ETSI Package Management (SDC Enhancements)- Guilin

Requirements & Use Cases

The following requirements are defined in the Guilin release - functional requirements proposed list, Guilin release - functional requirements proposed list

• Onboard ETSI SOL004 compliant VNF packages 
  • Support for onboarding ETSI v2.7.1 SOL004 CSAR Packages (Link to ETSI SOL004 v2.7.1 )
  • Support for onboarding ETSI v2.7.1 SOL001 VNF Descriptor (Link to ETSI SOL001 v2.7.1)
  • Support for mapping of ETSI v2.7.1 SOL001 VNF Descriptor into SDC AID Data Model
  • Support for using an ETSI v2.7.1 VNF in an ONAP Service
• Onboard ETSI SOL007 compliant Network Service Descriptor packages (stretch goal for Guilin)
  • Support for Cataloging and Preserving the original SOL007 package
  • Support for mapping of ETSI v2.7.1 SOL001 Network Service Descriptor in the SOL007 package into SDC AID Data Model
  • Support for deploying a service that contains an ETSI SOL001 v2.7.1 compliant Network Service using VF-C as the NFVO
  • Support for deploying a service that contains an ETSI SOL001 v2.7.1 compliant Network Service using an external NFVO
• Design ETSI SOL007 compliant Network Service Descriptor packages
  • Support for deploying a service that contains an ETSI SOL001 v2.7.1 compliant Network Service using VF-C as the NFVO
  • Support for deploying a service that contains an ETSI SOL001 v2.7.1 compliant Network Service using an external NFVO
• Support for Nested/Hierarchical ETSI SOL001 v2.7.1 Network Service Descriptor (not for Guilin)
• Design Service templates, leveraging NSDs
  • Support Service templates including NSDs

Feature Descriptions

Epic and User Story

ETSI Package Management Architecture

The diagram depicts the package management architecture. 

1. SDC supports SOL004 VNF/PNF package onboarding, and stores the original vendor VNF/PNF package inside the SDC package
   1. SOL004 package includes SOL001 VNFD/PNFD
   2. PNF onboarding has been tested
2. SDC will support SOL007 NS package onboarding and store the original vendor NS package inside the SDC package
   1. NS onboarding will be supported
   2. NS onboarding will be tested
3. SDC supports VNF/PNF package management interfaces from OSS/BSS via SOL005 Package Management APIs (TBD)
4. SO supports NS package management interfaces from OSS via SOL005 Package Management APIs (TBD)
5. ETSI Catalog Manager stores SOL004/SOL007 Packages for other ONAP runtime components such as SO, SOL003/SOL005 Adapters, VFC and others
   1. ONAP-ETSI Catalog Manager will store SOL004 packages for VNF and PNF
   2. ONAP-ETSI Catalog Manager will store SOL007 packages for NS
6. SOL003 VNFM Adapter provides VNFMs Query/Fetch VNF packages/contents/artifacts, Reading VNFD and subscription/notification services
7. SOL005 Adapter provides NS/PNF/VNF package management to VF-C/External NFVO by leveraging SOL005 package management APIs

Onboarding

SDC NS/VNF/PNF/NS Onboarding and Distribution

This section describes SDC VNF/PNF onboarding and the End-to-End package distribution from SDC to SVNFM/external NFVOs.

SDC takes the vendor provided package and adds some files or changes files and meta data according to SDC procedure.

SDC NS/VNF/PNF Onboarding Procedure and Original Vendor VNF/PNF Package Handling

• Enhancement (Ericsson contribution) was made to the SDC Dublin to support SOL004 PNF/VNF onboarding with .zip and .csar file extensions.
  
  • SDC VSP and Resource csar files have the ETSI_PACKAGE, which contains the original vendor VNF package.
    • The VNFM and external NFVO use the original vendor VNF/NS packages.
    • ONAP-ETSI Catalog Manager will be changed for the location of the original vendor package.
  • SOL007 NS onboarding will follow the same procedure; i.e., storing the vendor SOL007 NS package into the ETSI_PACKAGE directory.
• In Guilin, the ONBOARDED_PACKAGE directory is changed to the ETSI_PACKAGE directory.

1. At onboarding, SDC checks the file extension and performs the following procedures
   1. If the file is .zip, SDC unzips
      1. If it has .cert & .cms, it is a package with security and security validation will be performed.
      2. If it does not include .cert & .cms, it is an existing Heat template onboarding, and SDC follows the Heat template onboarding procedure
2. If the file is .csar, it is a package without security.
3. Next, SDC will check the TOSCA.meta file.
4. If it contains SOL004v2.x.1 keywords, the package will be handled as SOL004v2.x.1. In the Guilin release, v2.7.1 will be supported.
5. Otherwise, it will be handled as existing TOSCA (non-SOL004) package onboarding which will not have the ETSI_PACKAGE artifact.

NS Onboarding Design

• extend OrchestrationTemplateProcessCsarHandler.java to handle SOL007
  • processCsar()
    • instantiateToscaConverterFor(resourceType).convert(fileContentHandler)
      • calling ToscaSolModelDrivenConverterPNF()
        • pndfTransformationEngine.transform()
      • calling ToscaSolConverterVnf()
        • vnfTopologyTemplateConverter().convertTopologyTemplate(serviceTemplate, readerService)
          • convertInputs()
          • convertNodeTemplates()
          • convertOutputs()
          • convertSubstitutionMappings()
          • convertPolicies()
      • need to call ToscaSolModelDrivenConverterNS()
• create ToscaSolModelDrivenConverterNS class
  • create NSdNodeTemplateTransformationEngine class
    • transform() to SDC AID DM NS
• generate the SDC package for NS with the original vendor SOL007 NS package

VNF Onboarding Design

• leverage the existing SOL004 VNF onboarding mechanism
• create a transform class to transform to SDC AID DM VNF
• generate the SDC package for VNF with the original vendor SOL004 VNF package

PNF Onboarding Design

• leverage the existing SOL004 PNF onboarding mechanism
• the transformation to SDC AID DM is already done
• It is already done: generate the SDC package for PNF with the original vendor SOL004 VNF package

The following diagram depicts the onboarding procedures for VNF/NS/PNF.

1. SOL004 VNF/PNF and SOL007 NS Packages are onboarded to SDC.
2. SDC creates its Resource CSAR by adding ONAP-specific files and metadata according to SDC procedure.
   1. For VNF onboarding, SOL001 VNFD is mapped to SDC Data Model.
   2. For NS onboarding, SOL001 NSD is mapped to SDC Data Model. Note: the SDC NS Data Model would be SOL001 NSD-based.
   3. For PNF onboarding, SOL001 PNFD is mapped to SDC Data Model.
   4. The original SOL004 VNF/PNF and SOL007 NS packages will be stored in the ETSI_PACKAGE directory.
   5. SDC shall have a capability to design SOL007 NSDs and generates SOL007 NS packages
      1. Since SDC does not have a proper NS Model, it will follow SOL001 NSD.
   6. SDC embeds the Resource CSAR into its Service CSAR for distribution.
      1. After SDC validates the onboarded packages, the Service CSAR is distributed.
      2. SDC sends the package notification to DMaaP for its package notification subscribers.
3. ETSI Catalog Manager receives the package notification from SDC.
   1. ETSI Catalog Manager queries SDC for the SDC CSAR.
      1. ETSI Catalog Managers examines the SDC CSAR. If the SDC CSAR contains the ETSI_PACKAGE directory, it extracts the SOL004/SOL007 packages from the directory.
      2. ETSI Catalog Manager stores the SOL004/SOL007 packages to its Catalog Database.
   2. ETSI Catalog Manager provides APIs for the SOL003/SOL005 Adapters to distribute the packages to SVNFM/NFVO.

Design NS

NSD Structure

SDC supports NSD design that meets the following requirements.

• The NSD shall reference the VNFDs applicable to its constituent VNFs.
• The NSD shall include the VLDs applicable to the VLs used by the NS to interconnect its constituent NFs.
• The NSD shall reference the PNFDs applicable to its constituent PNFs.
• The NSD shall include the descriptors of the VNFFGs applicable to the NS (stretch goal).
• The NSD shall support the capability to include or reference NS LCM scripts.
• The NSD shall support the capability to providing monitoring parameters to be tracked during the lifetime of a NS instance (stretch goal).
• The NSD shall support the capability to describe auto scale rules, associating criteria to scaling actions (stretch goal).
• The NSD shall include package security information enabling validating its authenticity and integrity.
• The NSD shall include a globally unique identifier for identifying each descriptor instance.
• The NSD shall include an identifier to select to controller compatible with the NSD.
• A VLD shall enable specifying the type of connectivity provided by the link between VNFs.

NSD Information Element

• SDC supports the following NSD Information Elements.
• SDC supports the netestedNsdId(s) for nested NSDs. (not for Guilin)
• SDC UI should be able to manage the NSD attributes.
• SDC supports the virtualLinkDesc(s) to define constituent VLs.

Use Cases for Guilin

VCPE

The following is an example of VCPE model hierarchy. In VCPE, the E2E Service model includes one NS (vCPE). And the vCPE NS model includes vbng, vbrgemu, vgmux and vgw VNFs and a network VL.

• SDC should be able to reference the vCPE NSD from the E2E Service model.
• SDC should be able to reference all the constituent VNFs and VL(s).

<example>

• Test with vGW and VGMUX with a VL first.

Latest vCPE CSARs

The latest (Frankfurt) vCPE CSARs can be retrieved from the https://git.onap.org/demo/tree/tosca/vCPE_F. There are one NS CSAR and five VNF CSARs:

• ns.csar
• infra.csar
• vbng.csar
• vbrgemu.csar
• vgmux.csar
• vgw.csar

Other Use Case

To represent nested NS cases, we will choose another use case.

• TBD

NSD Design Process in SDC

VNF Composition

The following diagram depicts how SDC

1. creates a NSD, based on SOL001 NSD
   1. generates SDC AID DM for NS, based on SOL001 NSD
2. drags and drops constituent VFs
3. generates SOL007 NS package

VL Composition

• SDC supports NSVLDs that are defined in the ETSI IFA 014, as part of NS design.
• SDC UI should be able to handle the following VLD attributes.

VNFD Composition

The NSD references the VNFD of a constituent VNFs.

• Drag and drops onboarded VNFs

The following depicts the VNFD information element.

SapD Composition

SapD fulfills the following information element.

Distribution

ETSI packages will be distributed from SDC to the ETSI Catalog Manager for other ONAP runtime components such as SO (SOL003/SOL005 Adapter) and VF-C.

• The original vendor package format could be one of the following.
  • Vendor package including certificate and signature (Zip format)
  • Vendor package without certificate and signature (CSAR format)

ETSI Catalog Manager Enhancements

ETSI Catalog Manager will interface with the SDC directly, without a help from ONAP SO.

Package Distribution Components Interactions

The following diagram depicts the ETSI package distribution. 

ETSI Package Distribution Flows

SDC SOL004/SOL007 VNF Package Security

Among the SOL004/SOL007 VNF package security options, the SDC supports the option2 as depicted below. In the option 2, there are two ways to zip the VNF packages, and SDC supports both.

SDC validates the VNF packages based on the embedded signature and certificate by leveraging CA.

• Vendor SOL004/SOL007 VNF Package with certificate and signature is onboarded into SDC
  • ZIP-format VNF package includes CSAR, Signature and Certificate
• SDC validates VNF package based on the certificate and signature
• SDC generates SDC internal model plus the vendor SOL004/SOL007 package CSAR and ZIP (with certificate and signature) – the supported format is TBD based on the security requirement

Package Security

A VNF package uses the signature and certificate to ensure package integrity and validity. A CSAR file is digitally signed with the VNF provider private key. During the VNF package onboarding to SDC, SDC validates the package and then does the following:

• Transform SOL001-based VNFD into SDC internal models
• Store the original Vendor package into the ETSI_PACKAGE directory
  • If the original vendor package is a zip file with signature and certificate, the ETSI_PACKAGE directory will contain the zip file. 
• VNFM and VF-C will receive the zip-format file.
• For Frankfurt, the SVNFM and external NFVO will receive a zip-format package with signature and certificate if the original vendor package contains signature and certificate.
  • SVNFM and NFVO will unzip the incoming zip package files and extract CSAR files from the zip package files without validation.
  • After the Frankfurt release, it is assumed that SVNFM and NFVO validate the incoming packages based on signature and certificate.

SOL001 Mapping to SDC AID DM

The following diagram depicts SOL001 Mapping to SDC AID DM.

Current Mapping Support (as of Frankfurt)

Note: AAI impacts are under discussion.

Presentation Slide (as a summary)

The following is a presentation slide that summarizes the Mapping.

Mapping of ETSI Information NS-related Elements with TOSCA types

• For E2E (OSS Service) modeling, use org.openecomp.resource.abstract.nodes.service
  • E2E (OSS Service-Level) is outside of ETSI scope, and it could be ONAP-specific that is orchestrated by ONAP SO
  • The E2E (OSS Service-Level) model references/includes associated NSs
  • For the E2E service level, the org.openecop.resource.abstract.nodes.service type is still used as the base type of the service. SDC will use the ETSI SOL001 NS type and attach the NSs to the E2E (OSS Service).
• For NS modeling, use tosca.nodes.nfv.NS
  • ONAP SO-NFVO, VFC and external NFVO manage the NS models and packages

ONAP ETSI-Alignment Modeling Hierarchy

• The following diagram depicts ONAP ETSI-Alignment Modeling hierarchy.
• Note: the ONAP VFC model represents the design time VFC, not runtime VFC instance(s).

Mapping between SOL001 Data Model and SDC AID DM

The following summarizes the mapping between two models:

Current SDC Resource Models

SDC: nfv-types					SDC: heat-types
ETSI NFV IE	SDC Descriptor / SOL001	TOSCA Type	Derived from		SDC Descriptor	TOSCA Type	Derived from
NSD	nodes.yml / SOL001	tosca.nodes.nfv.NS	tosca.nodes.Root		Generic_Service.yml	org.openecomp.resource.abstract.nodes.service (use it for both E2E (OSS Service) and NS)	tosca.nodes.Root
	NSD.yml	org.openecomp.resource.vfc.NSD	tosca.nodes.Root		N/A
SapD	SOL001	tosca.nodes.nfv.Sap	tosca.nodes.Root
NsVirtualLinkDesc	SOL001	tosca.nodes.nfv.NsVirtualLink (there is tosca.nodes.nfv.VnfVirtualLink)	tosca.nodes.Root		vl.yml	org.openecomp.resource.vl.VL	tosca.nodes.network.Network
					extVl.yml	org.openecomp.resource.vl.extVL	tosca.nodes.Root
					internalVl.yml	org.openecomp.resource.vl.internalVL	tosca.nodes.network.Network
	extZteVL.yml	tosca.nodes.nfv.ext.zte.VL	tosca.nodes.Root
Pnfd		tosca.nodes.nfv.PNF	tosca.nodes.Root		Generic_PNF.yml	org.openecomp.resource.abstract.nodes.PNF	tosca.nodes.Root
Vnfd	VNF.yml	tosca.nodes.nfv.VNF	tosca.nodes.Root		Generic_VF.yml	org.openecomp.resource.abstract.nodes.VF	tosca.nodes.Root
Vnffgd		tosca.groups.nfv.VNFFG	tosca.groups.Root		forwardingPath.yml(?)	org.openecomp.nodes.ForwardingPath	tosca.nodes.Root

NSD Mapping to SDC AID DM

Initial Input

• Internal NSD representation

NSD Mapping to SDC AID DM

A benefit of mapping an onboarded ETSI NS to the internal representation of an ONAP Service is that the ETSI NS can access the standard ONAP runtime functionality implemented or planned for support of ONAP Services.

SOL001 NSD mapping to/from NS SDC AID DM

• ONAP previous analysis
  • The SDC NSD node type, org.openecom.resource.vfc.NSD, is modeled as a component of a VF to represent an allotted resource. But, it is not derived from the org.openecomp.resource.vfc.AllottedResource, either. 
  • The SDC NSD might be designed for Volte use case support, and used by the VFC.
  • It is recommended to deprecate the current SDC NSD node type, and to replace with SOL001 tosca.nodes.nfv.NS node type.
• Solutions
  • SDC generates SOL001 tosca.nodes.nfv.NS node type
  • SDC takes SOL001 NSD with tosca.nodes.nfv.NS node type as is, without mapping; i.e., no mapping is necessary
  • ONAP SO NFVO uses the SOL001 NSD
  • VFC needs to use the SOL001 NSD
  • There could be some impact on VID and ONAP SO Catalog DB for the SOL001 NSD - to be analyzed.
• Guilin Decisions
  • SDC generates SOL001 tosca.nodes.nfv.NSD node type, and uses it as SDC AID DM.

SOL001 NS

<tosca.datatypes.nfv.NsProfile>

SDC TOSCA Repository

https://gerrit.onap.org/r/gitweb?p=sdc.git;a=tree;f=catalog-be/src/main/resources/import/tosca;h=70fecc1c6de587cd003c38f3e43547a10785e723;hb=refs/heads/master

SDC nfv-types

SDC nfv-types/NSD

SDC TOSCA repository: /catalog-be/src/main/resources/import/tosca/nfv-types/NSD/

• need to update to tosca_simple_yaml_1.2

<nodes.yml: org.openecomp.resource.vfc.NSD>

  org.openecomp.resource.vfc.NSD:

    derived_from: tosca.nodes.Root

    description: ECOMP Allotted Resource base type all other allotted resources node types derive from

    properties:

      nsd_id:

        type: string

        required: true

        description: ID of the NSD

      nsd_designer:

        type: string

        required: true

        description: Designer of the NSD

      nsd_version:

        type: string

        required: true

        description: Version of the NSD

      nsd_name:

        type: string

        required: true

        description: Name of the NSD

      providing_service_uuid:

        type: string

        required: true

        description: The depending service uuid in order to map the allotted resource to the specific service version

      providing_service_invariant_uuid:

        type: string

        required: true

        description: The depending service invariant uuid in order to map the allotted resource to the specific service version

      providing_service_name:

        type: string

        required: true

        description: The depending service name in order to map the allotted resource to the specific service version

    requirements:

    - virtualLink:

        capability: tosca.capabilities.network.Linkable

        relationship: tosca.relationships.network.LinksTo

    capabilities:

      virtual_linkable:

        type: tosca.capabilities.network.Linkable

VNFD Mapping to SDC AID DM

SOL001 VNF mapping to/from VNF SDC AID DM

• ONAP previous analysis
  • There is no 1:1 mapping between the SOL001 tosca.nodes.nfv.VNF and org.openecomp.resource.abstract.nodes.VF.
    • SDC VF node types has very few properties.
    • a lot of common properties are added to each node type created by SDC
    • new common properties are mainly about networking and ONAP specific properties
  • There is no clear mapping logic between the current node types
    • SDC creates new data type as ONAP deployment configuration.
  • In ETSI, the descriptor_id is used to reference to the VNF, but in ONAP, the UUID is used to reference to the VNF.
• Solutions
  • map between SOL001 VNF and SDC AID DM VNF selectively.
    • data in the SOL001 that would be considered Cloud Provider automation data could be remained unmapped
    • Examples of Service Provider data that would need to be mapped in order to drive ONAP automation would include:
      • HPA requirements needed by OOF to determine cloud feasibility
      • Input parameters passed to the Cloud provider
    • ONAP wants to distinguish between the mode/data required to drive ONAP functionality from a Service Provider perspective from any ancillary mode/data required to drive Cloud Provider automation.
  • UUID and invariantUUID must not be modeled as metadata type, per TOSCA YAML because the data provided within metadata, maybe ignored by TOSCA orchestrator and should not affect runtime behavior. 
  • Identify Cloud Provider automation-related data and remove it from the mapping
  • Identify Service Provider data and map it to SDC AID DM
  • ONAP SO NFVO uses SOL001 VNF; other ONAP runtime components could use the new mapped org.openecomp.resource.abstract.nodes.ETSI.VNF

Current VNF Modeling in ETSI and SDC

Solutions:

There are two options. For now, we chose the option A. The option B is under discussion.

Option A:

Define a new data type based on the org.openecomp.resource.abstract.nodes.VF with ETSI SOL001 VNF data type attributes.

• Make the org.openecomp.resource.abstract.nodes.ETSI.VNF a superset of both tosca.nodes.nfv.VNF and org.openecomp.resource.abstract.node.VF
• During VNF onboarding, SDC copies SOL001 VNF attribute contents to the corresponding attributes in tte org.openecomp.resource.abstract.nodes.ETSI.VNF
• SOL001 VNF attributes in SDC AID DM VNF will be visible to SDC UI, so SDC UI can change the attributes
• ONAP specific attributes that are inherited from the org.openecomp.resource.abstract.nodes.VF will be filled up by SDC (design time)
  • Those attribute contents will not be mapped back into the SOL001 VNF (reverse mapping). For that case, only the SOL001 VNF corresponding attributes will be copied

Option B:

Define a new data type based on the tosca.nodes.nfv.VNF with SDC AID DM VNF data type attributes.

• SDC AID DM VNF data type attributes will be handled as the 'additionalAttributes', which is a map of key, value pairs.
• Those attribute contents will not be mapped back into the SOL001 VNF (reverse mapping). For that case, only the SOL001 VNF corresponding attributes will be copied.

SOL001 VDU mapping to/from VNF SDC AID DM VFC

Current SOL001 VDU vs. SDC AID DM VFC

• no 1:1 mapping
• note: the SDC AID DM VFC represents design-time VFC (like VDU), not VFC instances in runtime

Solutions for VDU and VFC mapping

• Make the org.openecomp.resource.abstract.nodes.ETSI.VFC a superset of both tosca.nodes.nfv.Vdu and org.openecomp.resource.abstract.nodes.VFC
• Note: the org.openecomp.resource.abstract.nodes.VFC represents design-time VFC, not VFC instances

New SDC AID DM VFC type (org.openecomp.resource.abstract.nodes.ETSI.VFC)

SOL001 2.7.1 VNFD Mapping from/to SDC AID DM VNFD

SOL001 2.7.1 VNFD Template

tosca_definitions_version: tosca_simple_yaml_1_2

description:

imports:

data_types:

node_types:

topology_template:

    inputs: 

    node_templates: 

        VNF

substitution_mappings:

    capabilities:

    requirements:

SDC VFD Template

tosca_definitions_version: tosca_simple_profile_for_ecomp_1_0

descriptions:

imports:

data_types:

node_types:

topology_template:

    inputs:

    node_templates:

         vfc:

            type: org.openecomp.resource.vfc

        extCP:

            type: org.openecomp.resources.cp

    groups:

        VFModule_Base:

            type: org.openecomp.groups.VfModule

        VFModule_Expansion:

            type: org.openecomp.groups.VfModule

    workflows:

    policies:

        anti_collated_az_policy:

substitution_mappings:

    node_type: org.openecomp.resources.vf.<vf_name>

    capabilities:

    requirements:

SOL001 VNFD mapping to/from SDC AID DM VFD

VF-Module Initial Input 

The following is a summary of initial input from Gil Bullard (AT&T).

• Mapping Scope Challenges and Suggestions 

  • ONAP wants to distinguish between the mode/data required to drive ONAP functionality from a Service Provider perspective from any ancillary mode/data required to drive Cloud Provider automation.

    • See the ONAP MultiVim Proposal on the separation of concerns.
  • SDC AID  was created before a separation of concerns was envisioned, thus there are data structures in the SDC AID that would be considered Cloud Provider automation data and that we would likely take out of the SDC AID.
    • Examples of Service Provider data that would need to be mapped in order to drive ONAP automation would include:
      • HPA requirements needed by OOF to determine cloud feasibility
      • Input parameters passed to the Cloud provider
    • There is probably some data in the SOL001 that would be considered Cloud Provider automation data. Any such data could remain unmapped
    • SOL001 content needed to drive ONAP automation (SO, OOF, SDNC, AAI, DCAE, etc.) would need to be mapped
  • The VNFM should not be aware of the VF Module structure, though the current SO-SDNC interactions to get assignment are by VF Module, and the VF Module entity plays prominent in AAI. That means there needs to be two adaptation points as we have discussed:
    • An SDC function to extract VF Module information from the SOL001 VNFD prior to distribution to runtime
    • A VNFM Adapter function to flatten the VF Module structure prior to handoff to the VNFM

• VF-Module Deduction from SOL001

• • There is an assumption that SDC transforms the vendor provided VNF package into ONAP-compliant one; i.e., deducing VF Modules based on VNFD ScalingAspects and Delta.
  • If SDC supports the transformation in Dublin time-frame, the transformed CSAR will be imported to SO, and SO VNF- and VF-Module-level workflows will manage VNF and VF Module topology towards SDNC with the following changes - Input from Gil Bullard (AT&T)
    • Today the VNF-level workflow has an embedded per-VF Module loop that a) retrieves the SDNC assignments for that VF Module, and then b) sends those VF Module-level assignments down to the VIM (e.g., OpenStack); the loop then moves to repeat "a" with the next VF Module. 
    • The new VNF-level flow will have the following sequences:
      1. an embedded per-VF Module loop that only retrieves the SDNC assignments for each VF Module; because the VIM is hidden from SO's sight, beneath the VNFM Adapter/VNFM.
      2. After finishing the loop, the SO workflows will send a structure  to the VNFM Adapter that includes the aggregate assignments at the VNF level.
      3. The VNFM Adapter aggregates all the VF-Module level assignments and transforms the assignment data into SOL003 API parameters before sending them to SVNFM
         1. The VNFM Adapter would need to be able to parse the VNF-level assignments structure received from SO to obtain the per-VDUconnection point assignments information and any per-VDU parameter information (e.g., hostnames)
         2. In doing so, the VNFM Adapter would need to know to ignore the VF Module groupings of these assignments
         3. Further know how to map the ONAP data structure and parameter names into the ETSI (e.g., VM=VDU, VNFC=VNFC, vNIC=vNIC, etc.). Note that the above assumes that in ONAP, as in ETSI, there will be a one-to-one correspondence between VM/VDU and VNFC.

• 
  

  • Assumptions for deducing VF-Module from SOL001 (Gil Bullard's input)

• • • SOL001 concept of Aspect+ScalingDelta combination is one to one with the ONAP concept of VF Module.
    • SOL001 concept of VDU is one to one with the ONAP concept of A&AI vServer
    • SOL001 concept of a connection point associated with a VDU corresponds to the ONAP concept of the same name, as does the understanding of the meaning of “internal” versus “external” connection point.
    • ONAP-compliant SOL001 VNF Vendors will be obliged to name their HEAT files using a naming convention that encodes the SOL001 Aspect+ScalingDelta names
    • ONAP-compliant SOL001 VNF Vendors will be obliged to name their SOL001 Aspect+ScalingDelta parameters using a naming convention that readily maps to the corresponding HEAT properties.  
    • In addition, if AT&T has already deployed such a vendor’s VNF into its network, the HEAT naming will remain invariant, and (at least) the (AT&T version of that) SOL001 be written to match it.
  • What to do
    • ONAP will be extended to incorporate the constructs of Aspect and Scaling Level.  This includes SDC’s, SOs, and A&AI’s modeling of these constructs and A&AI's ability to capture and SO’s ability to set/update the "current scaling level" of a VNF for a given Aspect. 
    • If ETSI in their SOL001 VNFD had defined a "ScalingDelta" in a straightforward manner, i.e., in terms of the VNFCs that comprise it, then it would be very easy to extract VF Module information from the VNFD.  (I would like to see ETSI define "ScalingDelta" in this manner, as opposed to the current way they do so. )  However, given that they did not, ONAP SDC would need to be extended to derive the VF Module “structure” from the SOL001 document through the algorithm below.  “Structure” in this case includes the VDU topology, connection points and associated parameters.  This algorithm will:
    • Determine the set of Aspects and corresponding VDUs and associated ScalingDeltas (step_deltas) from the SOL001.
    • Determine the set of ScalingLevels associated with each Aspect and the ScalingDeltas associated with each.
    • Translate the VDU-centric representation of ScalingDeltas (step_deltas) as per SOL001 to come up with a ScalingDelta-centric representation that captures the number and type of VDUs associated with that ScalingDelta across the various VDU types.
    • Create a VF Module object that corresponds to each ScalingDelta-centric representation of a ScalingDelta calculated above.
    • Fill in the details of the VF Module object based on the SOL001 data to represent the VDU connection points, associated Networks (internal or external), and associated Parameters.
    • Determine if there is an artifact in the SOL004 package that is a HOT YAML whose file name corresponds (through a VNF vendor obligatory naming convention) to the Aspect+ScalingDelta from which this VF Module object was derived.  If so, associate that HOT file with the VF Module.
    • Name the VF Module based on a naming convention to capture the Aspect+ScalingDelta names
    • Determine and capture the mapping from each Aspect + ScalingLevel model for the VNF to the corresponding VF Module.
    • Given a desired state Aspect+ScalingLevel, will be able to calculate (from the SDC distributed mapping of Aspect+ScalingLevel to VF Module along with the current Scaling Level for this Aspect as per A&AI) the (ordered set of) VF Module(s) needed to take that VNF from the “current scaling level” to the desired level for that Aspect.
    • Note:  As an aside, SDC enhancements are being discussed. It is not clear if the SDC changes will be available in the Dublin time frame. some “stubbing off” SDC with a simulator could be suggested to at least prove in the run-time aspects of the solution.

org.openecomp.group.VfModule Attribute and SOL001 VNF Policies deduction

VirtualLink Mapping to SDC AID DM

SOL001 VL mapping to/from VL SDC AID DM

• ONAP previous analysis
  • Each vendor/operator defined their own VL node types (e.g., tosca.nodes.nfv.ext.zte.VL)
  • The vendor/operator-specific node types have no direct 1:1 mapping to tosca.nodes.nfv.NsVirtualLink
• Solutions
  • Deprecate vendor/operator-specific VLs
  • Use SOL001 tosca.nodes.nfv.NsVirtualLink
  • ONAP SO NFVO uses the SOL001 tosca.nodes.nfv.NsVirtualLink
  • VFC needs to adapt SOL001 tosca.nodes.nfv.NsVirtualLink

SOL001 VL

<tosca.nodes.nfv.NsVirtualLink>

<tosca.datatypes.nfv.NsVlProfile>

<tosca.datatypes.nfv.ConnectivityType>

<tosca.datatypes.nfv.LinkBitrateRequirements>

<tosca.datatypes.nfv.NsVirtualLinkQos>

<tosca.datatypes.nfv.ServiceAvailability>

Current SDC VL

<tosca.nodes.nfv.ext.zte.VL>

  tosca.nodes.nfv.ext.zte.VL:

    derived_from: tosca.nodes.Root

    description: Ext ZTE VL

    properties:

      segmentation_id:

        type: string

        required: false

      network_name:

        type: string

        required: false

      is_predefined:

        type: boolean

        required: false

      mtu:

        type: integer

        required: false

      dns_nameservers:

        type: list

        required: false

        entry_schema:

          type: string

      physical_network:

        type: string

        required: false

      dhcp_enabled:

        type: boolean

        required: false

      network_id:

        type: string

        required: false

      host_routes:

        type: list

        required: false

        entry_schema:

          type: tosca.datatypes.nfv.ext.HostRouteInfo

      ip_version:

        type: integer

        required: false

      vendor:

        type: string

        required: false

      name:

        type: string

        required: false

      start_ip:

        type: string

        required: false

      vlan_transparent:

        type: boolean

        required: false

      cidr:

        type: string

        required: false

      gateway_ip:

        type: string

        required: false

      network_type:

        type: string

        required: false

      end_ip:

        type: string

        required: false

      location_info:

        type: tosca.datatypes.nfv.ext.LocationInfo

        required: false

    capabilities:

      virtual_linkable:

        type: tosca.capabilities.nfv.VirtualLinkable

        occurrences:

        - 1

        - UNBOUNDED

        valid_source_types: [

          ]

PNF Mapping to SDC AID DM

SOL001 PNF mapping to/from VL SDC AID DM