XML that has bad data ahead of <?xml, including a lot of copyright headers. (Java may fare better than Python, but they're technically invalid).
A few documents (properties and XML both) are unparseable for other reasons, so they're reported as such in Notes.
Analysis is pattern-based and fairly superficial:
- There are 300+ files.
- Even within EELF, there's a lot of variation.
- For Logback, EELF is identified by characteristic MDC keys, and compliant logging by telltale MDC serialization, markers and escaping (all of which seem to be non-existent in non-compliant logging).
- For Log4j, likewise, but slightly more forgiving when sniffing for EELF, and there are no instances of compliant logging for Log4J, so nothing to look for.
Summarizing:
- Log provider configuration is in shambles.
- Ad hoc configurations predominate.
- EELF remains ubiquitous.
- Log4j, too, and note the number of Log4j properties files (→ Log4j v1, which does not support escaping, and therefore cannot emit logs that can be reliably indexed).
- Compliant logging:
  - Is rare in component configuration (i.e. inside projects).
  - Is slightly more common in OOM overrides (which generally take precedence where they exist).

Component	File	Provider	Compliant	EELF	Anomaly	Notes
aaf	aaf/cadi/sidecar/fproxy/config/logback-spring.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aaf	aaf/cadi/sidecar/rproxy/config/logback-spring.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/aai-common/aai-core/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/aai-service/ajsc-aai/ajsc-shared-config/etc/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/babel/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/cacher/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/champ/champ-service/bundleconfig-local/etc/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/data-router/bundleconfig-local/etc/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/gizmo/bundleconfig-local/etc/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/graphadmin/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/graphgraph/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/model-loader/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/oom/components/aai-babel/resources/config/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/oom/components/aai-babel/resources/fproxy/config/logback-spring.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/oom/components/aai-babel/resources/rproxy/config/logback-spring.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/oom/components/aai-champ/resources/config/log/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/oom/components/aai-champ/resources/fproxy/config/logback-spring.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/oom/components/aai-champ/resources/rproxy/config/logback-spring.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/oom/components/aai-data-router/resources/config/log/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/oom/components/aai-elasticsearch/resources/config/log4j2.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
aai	aai/oom/components/aai-gizmo/resources/config/log/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/oom/components/aai-gizmo/resources/fproxy/config/logback-spring.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/oom/components/aai-gizmo/resources/rproxy/config/logback-spring.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/oom/components/aai-graphadmin/resources/config/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/oom/components/aai-modelloader/resources/config/log/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/oom/components/aai-resources/resources/config/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/oom/components/aai-resources/resources/fproxy/config/logback-spring.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/oom/components/aai-resources/resources/rproxy/config/logback-spring.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/oom/components/aai-schema-service/config/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/oom/components/aai-search-data/resources/config/log/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/oom/components/aai-search-data/resources/fproxy/config/logback-spring.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/oom/components/aai-search-data/resources/rproxy/config/logback-spring.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/oom/components/aai-spike/resources/config/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/oom/components/aai-traversal/resources/config/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/resources/aai-resources/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/schema-service/aai-schema-service/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/search-data-service/search-data-service-app/bundleconfig-local/etc/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/sparky-be/sparkybe-onap-application/config/logging/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/spike/bundleconfig-local/etc/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/traversal/aai-traversal/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
aai	aai/validation/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
appc	appc/appc-client/client-simulator/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
appc	appc/appc-oam/appc-oam-bundle/src/main/resources/org/onap/appc/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
appc	appc/appc-provider/appc-provider-bundle/src/main/resources/org/onap/appc/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
appc	appc/appc-sdc-listener/appc-sdc-listener-bundle/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
appc	appc/appc-sdc-listener/appc-sdc-listener-bundle/src/main/resources/ci/conf/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
appc	appc/appc-sequence-generator/appc-sequence-generator-bundle/src/main/resources/org.openecomp.appc/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
ccsdk	ccsdk/apps/ms/neng/opt/etc/config/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
ccsdk	ccsdk/cds/ms/blueprintsprocessor/application/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
ccsdk	ccsdk/cds/ms/sdclistener/application/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
ccsdk	ccsdk/dashboard/ccsdk-app-os/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
ccsdk	ccsdk/platform/nbapi/WebContent/WEB-INF/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
ccsdk	ccsdk/platform/nbapi/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
ccsdk	ccsdk/sli/northbound/dmaap-listener/src/main/resources/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
ccsdk	ccsdk/sli/northbound/ueb-listener/src/main/resources/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
cds	oom/kubernetes/cds/charts/cds-blueprints-processor/resources/config/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
cds	oom/kubernetes/cds/charts/cds-sdc-listener/resources/config/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
clamp	clamp/src/main/resources/logback-default.xml	Logback	Y	Y	N
clamp	clamp/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
clamp	oom/kubernetes/clamp/charts/clamp-backend/resources/config/logback.xml	Logback	Y	Y	N
cli	cli/deployment/zip/src/main/release/conf/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
cli	cli/framework/src/main/resources/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
cli	cli/grpc/grpc-client/src/main/resources/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
cli	cli/grpc/grpc-server/src/main/resources/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
dcae	dcae/apod/cdap/cdap3vm/config/cdap-config-template/logback-container.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
dcae	dcae/apod/cdap/cdap3vm/config/cdap-config-template/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
dcae	dcae/apod/cdap/cdap3vm/config/hadoop-cluster-config-template/core_hadoop/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
dcae	dcae/apod/cdap/cdap3vm/config/hadoop-cluster-config-template/hbase/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
dcae	dcae/apod/cdap/cdap3vm/config/hadoop-cluster-config-template/kafka/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
dcae	dcae/apod/cdap/cdap3vm/config/hadoop-cluster-config-template/zookeeper/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
dcae	dcae/collectors/ves/etc/log4j.xml	Log4j	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
dcae	dcae/controller/dcae-controller-core/dcae-controller-platform-server/src/main/server/config/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	Y	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
dcae	dcae/controller/dcae-controller-service-cdap/dcae-controller-service-cdap-adaptor/src/main/server/config/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
dcae	dcae/controller/dcae-controller-service-cdap/dcae-controller-service-cdap-cluster/dcae-controller-service-cdap-cluster-manager/src/main/server/config/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
dcae	dcae/controller/dcae-controller-service-docker/dcae-controller-service-common-docker/dcae-controller-service-common-docker-manager/src/main/server/config/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
dcae	dcae/controller/dcae-controller-service-docker/dcae-controller-service-docker-adaptor/src/main/server/config/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
dcae	dcae/controller/dcae-controller-service-docker/dcae-controller-service-docker-host/dcae-controller-service-docker-host-manager/src/main/server/config/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
dcae	dcae/controller/dcae-controller-service-vm/dcae-controller-service-common-vm/dcae-controller-service-common-vm-manager/src/main/server/config/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
dcae	dcae/controller/dcae-controller-service/dcae-controller-service-dmaap-drsub/dcae-controller-service-dmaap-drsub-manager/src/main/server/config/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
dcae	dcae/controller/dcae-controller-service/dcae-controller-service-standardeventcollector/dcae-controller-service-standardeventcollector-manager/src/main/server/config/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
dcae	dcae/dcae-inventory/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
dcae	dcae/demo/OPENECOMP-DEMO/vm-config/vm-cdap-cluster/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	Y	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
dcae	dcae/demo/OPENECOMP-DEMO/vm-config/vm-controller/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	Y	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
dcae	dcae/demo/OPENECOMP-DEMO/vm-config/vm-docker-host/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	Y	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
dcae	dcae/demo/OPENECOMP-DEMO/vm-config/vm-postgresql/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	Y	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
dcae	dcae/dmaapbc/.metadata/.plugins/org.eclipse.m2e.logback.configuration/logback.1.4.0.20130601-0317.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
dcae	dcae/dmaapbc/src/main/resources/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
dcae	dcae/dmaapbc/src/main/webapp/WEB-INF/log4j.xml	Log4j	N	N	Y	Unparseable: unbound prefix: line 23, column 0.
dcae	dcae/operation/utils/operation-utils/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
dcaegen2	dcaegen2/analytics/pnda/pnda-ztt-app/src/universal/sparkStreaming/PndaZTTApp/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
dcaegen2	dcaegen2/analytics/tca-gen2/dcae-analytics/dcae-analytics-tca-web/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
dcaegen2	dcaegen2/collectors/datafile/datafile-app-server/src/main/resources/logback-spring.xml	Logback	Y	N	N
dcaegen2	dcaegen2/collectors/hv-ves/sources/hv-collector-dcae-app-simulator/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	Y	N	N
dcaegen2	dcaegen2/collectors/hv-ves/sources/hv-collector-kafka-consumer/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	Y	N	N
dcaegen2	dcaegen2/collectors/hv-ves/sources/hv-collector-main/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	Y	N	N
dcaegen2	dcaegen2/collectors/hv-ves/sources/hv-collector-xnf-simulator/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	Y	N	N
dcaegen2	dcaegen2/collectors/restconf/etc/log4j.xml	Log4j	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
dcaegen2	dcaegen2/collectors/ves/src/main/resources/log4j2.xml	Log4j	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
dcaegen2	dcaegen2/platform/inventory-api/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
dcaegen2	dcaegen2/platform/servicechange-handler/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
dcaegen2	dcaegen2/services/components/datalake-handler/feeder/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
dcaegen2	dcaegen2/services/mapper/UniversalVesAdapter/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
dcaegen2	dcaegen2/services/mapper/snmpmapper/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
dcaegen2	dcaegen2/services/pm-mapper/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	Y	N	N
dcaegen2	dcaegen2/services/prh/prh-app-server/src/main/resources/logback-spring.xml	Logback	Y	N	N
dcaegen2	dcaegen2/services/son-handler/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
dmaap	dmaap/buscontroller/dmaap-bc/misc/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
dmaap	dmaap/buscontroller/dmaap-bc/src/main/webapp/WEB-INF/log4j.xml	Log4j	N	N	Y	Unparseable: unbound prefix: line 23, column 0.
dmaap	dmaap/datarouter/datarouter-node/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
dmaap	dmaap/datarouter/datarouter-prov/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
dmaap	dmaap/datarouter/datarouter-prov/src/main/resources/misc/log4j.drroute.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
dmaap	dmaap/datarouter/datarouter-subscriber/src/main/resources/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
dmaap	dmaap/dbcapi/src/main/resources/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
dmaap	dmaap/dbcapi/src/main/webapp/WEB-INF/log4j.xml	Log4j	N	N	Y	Unparseable: unbound prefix: line 23, column 0.
dmaap	dmaap/messagerouter/dmaapclient/src/main/resources/log4j.xml	Log4j	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
dmaap	dmaap/messagerouter/messageservice/ajsc-shared-config/etc/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
dmaap	dmaap/messagerouter/mirroragent/src/main/resources/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties. Unreadable: 'utf-8' codec can't decode byte 0xa9 in position 279: invalid start byte.
dmaap	dmaap/messagerouter/msgrtr/etc/log4j.xml	Log4j	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
dmaap	dmaap/messagerouter/msgrtr/etc/log4j_template.xml	Log4j	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
dmaap	oom/kubernetes/dmaap/components/dmaap-dr-node/resources/config/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
dmaap	oom/kubernetes/dmaap/components/dmaap-dr-prov/resources/config/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
dmaap	oom/kubernetes/dmaap/components/message-router/charts/message-router-kafka/resources/config/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
dmaap	oom/kubernetes/dmaap/components/message-router/resources/config/dmaap/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
ecompsdkos	ecompsdkos/ecomp-sdk/epsdk-app-os/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
esr	oom/kubernetes/esr/charts/esr-server/resources/config/logback.xml	Logback	Y	Y	N
esr	oom/kubernetes/esr/resources/config/log/esrserver/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Unparseable: XML or text declaration not at start of entity: line 18, column 0.
integration	integration/csit/plans/aai/resources/aai-resources/appconfig/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
integration	integration/csit/plans/aai/resources/aai-traversal/appconfig/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
integration	integration/csit/plans/aai/traversal/aai-resources/appconfig/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
integration	integration/csit/plans/aai/traversal/aai-traversal/appconfig/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
integration	integration/csit/scripts/music/music-properties/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
integration	integration/csit/scripts/optf-has/has/music-properties/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
logging-analytics	logging-analytics/pomba/pomba-aai-context-builder/config/logback.xml	Logback	Y	N	N
logging-analytics	logging-analytics/pomba/pomba-context-aggregator/config/logback.xml	Logback	Y	N	N
logging-analytics	logging-analytics/pomba/pomba-network-discovery-context-builder/config/logback.xml	Logback	Y	N	N
logging-analytics	logging-analytics/pomba/pomba-sdc-context-builder/config/logback.xml	Logback	Y	N	N
logging-analytics	logging-analytics/pomba/pomba-sdnc-context-builder/config/logback.xml	Logback	Y	N	N
logging-analytics	logging-analytics/reference/logging-demo/resources/microservice/conf/logback.xml	Logback	Y	N	N
logging-analytics	logging-analytics/reference/logging-demo/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	Y	Y	N
logging-analytics	logging-analytics/reference/logging-kubernetes/logdemonode/charts/logdemonode/resources/config/logback.xml	Logback	Y	Y	N
logging-analytics	logging-analytics/reference/provider/helm/logback/chart/resources/logback.xml	Logback	Y	Y	N
msb	oom/kubernetes/msb/charts/msb-discovery/resources/config/logback.xml	Logback	Y	Y	N
msb	oom/kubernetes/msb/charts/msb-eag/resources/config/log/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Unparseable: no element found: line 28, column 0.
msb	oom/kubernetes/msb/charts/msb-eag/resources/config/logback.xml	Logback	Y	Y	N
msb	oom/kubernetes/msb/charts/msb-iag/resources/config/log/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Unparseable: no element found: line 28, column 0.
msb	oom/kubernetes/msb/charts/msb-iag/resources/config/logback.xml	Logback	Y	Y	N
msb	oom/kubernetes/msb/resources/config/log/discovery/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Unparseable: no element found: line 28, column 0.
msb	oom/kubernetes/msb/resources/config/log/eag/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Unparseable: no element found: line 28, column 0.
msb	oom/kubernetes/msb/resources/config/log/iag/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Unparseable: no element found: line 28, column 0.
mso	mso/bpmn/MSOCommonBPMN/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
mso	mso/bpmn/MSOInfrastructureBPMN/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
mso	mso/mso-config/files/default/mso-api-handler-infra-config/logback.apihandler-infra.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
mso	mso/mso-config/files/default/mso-appc-adapter-config/logback.appc.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
mso	mso/mso-config/files/default/mso-asdc-controller-config/logback.asdc.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
mso	mso/mso-config/files/default/mso-bpmn-config/logback.bpmn.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
mso	mso/mso-config/files/default/mso-po-adapter-config/logback.network.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
mso	mso/mso-config/files/default/mso-po-adapter-config/logback.tenant.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
mso	mso/mso-config/files/default/mso-po-adapter-config/logback.vnf.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
mso	mso/mso-config/files/default/mso-requests-db-adapter-config/logback.msorequestsdbadapter.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
mso	mso/mso-config/files/default/mso-sdnc-adapter-config/logback.sdnc.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
mso	mso/mso-config/files/default/mso-workflow-message-adapter-config/logback.workflow-message-adapter.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
multicloud	multicloud/framework/artifactbroker/packages/src/main/resources/etc/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
music	music/jar/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
music	music/mdbc/mdbc-server/src/main/resources/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
music	music/mdbc/mdbc-server/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
music	music/music-core/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
ncomp	ncomp/cdap/ncomp-cdap-adaptor/src/main/server/config/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
ncomp	ncomp/docker/ncomp-docker-adaptor/src/main/server/config/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
ncomp	ncomp/maven/ncomp-maven-sirius-project/src/main/resources/archetype-resources/src/main/server/config/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
ncomp	ncomp/maven/ncomp-maven-sirius-runtime/src/main/resources/archetype-resources/config/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
oof	oom/kubernetes/oof/charts/oof-cmso/charts/oof-cmso-optimizer/resources/config/logback.xml	Logback	Y	Y	N
oof	oom/kubernetes/oof/charts/oof-cmso/charts/oof-cmso-service/resources/config/logback.xml	Logback	Y	Y	N
oof	oom/kubernetes/oof/charts/oof-cmso/charts/oof-cmso-ticketmgt/resources/config/logback.xml	Logback	Y	Y	N
oof	oom/kubernetes/oof/charts/oof-cmso/charts/oof-cmso-topology/resources/config/logback.xml	Logback	Y	Y	N
optf	optf/cmso/cmso-optimizer/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
optf	optf/cmso/cmso-service/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
optf	optf/cmso/cmso-ticketmgt/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
optf	optf/cmso/cmso-topology/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
optf	optf/fgps/valetapi/kubernetes/org-onap-fgps-dev/resources/config/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
optf	optf/fgps/valetapi/opt/etc/config/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
optf	optf/fgps/valetapi/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
policy	oom/kubernetes/policy/charts/pdp/resources/config/log/xacml-pdp-rest/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
policy	oom/kubernetes/policy/resources/config/log/ep_sdk_app/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
policy	oom/kubernetes/policy/resources/config/log/xacml-pap-rest/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
policy	policy/apex-pdp/core/core-infrastructure/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
policy	policy/apex-pdp/examples/examples-servlet/src/main/resources/webapp/WEB-INF/classes/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
policy	policy/apex-pdp/packages/apex-pdp-package-full/src/main/resources/logback-default.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
policy	policy/apex-pdp/packages/apex-pdp-package-full/src/main/resources/logback-logic.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
policy	policy/apex-pdp/packages/apex-pdp-package-full/src/main/resources/logback-server.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
policy	policy/apex-pdp/packages/apex-pdp-package-full/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
policy	policy/api/packages/policy-api-tarball/src/main/resources/etc/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
policy	policy/common/integrity-audit/src/main/resources/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
policy	policy/common/integrity-audit/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
policy	policy/common/integrity-monitor/src/main/resources/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
policy	policy/common/integrity-monitor/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
policy	policy/distribution/packages/policy-distribution-tarball/src/main/resources/etc/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
policy	policy/drools-applications/controlloop/common/feature-controlloop-amsterdam/src/main/feature/config/logback-include-amsterdam.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
policy	policy/drools-applications/controlloop/common/feature-controlloop-usecases/src/main/feature/config/logback-include-usecases.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
policy	policy/drools-pdp/feature-eelf/src/main/feature/config/logback-eelf.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
policy	policy/drools-pdp/policy-management/src/main/server/config/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
policy	policy/engine/BRMSGateway/src/main/resources/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
policy	policy/engine/BRMSGateway/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
policy	policy/engine/ONAP-PAP-REST/src/main/resources/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
policy	policy/engine/ONAP-PAP-REST/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
policy	policy/engine/ONAP-PDP-REST/src/main/resources/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
policy	policy/engine/ONAP-PDP-REST/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
policy	policy/engine/ONAP-SDK-APP/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
policy	policy/engine/PolicyEngineAPI/src/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
policy	policy/engine/PolicyEngineAPI/src/main/resources/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
policy	policy/engine/PolicyEngineAPI/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
policy	policy/engine/packages/base/src/files/bin/java/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
policy	policy/models/models-sim/models-sim-dmaap/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
policy	policy/models/models-sim/policy-models-sim-pdp/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
policy	policy/pap/packages/policy-pap-tarball/src/main/resources/etc/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
policy	policy/xacml-pdp/packages/policy-xacmlpdp-tarball/src/main/resources/etc/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
pomba	oom/kubernetes/pomba/charts/pomba-aaictxbuilder/resources/config/logback.xml	Logback	Y	N	N
pomba	oom/kubernetes/pomba/charts/pomba-contextaggregator/resources/config/logback.xml	Logback	Y	N	N
pomba	oom/kubernetes/pomba/charts/pomba-networkdiscovery/resources/config/logback.xml	Logback	Y	N	N
pomba	oom/kubernetes/pomba/charts/pomba-networkdiscoveryctxbuilder/resources/config/logback.xml	Logback	Y	N	N
pomba	oom/kubernetes/pomba/charts/pomba-sdcctxbuilder/resources/config/logback.xml	Logback	Y	N	N
pomba	oom/kubernetes/pomba/charts/pomba-sdncctxbuilder/resources/config/logback.xml	Logback	Y	N	N
pomba	oom/kubernetes/pomba/charts/pomba-search-data/resources/config/log/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
pomba	oom/kubernetes/pomba/charts/pomba-servicedecomposition/resources/config/log/logback.xml	Logback	Y	N	N
portal	oom/kubernetes/portal/charts/portal-app/resources/config/deliveries/properties/ONAPPORTAL/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
portal	oom/kubernetes/portal/charts/portal-sdk/resources/config/deliveries/properties/ONAPPORTALSDK/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
portal	portal/deliveries/properties_simpledemo/ONAPPORTAL/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
portal	portal/deliveries/properties_simpledemo/ONAPPORTALSDK/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
portal	portal/ecomp-portal-BE-os/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
portal	portal/ecomp-portal-widget-ms/widget-ms/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
portal	portal/sdk/ecomp-sdk/epsdk-app-os/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
sandbox-vid	sandbox-vid/deliveries/src/main/docker/docker-files/conf.d/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
sandbox-vid	sandbox-vid/deliveries/src/main/docker/docker-files/conf.d/logback_template.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
sandbox-vid	sandbox-vid/vid-automation/conf/log4j2.xml	Log4j	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
sandbox-vid	sandbox-vid/vid-automation/src/main/resources/ci/conf/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
sandbox-vid	sandbox-vid/vid-automation/src/main/resources/log4j2.xml	Log4j	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
sdc	oom/kubernetes/sdc/charts/sdc-be/resources/config/logging/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
sdc	oom/kubernetes/sdc/charts/sdc-dcae-be/resources/config/logging/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
sdc	oom/kubernetes/sdc/charts/sdc-dcae-dt/resources/config/logging/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
sdc	oom/kubernetes/sdc/charts/sdc-dcae-fe/resources/config/logging/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
sdc	oom/kubernetes/sdc/charts/sdc-fe/resources/config/logging/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
sdc	oom/kubernetes/sdc/charts/sdc-onboarding-be/resources/config/logging/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
sdc	sdc/asdctool/src/main/resources/config/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
sdc	sdc/catalog-be/src/main/resources/config/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
sdc	sdc/catalog-fe/src/main/resources/config/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
sdc	sdc/dcae-d/ci/src/main/resources/conf/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
sdc	sdc/dcae-d/dt-be-main/dcaedt_be/src/main/resources/logback-spring.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
sdc	sdc/dcae-d/dt-be-main/dcaedt_catalog/api/src/main/resources/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
sdc	sdc/dcae-d/dt-be-main/dcaedt_catalog/service/src/main/resources/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
sdc	sdc/dcae-d/dt-be-main/docker/docker_be/chef-repo/cookbooks/Deploy-DCAE/files/default/logback-spring.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
sdc	sdc/dcae-d/fe/docker/chef-repo/cookbooks/Deploy-DCAE/files/default/logback-spring.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
sdc	sdc/openecomp-be/dist/sdc-onboard-backend-docker/artifacts/chef-repo/cookbooks/sdc-onboard-backend/files/default/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
sdc	sdc/openecomp-be/dist/sdc-onboard-backend-docker/artifacts/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
sdc	sdc/openecomp-be/lib/openecomp-core-lib/openecomp-config-lib/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
sdc	sdc/openecomp-be/tools/zusammen-tools/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
sdc	sdc/sdc-distribution-client/sdc-distribution-ci/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
sdc	sdc/sdc-distribution-client/sdc-distribution-ci/src/main/resources/ci/conf/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
sdc	sdc/sdc-titan-cassandra/config/cassandra/log4j-empty.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
sdc	sdc/sdc-titan-cassandra/config/cassandra/log4j-server.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
sdc	sdc/sdc-titan-cassandra/config/cassandra/log4j-tools.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
sdc	sdc/sdc-workflow-designer/workflow-designer-be/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
sdc	sdc/ui-ci/src/main/resources/ci/conf/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
sdc	sdc/ui-ci/src/main/resources/log4j2.xml	Log4j	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
sdc	sdc/utils/webseal-simulator/sdc-simulator/chef-repo/cookbooks/sdc-simulator/files/default/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
sdnc	sdnc/apps/pomba/network-discovery/config/logback.xml	Logback	Y	N	N
sdnc	sdnc/apps/pomba/network-discovery/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	Y	N	N
sdnc	sdnc/apps/pomba/service-decomposition/config/logback.xml	Logback	Y	N	N
sdnc	sdnc/features/sdnc_report_api_sdnc_253_story/sdnc_reports_api/src/main/resources/log4j2.xml	Log4j	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
sdnc	sdnc/features/sdnc_report_api_sdnc_253_story/sdnc_reports_service/src/main/resources/log4j2.xml	Log4j	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
sdnc	sdnc/oam/SdncReports/SdncReportsApi/src/main/resources/log4j2.xml	Log4j	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
sdnc	sdnc/oam/configbackuprestore/vnfconfigbackupservice/src/main/resources/log4j2.xml	Log4j	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
sdnc	sdnc/oam/data-migrator/src/main/resources/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
sdnc	sdnc/oam/installation/dmaap-listener/src/main/properties/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
sdnc	sdnc/oam/installation/ueb-listener/src/main/properties/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
so	oom/kubernetes/so/resources/config/log/logback.apihandler-infra.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
so	oom/kubernetes/so/resources/config/log/logback.appc.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
so	oom/kubernetes/so/resources/config/log/logback.asdc.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
so	oom/kubernetes/so/resources/config/log/logback.bpmn.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
so	oom/kubernetes/so/resources/config/log/logback.msorequestsdbadapter.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
so	oom/kubernetes/so/resources/config/log/logback.network.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
so	oom/kubernetes/so/resources/config/log/logback.sdnc.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
so	oom/kubernetes/so/resources/config/log/logback.tenant.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
so	oom/kubernetes/so/resources/config/log/logback.vfc.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
so	oom/kubernetes/so/resources/config/log/logback.vnf.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
so	oom/kubernetes/so/resources/config/log/logback.workflow-message-adapter.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
so	so/deployment-configs/src/main/resources/logger/logback-spring.xml	Logback	Y	Y	N
so	so/logger/logback-spring.xml	Logback	Y	Y	N
so	so/packages/docker/src/main/docker/docker-files/configs/logging/logback-spring.xml	Logback	Y	Y	N
so	so/so-config/files/default/mso-api-handler-infra-config/logback.apihandler-infra.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
so	so/so-config/files/default/mso-appc-adapter-config/logback.appc.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
so	so/so-config/files/default/mso-asdc-controller-config/logback.asdc.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
so	so/so-config/files/default/mso-bpmn-config/logback.bpmn.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
so	so/so-config/files/default/mso-po-adapter-config/logback.network.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
so	so/so-config/files/default/mso-po-adapter-config/logback.tenant.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
so	so/so-config/files/default/mso-po-adapter-config/logback.vfc.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
so	so/so-config/files/default/mso-po-adapter-config/logback.vnf.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
so	so/so-config/files/default/mso-requests-db-adapter-config/logback.msorequestsdbadapter.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
so	so/so-config/files/default/mso-sdnc-adapter-config/logback.sdnc.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
so	so/so-config/files/default/mso-workflow-message-adapter-config/logback.workflow-message-adapter.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
ui	ui/dmaapbc/dcae_dmaapbc_webapp/dbca-os/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	Y	N
vfc	oom/kubernetes/vfc/charts/vfc-huawei-vnfm-driver/resources/config/logging/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
vfc	oom/kubernetes/vfc/charts/vfc-juju-vnfm-driver/resources/config/logging/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
vfc	oom/kubernetes/vfc/charts/vfc-resmgr/resources/config/logging/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
vfc	vfc/nfvo/driver/ems/ems/boco/conf/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties. Unreadable: 'utf-8' codec can't decode byte 0xa0 in position 40: invalid start byte.
vfc	vfc/nfvo/driver/ems/ems/microservice-standalone/src/main/assembly/conf/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties. Unreadable: 'utf-8' codec can't decode byte 0xa0 in position 40: invalid start byte.
vfc	vfc/nfvo/driver/vnfm/gvnfm/juju/juju-vnfmadapter/Juju-vnfmadapterService/service/src/main/resources/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
vfc	vfc/nfvo/driver/vnfm/svnfm/huawei/vnfmadapter/VnfmadapterService/service/src/main/resources/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
vfc	vfc/nfvo/driver/vnfm/svnfm/nokia/vnfmdriver/vfcadaptorservice/vfcadaptor/src/main/resources/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
vfc	vfc/nfvo/multivimproxy/service/src/main/resources/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
vfc	vfc/nfvo/resmanagement/ResmanagementService/service/src/main/resources/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
vid	oom/kubernetes/vid/resources/config/log/vid/logback.xml	Logback	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
vid	vid/vid-automation/conf/log4j2.xml	Log4j	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
vid	vid/vid-automation/src/main/resources/ci/conf/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
vid	vid/vid-automation/src/main/resources/log4j2.xml	Log4j	N	N	Y	Ad hoc.
vnfsdk	vnfsdk/refrepo/vnfmarket-be/vnf-sdk-marketplace/src/main/resources/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.
vnfsdk	vnfsdk/validation/csarvalidation/src/main/resources/log4j.properties	Log4j	N	N	Y	Deprecated: log4j.properties.