Zoom bridge: https://zoom.us/j/283628617
PTL Recordings
AntiTrust Message

Agenda

START RECORDING

Duration	Agenda Item	Requested by	Notes / Links
1 hour	Cross-project discussions		Java 11 and Alpine versioning proposal for Frankfurt Amy Zwarico Recommendation from SECCOM Java 11.05 Alpine 3.10.3 SECCOM requesting feedback from PTLs Pre-built image recommendation vs JDK v recommendation? Java 11 transition Note that projects with ODL dependencies must remain at Java 8 for Frankfurt. ODL Sodium (Feb/Mar) supports Java 11. Dependency on oparent oParent is led by the Integration Team Current version 2.2.0-Snapshot and 2.1.0-released) Java 8 projects use the 2.X version Java 11 projets use the 3.X version JBB Jobs support Java 11 Moving to Java 11: 2.x ==> 3.x Not on 2.x: 1.x ==> 2.x Staying on 2.x: 2.x ==> 2.2+ (likely)
	LF IT Support		https://jira.linuxfoundation.org/servicedesk/customer/portal/2/IT-18172 via Pamela Dragosh(Related to CSIT problems) Problem is understood now. ETA based on Jessica's availability over the next week or two. Morgan Richomme - did you send an email notification to warn community about Dec 3 deletion of disabled Jenkins jobs? Email sent last week. Jessica Gonzalez : pylint implementation in all the projects as an informational tool (similar to checkstyle for JAVA) for the PTLs/Committers about the quality of submitted code.It will be part of the verify Jenkins job but it will not return verify -1 by default except if PTL will raise the request to block the code. No action for the TSC. Maturity dashboard issue: Jessica Gonzalez to send a note to onap-release, onap-tsc mailing list to provide guidelines in order to avoid this behavior in the future (not discard update?)- problem captured as IT-18144 Ticket closed IT-18078 integration/xtesting Jessica says e-mail sent to TSC mailing list. Waiting for TSC approval. ACTION: Kenny to review issue and determine need for TSC vote. ACTION: David to follow up with Kenny. Do we need to add this to the TSC agenda? IT-17739/RELENG-2422 - new open ticket to address the template changes for docker tagging. Its pending on LF update. Waiting for feedback from Vijay RELENG-2517 -ONAP JIRA has invalid resolution type resulting in confusing behavior - OJessica Gonzalez to send a note to onap-release, onap-tsc mailing list about this limitation? Need TSC approval to move forward. SONAR Threshold - "Passed" Threshold will be set to 55% and "Warning" Threshold will be set to 50% Completed Note that current version of SONAR no longer includes "warning" parameter Recommendation is to move to SONAR cloud Discuss upgrade in TSC meeting IT-17899 - APPC code coverage down from 80% to 5% (with sonar cloud migration) Still investigating Possibly related to using older version of Sonar SUPPORT-690 : Integration with gitlab Roadmap for support has been created Should we move to one mailing list per project? https://www.surveymonkey.com/r/53WFQD9
	Testing Environment	Morgan Richomme	Any update?
	Sharing Best Practices		El-Alto Retrospective - please submit your feedback by Nov 15th - these will be reviewed during the PTL Call on 11/18. Krzysztof Opasiak - did you setup separate meetings with MSB, Logging, and CLI projects (In that order) to discuss security maturity and open OJSI tickets? cl664y@att.com - The invitation has been sent to MSB PTL waiting for response. Aiming to have a call somewhere between 12 and 15 of November
IF TIME ALLOWS ....
20 min	Release status	David McBride Paweł Pawlak djhunt Alla.Goldner Stephen terrill Hui Deng Andy Mayer Pamela Dragosh	El Alto - final cleanup OOM tagging - is this done? (Jessica Gonzalez, Brian Freeman, Mike Elliott) Any other issues? Frankfurt M1 Status Python 3 / Java 11 status Schedule review
10 mins	Remaining Action Items	Former user (Deleted)	PTL Weekly ONAP12, Mon UTC 13:00
10 mins	AAF and Service Mesh Support	Mike Elliott	M3 Security Checklist item to ensure AAF integration can be enabled/disabled Consistent Helm Chart configuration value supporting AAF and Service Mesh: OOM-1986 - Getting issue details... STATUS
	Incoming Events	Kenny Paul	PTL call is now planned @3pm CET, 9am EST, 6am PST, 8am CST, 10pm China Time, 7.30pm Indian Time TSC Election - Ballots distributed. Voting ends Nov 19, 22:00 UTC ONAP/CNTT F2F Event in January 13-16th, 2020 - Prague - Registration https://events19.linuxfoundation.org/events/lf-networking-ddf-plugfest-2020/ ONAP 2 day event before or after ONES North America (April 20&21) - Los Angeles (TBC) ONAP DDF planned in June - under planning ONAP 2 day event before or after ONS North Europe - Antwerp (TBC) Survey coming from LFN for Dec OR Jan for steady-state full DDF meetings to all LFN communities & locations TSC Meetings will be canceled on Nov 28th, Dec 25th, 2019 and Jan 1st, 2020 Linux Foundation office holiday closures Nov. 28th & 29th Dec. 23rd through Jan 3rd, 2020 - Shall we cancel PTL calls on 12/3 and 12/30?

Zoom Chat Log

06:10:46 From Jonathan Gathman : FROM openjdk:12-jdk-alpine
06:12:53 From Adrian O'Sullivan : in NBI we had used openjdk:11-jre-slim in El Alto
06:13:49 From Jonathan Gathman : I couldn’t get that pulled down anymore.
06:14:03 From Vijay Venkatesh Kumar (AT&T) : https://lf-onap.atlassian.net/wiki/display/DW/CIA-+Container+Images+-+Best+Practices+and+Tools
06:14:03 From Jonathan Gathman : If someone else is able, that’s great.
06:17:15 From Vijay Venkatesh Kumar (AT&T) : Recommended base image from CIA team -https://wiki.onap.org/display/DW/ONAP+Normative+container+base+images. This is based on Dublin; need to be relooked by CIA team.
06:24:12 From Morgan Richomme : @Adrian do you use oparent in NBI? (as the version supported Java 11 has not been released yet..)
06:25:06 From Mike Elliott : Unfortunately need to drop temporarily. Will rejoin call in 35 minutes (top of hour).
06:25:42 From Adrian O'Sullivan : we use oparent 2.1.0 in the NBI pom
06:27:58 From Morgan Richomme : @adrian and you did not get any dependency issues using the jre11 for el alto (2.1.0 is related to Java 8)
06:29:27 From Adrian O'Sullivan : @morgan No issues that I know of
06:46:30 From Dan Timoney : At some point on this call, I’d like to confirm the process for requesting a new repo. I sent an approval request to infrastructure-coordinator@onap.org 2 weeks ago and and still haven’t gotten a response

Action Items

Amy Zwarico- recommend pre-built image instead of JDK version. Also consider Java 12+ vs. Java 11.
David McBride - follow up with Kenny regarding 18078 and infra coordinator. Add to TSC agenda.
Jessica Gonzalez - send email regarding SONAR