661303200

2020 TSC Recordings	2020 TSC Decisions	Anti-Trust Policy

Table of Contents
maxLevel 1

...

Attendance is taken purely upon #info in Zoom Chat

Alla.Goldner	AMDOCS	djhunt	IBM
Andreas Geißler	DT	Lingli Deng	China Mobile
Bin Yang	WindRiver	Murat Turpçu	Turk Telecom
cl664y@att.com	AT&T	Former user (Deleted)	Reliance Jio
Ciaran Johnston	Ericsson	Olivier Phenix	Bell Canada
Davide Cherubini	Vodafone	Ranny Haiby	Samsung
Dong Wang	China Telecom	Seshu Kumar Mudiganti	Huawei
Eric Debeau proxy Morgan Richomme	Orange	Srinivasa Addepalli - proxy:

Yipan

Yipan Deng	Intel
Fernando Oliveira	Verizon		Timo Perala	Nokia

Time (mins)	Agenda Items	Presented By	Presos/Notes/Links/	JIRA Tasks
	Welcome Dong Wang		Congratulations on being confirmed as the new TSC rep for China

60

Telecom
60	Release Status	David McBride	M4 Blocking items Morgan Richomme notes that not all of the HTTP port issues are documented in JIRA Frankfurt Milestone Status

#agreed

- - #AGREED The TSC approves of the following projects for Frankfurt M4: AAI, DCAE, SDNC, VFC, SO, MultiCloud
  - Code coverage task moved to Frankfurt RC0 (March 26)
  - Additional requirement for Sonar migration
- Requirements

AGREED

- - #AGREED The TSC approves
    Jira Legacy
    showSummary false
    server System Jira
    serverId 4733707d-2057-3a0f-ae5e-4fd8aff50176
    key REQ-140
    ,
    Jira Legacy
    showSummary false
    server System Jira
    serverId 4733707d-2057-3a0f-ae5e-4fd8aff50176
    key REQ-37
    ,
    Jira Legacy
    showSummary false
    server System Jira
    serverId 4733707d-2057-3a0f-ae5e-4fd8aff50176
    key REQ-150
    ,
    Jira Legacy
    showSummary false
    server System Jira
    serverId 4733707d-2057-3a0f-ae5e-4fd8aff50176
    key REQ-84
    Jira Legacy
    showSummary false
    server System Jira
    serverId 4733707d-2057-3a0f-ae5e-4fd8aff50176
    key REQ-118
    ,
    Jira Legacy
    showSummary false
    server System Jira
    serverId 4733707d-2057-3a0f-ae5e-4fd8aff50176
    key REQ-129
    ,
    Jira Legacy
    showSummary false
    server System Jira
    serverId 4733707d-2057-3a0f-ae5e-4fd8aff50176
    key REQ-76
    ,
    Jira Legacy
    showSummary false
    server System Jira
    serverId 4733707d-2057-3a0f-ae5e-4fd8aff50176
    key REQ-174
    ,
    Jira Legacy
    showSummary false
    server System Jira
    serverId 4733707d-2057-3a0f-ae5e-4fd8aff50176
    key REQ-215
    ,
    Jira Legacy
    showSummary false
    server System Jira
    serverId 4733707d-2057-3a0f-ae5e-4fd8aff50176
    key REQ-219
    &
    Jira Legacy

server

- - showSummary false
    server System Jira
    serverId 4733707d-2057-3a0f-ae5e-4fd8aff50176
    key REQ-227
    as documented in v572 of the Frankfurt Release Requirements
RC0
- Scheduled for March 26
- relman JIRA tickets published

5

RelEng/Infrastructure

Jessica Gonzalez

Tickets- Open showstoppers:
https://jira.linuxfoundation.org/browse/IT-19212
Tickets- Waiting on Community:
Migration Status / Upcoming Changes
Ubuntu 18.04 available. Email sent to onap mailing lists.

SonarCloud migration
- SonarCloud migration from SonarQube
- https://sonarcloud.io/organizations/onap/projects?coverage=5&sort=coverage

Remember - code coverage criteria i.e. 55% AND migration to SonarCloud must be completed by RC0

5

PTL

Subcommittee Update

Security

Update on release management task "Address all security issues"
- SECCOM and PTLs agreed on compromise at March 9 PTL meeting
  - Best effort on OJSI tickets for Frankfurt, except for
    Jira Legacy
    showSummary false
    server System Jira
    columns key,summary,type,created,updated,due,assignee,reporter,priority,status,resolution
    serverId 4733707d-2057-3a0f-ae5e-4fd8aff50176
    key REQ-231
  - REQ-231 is mandatory with some exceptions
    - Projects not participating in Frankfurt
    - Projects impacted by AAF
    - Non-ONAP components
    - Additional exceptions considered on a case-by-case basis

VOTE: Does the TSC approve the changes to the release management task, "address all security issues" as described above?

10

Subcommittee Update

Architecture

Rescheduled to 3/19

Chaker Al-Hakim

Documentation Prototype review

Arch review policy and process

VOTE: Does the TSC approve the architectural review policy and process documented above.

30

El Alto Retrospective

Action Plan

Rescheduled to 3/19

David McBride

El Alto Retrospective Results (move to next week's meeting)

Detailed results
Summary of El Alto retrospective top three priorities
1. Integration tests in target deployments using OOM.
2. Improve robot healthcheck across projects.
3. More projects added to CI pipeline and more project-specific testing.

5

Documentation Hackathon results + Wiki Migration Status

Rescheduled to 3/19

Andreas Geißler Sofia Wallin

see: 2020 March 11th Documentation Hackathon

5

TSC Activities and Deadlines

cl664y@att.com

Review 2020 Mentor Projects

TSC Task Force - Cloud Native

Initial Feedback
Request ONAP Subcommittees to identify 1 representative to join the ONAP CNF Task Force - Please send an e-mail to Kenny and David
- List of volunteers

5

Upcoming Events

Kenny Paul

ONAP Documentation hackathon - March 25th
- Please add your topic to the planning page
LFN Technical Meetings - Virtual Event
- Discussed at length at the TSC meeting yesterday
- ONAP input to TAC: 3 hours per day, for 3 days, held between 13:00 UTC and 16:100 UTC April 21-23
- Need 2-3 volunteers to to be on a LFN Joint Planning Committe

F2F Events (depending on

COVI

COVID-19 evolution):

LFN Developer and Testing Forum on June 1-4, 2020 - TBD may be a Virtual Event
ONAP 2 day event after ONS North Europe - Antwerp (TBD)
Survey will be sent from LFN for Dec OR Jan for steady-state full DDF meetings to all LFN communities & location

Action Items

Scott Blandford sync up with Eric Debeau 12 Mar 2020
action items to be added

Zoom Chat Log

...

on
Jira Legacy
server System Jira
columns key,summary,type,created,updated,due,assignee,reporter,priority,status,resolution
serverId 4733707d-2057-3a0f-ae5e-4fd8aff50176
key REQ-150
12 Mar 2020

Zoom Chat Log

From Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone: (06:57 51 AM)
 #info Fred Oliveira, Verizon #topic rollcall 
From Dong Wang Davide (China TelecomVodafone) to Everyone: (06:58 56 AM)
 #info Dong Wang, China Telecom 
From bin.yang@windriver.com #info Davide Cherubini, Vodafone 
From Catherine Lefèvre (ONAP) to Everyone: (06:58 57 AM)
 #info Bin Yang, Wind River 
From Murat Turpcu,Turk Telekom #Catherine Lefevre, AT&T 
From Fernando (Fred) Oliveira to Everyone: (06:59 57 AM)
 #info Murat TURPCU, Türk Telekom 
From Timo Perala (Nokia#info Fred Oliveira, Verizon 
From Dong Wang (China Telecom) to Everyone: (0706:00 58 AM)
 #info Timo Perala, Nokia 
From ALLAGO Dong Wang, China Telecom 
From bin.yang@windriver.com to Everyone: (0706:01 58 AM)
 #info Alla Goldner, Amdocs 
From Andreas Geissler #info Bin Yang, Wind River 
From Murat Turpcu,Turk Telekom to Everyone: (0706:01 59 AM)
 #info Andreas Geissler, DT #info Murat TURPCU, Türk Telekom 
From Morgan (Proxy Eric (Orange)) Timo Perala (Nokia) to Everyone: (07:01 AM)
 #info 00 AM) #info Timo Perala, Nokia 

07:01:13 From ALLAGO : #info Alla Goldner, Amdocs
07:01:25 From Andreas Geissler : #info Andreas Geissler, DT
07:01:27 From Morgan (Proxy Eric (Orange)) : #info Morgan Richomme, Orange (Proxy Eric Debeau) 
07:01:27 From Olivier Phenix (Bell Canada) to Everyone: (07:01 AM)
 #info : #info Olivier Phenix, Bell Canada Canada
07:01:57 From Ranny Haiby (Samsung) to Everyone: (07:01 AM)
 #info : #info Ranny Haiby, Samsung Samsung
07:02:33 From Yipan Deng (Intel) to Everyone: (07:02 AM)
 #info : #info proxy Yipan Deng, Intel Corp. (Proxy for Srinivasa Addepalli) 
07:02:39 From Ciaran Johnston to Everyone: (07:02 AM)
 #info Ciaran Johnston, Ericsson 
: #info Ciaran Johnston, Ericsson
07:02:40 From Jason Hunt to Everyone: (07:02 AM)
 #info : #info Jason Hunt, IBM 
From Me to Everyone: (IBM
07:08 AM)
 Kenny’s :10 From Hosty McHostface : Kenny’s machine crashed. rebooting now. 
07:16:16 From David McBride to Everyone: (07:16 AM)
 #vote Does the TSC approve the : #vote Does the TSC approve the changes to the release management task, "address all security issues" as described above? (+1, 0, -1) 
07:16:24 From bin.yang@windriver.com to Everyone: ( : #vote +1
07:16 AM)
 #vote +1 
:26 From Seshu m s71826 to Everyone : (+1
07:16 AM)
 +1 
:28 From Andreas Geissler to Everyone: (: #vote +1
07:16 AM)
 #vote +1 
From :29 From Jason Hunt to Everyone: (: #vote +1
07:16 AM)
 #vote +1 
:31 From Fernando (Fred) Oliveira (Verizon) to Everyone: (: #vote +1
07:16 AM)
 #vote +1 
:32 From Ranny Haiby (Samsung) to Everyone: (: #vote +1
07:16 AM)
 #vote +1 
:33 From Yipan Deng (Intel) to Everyone: (: #vote +1
07:16 AM)
 #vote +1 
:34 From Davide (Vodafone) to Everyone: (: #vote +1
07:16 AM)
 #vote +1 
:38 From Dong Wang (China Telecom) to Everyone: (: #vote +1
07:16 AM)
 #vote +1 
:41 From Murat Turpcu,Turk Telekom to Everyone: (: #vote +1
07:16 AM)
 #vote +1 
:41 From Olivier Phenix (Bell Canada) to Everyone: (: #vote +1
07:16 AM)
 #vote +1 
:42 From Timo Perala (Nokia) to Everyone: (: #vote +1
07:16 AM)
 #vote +1 
:46 From Ciaran Johnston to Everyone: (: #vote +1
07:16 AM)
 #vote +1 
:47 From Seshu m s71826 to Everyone: (: #vote +1
07:16 AM)
 #vote +1 
From Morgan :51 From Morgan (Proxy Eric (Orange)) to Everyone: (: #vote +1
07:16 AM)
 #vote +1 
17:16 From Catherine Lefèvre (ONAP) to Everyone: (: #vote +1
07:17 AM)
 #vote +1 
:40 From David McBride to Everyone : (#endvote
07:17 AM)
 #endvote 
:41 From Catherine Lefèvre (ONAP) to Everyone: (07:17 AM)
 #APPROVED : #APPROVED BY TSC (15) 
07:20:17 From Taka Cho to Everyone: (07:20 AM)
 I : I think APPC passed M4 M4
07:20:55 From Daniel Timoney to Everyone: (07:20 AM)
 I : I believe CCSDK also passed M4 M4
07:24:04 From bin.yang@windriver.com to Everyone: (07:24 AM)
 I : I think MultiCloud is ready to pass M4, the jira https://jira.onap.org/browse/MULTICLOUD-984 is fixed already already
07:25:52 From David McBride to Everyone: (07:25 AM)
 The : The TSC approves of the following projects for Frankfurt M4: AAI, DCAE, SDNC, VFC, SO #agree SO
07:26:26 From David McBride : #agree The TSC approves of the following projects for Frankfurt M4: AAI, DCAE, SDNC, VFC, SO 
SO
07:30:24 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #topics requirements
07:32:49 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : -REQ-140 yellow
07:33:20 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : @Damian expects open issues to be closed before RC0
07:35:54 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : Concerns regarding testing time if delivered in 2 weeks
07:38:11 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : -REQ-37
07:38:23 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : yellow
07:38:38 From Morgan (Proxy Eric (Orange)) : @David & Catherine, last M4 JIRA just closed for Integration
07:39:01 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : @Seshu content at provided will be part of Frankfurt
07:39:40 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : -REQ-150 yellow
07:41:29 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : @Scott B - input has been provided, but has not been documented.
07:41:59 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : Request from @Eric is for a control-loop tutorial
07:43:14 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #ACTION @Scott B sync with @Eric on status- provide update to TSC
07:45:05 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : -REQ-267 - M4 scorecard status not provided - recommend descoped
07:47:31 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : @Timo will try to get feedback on REQ-267 by EOD.
07:47:48 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : -REQ-84 yellow
07:48:01 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : scope has been narrowed
07:49:53 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : -REQ-118 -recommend for approval
07:50:05 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : -REQ-129 yellow
07:51:17 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : scope has been reduced - recommended for approval
07:51:58 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : -REQ-76 yellow - recommended for approval
07:53:34 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : -REQ-64 no feedback for M4 -is a TSC must have
07:54:08 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : @Chris M to follow up w/ @manoop by EOD
07:55:00 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : @Krzyztof will provide recommendation by EOD
07:55:47 From Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone: (07:30 AM)
 #topics requirements -REQ-140 yellow @Damian expects open issues to be closed before RC0 
: #ACTION ^^^ 2 lines above
07:56:08 From Catherine Lefèvre (ONAP) : thanks@Bin
07:56:22 From Catherine Lefèvre (ONAP) : checking now
07:56:55 From Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone: (07 : 35 AM)
 Concerns regarding testing time if delivered in 2 weeks  -REQ-37 yellow 
From Morgan (Proxy Eric (Orange)) to Everyone: (07:38 AM)
 @David & Catherine, last M4 JIRA just closed for Integration 
174 yellow recommend approval
07:57:21 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : -REQ-178 yellow
07:59:15 From Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone: (07:39 AM)
 @Seshu content at provided will be part of Frankfurt -REQ-150 yellow @Scott B - input has been provided, but has not been documented. Request from @Eric is for a control-loop tutorial 
From Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone: (07:43 AM)
 #ACTION @Scott B sync with @Eric on status- provide update to TSC -REQ-267 - M4 scorecard status not provided - recommend descoped @Timo will try to get feedback on REQ-267 by EOD. -REQ-84 yellow scope has been narrowed 
: #ACTION @David M contact @Kirian & @Ritu by EOD
07:59:19 From Catherine Lefèvre (ONAP) : @Bin - Multicloud Green for M4
08:00:27 From bin.yang@windriver.com : Thanks @Catherine
08:01:31 From Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone: (07 : 49 AM)
 -REQ-118 -recommend for approval -REQ-129 yellow scope has been reduced - recommended for approval  -REQ-76 yellow 215, REQ-219 recommended for approval -REQ-64 no feedback for M4 -is a TSC must have @Chris M to follow up w/ @manoop by EOD 
approval
08:01:53 From Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone: (07:55 AM)
 @Krzyztof will provide recommendation by EOD #ACTION ^^^ 2 lines above 
From Catherine Lefèvre (ONAP) to Everyone: (07:56 AM)
 thanks@Bin checking now 
: -REQ-223 red
08:03:15 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #ACTION @Tony to edit description for 223
08:04:13 From Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone: (07:56 AM)
 -REQ-174 yellow recommend approval -REQ-178 yellow #ACTION @David M contact @Kirian & @Ritu by EOD 
From Catherine Lefèvre (ONAP) to Everyone: (07:59 AM)
 @Bin - Multicloud Green for M4 
From bin.yang@windriver.com to Everyone: (08:00 AM)
 Thanks @Catherine 
: recommend continuing discussion @ PTL meerting
08:04:28 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : -REQ-229
08:04:48 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : scratch ^^^^
08:05:33 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : REQ-227 recommend approval
08:06:00 From Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone: (08 : 01 AM)
 -REQ-215, REQ-219 recommended for approval -REQ-223 red #ACTION @Tony to edit description for 223 recommend continuing discussion @ PTL meerting -REQ-229 
-REQ-231 yellow
08:07:05 From Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone : (08:04 AM)
 scratch ^^^^ REQ-227 recommend approval  -REQ-231 yellow -REQ-239 pending pending
08:07:56 From Jason Hunt to Everyone: (08:07 AM)
 I : I have to drop from audio… can take chat messages (sorry!) 
08:08:39 From Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone: (08 : 08 AM)
  -Document current upgrade component strategy - recommended for approval approval
08:10:41 From Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone: (08:10 AM)
 #vote : #vote Does the TSC approve REQ-140, REQ-37, REQ-150, REQ-84, REQ-118, REQ-129, REQ-76, REQ-174, REQ-215, REQ-219, REQ-227 as documented in v572 of the Frankfurt Release Requirements page as approved? +1, 0, -1 1
08:11:38 From Seshu m s71826 to Everyone: (: #vote +1
08:11 AM)
 #vote +1 
:45 From ALLAGO to Everyone: (: #vote +1
08:11 AM)
 #vote +1 
:46 From Ranny Haiby (Samsung) to Everyone: (: #vote +1
08:11 AM)
 #vote +1 
:48 From Andreas Geissler to Everyone: (: #vote +1
08:11 AM)
 #vote +1 
:49 From Davide (Vodafone) to Everyone: (: #vote +1
08:11 AM)
 #vote +1 
:50 From Dong Wang (China Telecom) to Everyone: (: #vote +1
08:11 AM)
 #vote +1 
:51 From Fernando (Fred) Oliveira (Verizon) to Everyone: (: #vote +1
08:11 AM)
 #vote +1 
:52 From Olivier Phenix (Bell Canada) to Everyone: (: #vote +1
08:11 AM)
 #vote +1 
:53 From Murat Turpcu,Turk Telekom to Everyone: (: #vote +1
08:11 AM)
 #vote +1 
:54 From Timo Perala (Nokia) to Everyone: (08:11 AM)
 #vote +1 
: #vote +1
08:11:56 From Yipan Deng (Intel) to Everyone: (08:11 AM)
 #vote +1 
: #vote +1
08:12:01 From Catherine Lefèvre (ONAP) to Everyone: (: #vote #+1
08:12 AM)
 #vote #+1 
:08 From Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone : (#endvote
08:12 AM)
 #endvote 
:11 From Morgan (Proxy Eric (Orange)) to Everyone: (: #vote +1
08:12 AM)
 #vote +1 
:19 From Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone : (#AGREED ^^^
08:12 AM)
 #AGREED ^^^ 
:20 From Morgan (Proxy Eric (Orange)) to Everyone: (: sorry too slow
08:12 AM)
 sorry too slow 
:44 From Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone: (08:12 AM)
 #AGREED : #AGREED TSC descopes REQ-267 from the Frankfurt release ^^^NOT AGREED still pending 
release
08:13:54 From Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone: (: ^^^NOT AGREED still pending
08:15 AM)
 Pending :02 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : Pending REQ-64, REQ-178, REQ-223, REQ-239, REQ-267 #topic mentorship Modeling267
08:16:15 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #topic mentorship
08:17:53 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : Modeling/etsicatalog change spec to 2.7.1 from 2.5.1 
1
08:20:59 From Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone: (08:20 AM)
 #AGREED : #AGREED approved with above change and recommended alignment with the CNF task force ETSI force
08:21:40 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : ETSI NFV APIs conformance test for OVP OVP
08:22:04 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : https://wiki.lfnetworking.org/pages/viewpage.action?pageId=33423631 #AGREED
08:23:09 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #AGREED approved as written written
08:26:52 From Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone: (08:26 AM)
 ONAP : ONAP Automation Testing - Portal/SDC SDC
08:27:00 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : https://wiki.lfnetworking.org/pages/viewpage.action?pageId=34603195 ONAP Security Requirements - Portal/SDC 
08:27:34 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : ONAP Security Requirements - Portal/SDC
08:27:42 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : https://wiki.lfnetworking.org/pages/viewpage.action?pageId=34603193 
08:31:03 From Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone: (08:31 AM)
 link : link to portal has been moved to RTD - needs to be changed ^^^^ ONAP Automation Testing - Portal/SDC ald changed
08:32:38 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : ^^^^ ONAP Automation Testing - Portal/SDC
08:33:22 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : ald @ PAM policy gui is changing. recommend removing the bullet correction bullet
08:34:27 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : correction architecture link back to wiki - not migrated yet #ACTION yet
08:35:08 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #ACTION Kenny send out for evote evote
08:36:14 From Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone: (08:36 AM)
 #TSC : #TSC ENDS 

Versions Compared

Old Version 17

New Version Current

Key

BRIDGE: https://zoom.us/j/661303200

Table of Contents
maxLevel 1

Agenda Items

Release Status

RelEng/Infrastructure

SonarCloud migration

Subcommittee Update

Subcommittee Update

El Alto Retrospective

Documentation Hackathon results + Wiki Migration Status

TSC Activities and Deadlines

Upcoming Events

Zoom Chat Log

Zoom Chat Log

Page Comparison

Versions Compared

Old Version 17

New Version Current

Key

Table of ContentsmaxLevel1

Agenda Items

Release Status

RelEng/Infrastructure

SonarCloud migration

Subcommittee Update

Subcommittee Update

El Alto Retrospective

Documentation Hackathon results + Wiki Migration Status

TSC Activities and Deadlines

Upcoming Events

Zoom Chat Log

Zoom Chat Log

Table of Contents
maxLevel 1