Scaling Meeting Minutes (Dublin)

Owned by Scott Blandford
Last updated: May 17, 2019Version comment
5 min read

May 28, 2019

Agenda

Recording

Attendees

Discussion

Action Items

May 21, 2019

Agenda

Recording

Attendees

Discussion

Action Items

May 14, 2019

Agenda

  1. Testing Status

  2. Update Scale Out Workflow

Recording

Attendees

Scott Blandford, Marco Platania, Pramod Jamkhedkar, Martial Ngueko, Lauren Lewis, Mehmet Toy, Pam Dragosh

Discussion

Action Items

Scott to clean up testing status
Scott to add Scaling 508,509 to CL Design time.
Add Scaling 503 to CL
Update Run time test cases
Remove call to APPC from Policy in Run time.

May 7, 2019

Agenda

  1. Testing Status

Recording

ONAP Scaling 190507.mp4

Attendees

Scott Blandford, Marco Platania, Martial Ngueko, Lauren Lewis, Pramod Jamkhedkar

Discussion

  • AAI issue is now fixed all information is in the response and formatted correctly

  • Policy is still not using the correct TOSCA Parser. Everyone else is. This is not a showstopper for Scaling

  • Lots of little problems but no showstoppers at this time

  • Lauren will update Flow diagrams with CDS information

  • There are a couple CDS issues with naming policy

  • Only a couple weeks left for testing.

  • A lot of work needs to be done over the next 2 weeks

Action Items

April 30, 2019

Agenda

  1. Development Status

  2. Testing Status

Recording

ONAP Scaling 190430.mp4

Attendees

Scott Blandford, Marco Platania, Promod Jamkhedkar, Lauren Lewis, Yuriy Malakov

Discussion

  • Met last Friday with DCAE, CLAMP and Policy to design a closed loop

  • Could not run an end to end test

  • Could run some separate pieces

    • Could create policies using new API

    • Could not deploy an operational Policy

    • May be able to parse CSAR files now

Action Items

April 23, 2019

Cancelled

Agenda

Recording

Attendees

Discussion

Action Items

April 16, 2019

Agenda

  1. M4 Status

  2. Testing Status

  3. Clamp Policy issue

  4. Dublin Risk Status 

Recording

ONAP Scaling 190416.mp4

Attendees

Scott Blandford, Marco Platania, Pramod, Jamkhedkar, Lauren Lewis, Martial Ngueko, Pam Dragosh, Vamshi Krisna, Jimmy Forsyth 

Discussion

  • M4 is today (4/16/19) All code has been submitted, reviewed and committed. Scaling will pass M4

  • Integration Testing will begin next week

  • There is an unforeseen issue with the information passed between CLAMP and Policy that makes it so Policy does not have all the data required to call SO.

  • There are a couple options available

    • Get more information from the CSAR including the VNF and Service metadata

    • Get data from AAI query: This has 2 options

      • Go back to using Named Query since it contains the required data

      • Get a fix on the new Custom Query since it is not passing on the "Extra Properties" that existed in the Named Query

    • Jimmy says he will look into fixing the Custom Query since it should be an 1 for 1 replacement of the Named Query 

  • The Risk highlighted in "Dublin Risks" no longer exists since we can now do instantiation.

Action Items 

 Jimmy to determine if AAI can fix Custom Query
Scott to update Dublin Risks page

April 9, 2019

Agenda

  1. Development Status

  2. M4 Readiness

  3. Review and Validate Flow Diagrams

  4. El Alto Planning 

Recording

Attendees

Scott Blandford, Marco Platania, Pramod Jamkedkar, Lauren Lewis, Yuriy Malakov, Mehmet Toy, Sebastien Determe, Martial Ngueko 

Discussion

  • Policy Code to call and parse Named Query needs Code Review

  • Need to get Tech Mahindra Status

  • SO instantiation still not working 

Action Items 



April 2, 2019

Meeting was cancelled due to F2F meeting in San Jose



March 26, 2019

Agenda

  1. Development Status - progress towards M4

  2. Issues preventing the application from getting to M4

  3. Brainstorm on El Alto Project Proposals

Recording

ONAP Scaling 190326

Attendees

Marco Platania (AT&T)

Pramod Jamkhedkar (AT&T)

Yuriy Malakov (AT&T)

Mehmet Toy (Verizon)

Lauren Lewis (AT&T)

Lathish

Discussion

  1.  Progress

  2.  

    1. Policy - Was able to get information from A&AI

    2. Policy - Ability to explore the tree of the Service Instance in different ways.  

    3. CDS Template/naming generation progress however meeting is required this week to finalize

    4. Issues with installing ONAP - Not sure if the issues are related to Cassandra or password issues

  3. ONAP 2019 Joint Subcommittee Meeting Silicon Valley link , 2019 Silicon Valley Meeting Proposals  

  4. Discussed the Proposed El Alto Use Cases

Action Items

  1. Meeting will be held to finalize the Name Generation and Package creation  - Yuriy M.



March 19, 2019

Agenda

  1. Development Status

  2. Review and Validate Flow Diagrams

  3. El Alto Planning 

Recording

Attendees

Scott Blandford, Marco Platania, Promod Jamkhedkar, Pam Dragosh, Yuriy Malakov, Lauren Lewis 

Discussion

  • Discussed Detailed status if Custom Query implementation within Policy

  • El Alto Planning 

    • Scaling

      • Multiple VNF Configuration (Discuss with Change Mgmt Team)

      • Overall Locking Mechanism Strategy (Discuss with Arch team)

      • Use CDS for VNF Configuration

      • Homing and Capacity Check

    • Closed Loop

      • TOSCA Policy Models

      • Control Loops for PNFs

      • Self Serve for Closed Loops

Action Items

Raise a Dublin Risk for not being able to instantiate a VNF and therefore populate AAI
Get Status from Tech Mahindra
Talk to Arch Comm about a Locking Strategy  

March 12, 2019

Agenda

  1. Development Status

  2. Review and Validate Flow Diagrams

  3. Use Case Tracking 

Recording

Attendees

Scott Blandford, Marco Platania, Pam Dragosh, Promod Jamkhedkar, Lauren Lewis, Mehmet Toy 

Discussion

  • AAI is not populated so Custom Query of DB is not working

    •  SO is blocking VNF Instantiation

  • Maybe raise a risk against SO if they do not pass M3 on Thursday 

Action Items



March 5, 2019

Agenda

  1. Development Status

  2. Review and Validate Flow Diagrams

  3. Use Case Tracking 

Recording

ONAP Scaling 190305.mp4

Attendees

Scott Blandford, Thamlur Raju, Marco Platania, Yuriy Malakov, Lathish, Pam Dragosh, Lauren Lewis, Joss Armstrong, Nathalie Labidurie, Pramod Jamkhedkar, Vivian Ye 

Discussion

  • Detailed discussion on Flow Charts 

Action Items

February 26, 2019

Agenda

  1. Use Case Tracking

  2. Continuation of CDS discussion

  3. Review and Validate Flow Diagrams 

Recording

ONAP Scaling 190226.mp4

Attendees

Scott Blandford, Manamohan, Jim Baker, Marco Platania, Martial Ngueko, Pam Dragosh, Rodrigo Ottero, Vijay VK, Lauren Lewis, Pramod Jamkhedkar, Yuriy Malakov, Joss Armstrong, Vivian Ye, Alexis de Talhouet, kredell, lathish, Randa Maher, Ben Chueng 

Discussion

  • We should be able to use CDS for instantiation today, No development work, just design time changes

  •  CDS is working with SO

  • SO work is being done in Dublin

  • Configuration will require development work

Action Items

Set up meeting with Tech Mahindra for status
update Closed Loop status with JIRA stories
Set up a meeting with CDS team to find out exactly how it will be used in Dublin  



February 19, 2019

Agenda

  1. M2 Readiness

  2. CDS Use for naming VF_Modules

  3. Development Tracking 

Recording

ONAP Scaling 190219

Attendees

Scott Blandford, Lathish, Pam Dragosh, Marco Platania, Jacques Bolduc, Martial Ngueko, Yuriy Malakov, Joss Armstrong, Johnathan Gathman, Milind Jalwadi, Sebastien Determe, Alok Gupta, Margaret Chiosi, Randa Maher, Honor 10, Ben Cheung 

Discussion

 Action Items

Marco to send Jimmy and Email about AAI Jira Story 
Scott: set up a follow on naming call for Marco, Milind, Yuriy, and Lauren
Send Milind the call details for the closed loop call.



February 12, 2019

Agenda

  1. Marco's Document

  2. Onboarding Policies, mS, Normatives 

Recording

ONAP Scaling 190212.mp4

Attendees

Scott Blandford, Marco Platania, Lauren lewis, Adam Krysiak, Joss Armstrong, Lathish, Martial Ngueko, Milind Jalwadi, Prmod Jamkedkar, Vijay VK, Mehmet Toy, Pam Dragosh 

Discussion

  • Configuration Policy changes in CLAMP will be  done in Dublin

  • Operational policy changes in CLAMP are aspirational and will not be completed in Dublin

Action Items

Invite SDC to Closed Loop meeting on Wednesday
Add agenda items to Closed Loop agenda for Wednesday  



February 5, 2019

Agenda

  1. Custom Queries

  2. Naming Policy

  3. Policy Models

    1. How are they created and distributed 

Recording

ONAP Scaling 190205.mp4

Attendees

Scott Blandford, Marco Platania, Pramod Jamkhedkar, Jacques Bolduc, Martial Ngueko, Milind Jalwadi, Pamela Dragosh, Lauren Lewis, Joss Armstrong 

Discussion

Action Items

January 29, 2019

Agenda

  1. Dummy VF_Module Automation

  2. Tech Mahindra Commitments

    1. Policy

    2. CLAMP

  3. Closed Loop Commitments 

Recording

ONAP Scaling 190129.mp4

Attendees

Scott Blandford, Steve Smokowski, Milind Jalwadi, Pam Dragosh, Marco Platania, Martial Ngueko, Amit Sinha, Lauren Lewis, Yuriu Malakov, Pramod Jamkhedkar

Discussion

Additional information may be found on this wiki page:  https://lf-onap.atlassian.net/wiki/x/G2j5

  • Dummy VF_Module fix impacts CLAMP and Policy

    • VID already parses the model

    • Need to determine whether CLAMP or Policy will parse the model

  •  Naming Policy - Impacts Policy

    • Current method breaks when Named Queries go away

    • Needs to be human readable

    • Used in SDNC-Preload

    • Pam to determine good options next week.

  • Simplification of Scale Out Screens - CLAMP

    • Tech Mahindra to provide Operations Policy GUI Changes 

Action Items



January 22, 2014

Agenda

  1. A&AI Named_Queries

  2. Distribute Traffic

  3. Scaling Automation

  4. Closed Loop Commitments 

Recording

ONAP Scaling 190122.mp4

Attendees

Scott Blandford, Milind Jalwadi, Marco Platania, Lathish, Martial ngueko, Pam Dragosh, Jacques Bolduc, Lauren Lewis, HC6145, Joss Armstrong, Prabhu 

Discussion

  • Named Queries  will be replaced with Custom Queries

    • Need to determine how Policy will handle this (Set up a meeting for later in the week)

  • Scaling Automation

    • How will policy get the ID's it needs if there are not already in AAI 

Action Items 

January 15, 2019

Agenda

  1. Summary from last few weeks

  2. Closed Loop focus

  3. Automation (Tech Mahindra) 

Recording

ONAP Scale Out 190115.mp4

Attendees

Scott Blandford, Lathish, Lukasz Rajewski, Martial Ngueko, Pamela Dragosh, Taka Cho, Lauren Lewis, Matti Hiltunen, Ajay Mahimkar, David Ho, Prema Bhatt, Yuriy Malakov, Randa Maher, Marco Platania, Adam Wudzinski 

Discussion

Action Items