zoom bridge: https://zoom.us/j/283628617

04 Mar 2019	PTL Recordings	Zoom Chat Log

Duration 60 minutes

Duration	Agenda Item	Requested by	Notes / Links
START RECORDING
5min	Review Action Items	Former user (Deleted)
5min	Review M3 checklist	cl664y@att.com Former user (Deleted)	The M3 checklist has recent updates (integration blockers) so please make sure you're picking up the latest template.
offline?	Dublin M2 risks followup #11: The new lifecycle Policy API definition being introduced for Dublin are under draft and having frequent churn; this is blocking DCAE Policy Handler evaluation/enhancement required to support this API. Based on current assessment of draft versions - new proposed updates impacts existing client (PH) handling of policy data in significant manner. #12 & #14: Lab Space & S3P- Geo-Redundancy - Lab Environment to be available by M4	Former user (Deleted) Yang Xu
	Windriver lab resource capacity and allocation	Stephen Gooch eddy.raineri Yang Xu	Dev and Integration teams are running into resource constraints in Windriver lab, and we expect the situation will get worse when approaching integration testing phase. Stephen will review the lab resource capacity and where the resource is allocated currently, and we will collect lab resource requirements from Dev teams <Met offline to discuss the situation and agreed to start with simple reporting on resource usage. Noted the Open Lab subcommittee was chartered to help oversee this exact topic. Former user (Deleted) will work with TSC to see if the dormant OpenLab Subcommittee might be re-invigorated. Invited Stephen Gooch and eddy.raineri back to PTL next session to showcase the resource usage report.>
30min	Self-release objective - Review for TSC approval 2019-03-07 global-jjb (java) - Automated release process (non-java components) - CIMAN-234	Former user (Deleted) Jessica Gonzalez	Review the plans with PTLs Desired outcome: Seek agreement from PTLs on process changes and timeframes Defer DockerHub until next week Early feedback: projects that avoid snapshot dependencies migration to global-jjb is much easier
5min	Follow-up from Footprint Optimization call	Eric Debeau Adolfo Perez-Duran (Deactivated)	Container Image Minimization Guidelines https://lists.onap.org/g/onap-tsc/message/4673 Docker images produced by project should be optimized and become the images to be used by Integration included in the ONAP release
5min	Where to find the containers to be certified by the Integration Team?	Eric Debeau Adolfo Perez-Duran (Deactivated) Mike Elliott
10min	Proposal: Modifying the Dublin M3 checklist: Data models and swagger requirement (from TSC meeting)	Andy Mayer Hui Deng	Our proposal is for M3 to please include a single modeling item: "Has the Project team provided links to Data Models (e.g., JSON, YANG, Swagger, etc.) for all Shared Information (e.g., APIs, API Payload, Shared Design Model)?" <Data model checklist item was agreed as informational only - M3 cannot be blocked by data model question>
5min	oParent contents and delivery plan	Amy Zwarico Paweł Pawlak	Please review the plan to provide the oParent contents BEFORE M3 <DEFER TOPIC LACK OF PRESENTER>
5min	New bug fix in Casablanca branch	Yang Xu	DMAAP-1065 - Getting issue details... STATUS The Jira is about fixing an expired AAF certificate in DMAAP for Casablanca branch. We need to come up with a procedure to release bug fix for the past releases (e.g. security bug fix etc.) <Need a process recommendation Kenny Paul Former user (Deleted) >
5min	Daylight savings time adjustment		Daylight saving time 2019 in the US will begin on Sunday, March 10, 2019, in Europe will begin on Sunday, March 31 in Australia will begin on Sunday, April 7, 2019, No Clock change in China, India Desired outcome: Gain agreement of how to schedule the PTL weekly meeting. Suggestion: announce only a single fixed time in one timezone on the meeting page PTL Weekly Meeting #ptl, then use meeting planner for every other timezone: https://www.timeanddate.com/worldclock/meetingtime.html?p1=137&p2=179&p3=136&p4=195&p5=676&p6=771&p7=33&p8=240&iv=0 <Kenny to issue a poll to understand the communities guidance on meeting times>
reminder	unconference@ONS		If you're going to ONS, be sure to take advantage of the unconference to get people together on topics that interest you!

Action Items:

Revise LF infrastructure roadmap to include the timeline and TSC-58 content 27 Feb 2019 in advance of TSC meeting Kenny Paul Former user (Deleted)
Krzysztof Opasiakto provide vulnerability procedure overview next week 2019-02-25
/* Vulnerability Management Procedure is being updated so I'd like to delay this till the procedure is approved by TSC to avoid confusion. Hopefully the overview will be delivered next week. */
Yang Xu add integration sanity passing in milestone checklist
(PTLs): Review ONAP codebase license scan, Feb. 2019 sent by Steve Winslow on 2/18. (reminder)
2/11: Migrate Docker image releases from Nexus3 into Docker Hub (Architecture Independence) by Dublin M4.
<2-15-2019> Preparing a preso for review of all known infrastructure change requests for review at PTL meeting 2-25-2019
Oom values.yaml or integration repo manifest ( TSC-86 - Lock down docker image tag name source of truth - oom values.yaml or integration repo manifest - A: both but manifest is the source SUBMITTED ) Michael O'Brien
if not covered - see TSC 2019-01-10
Quick discussion on nailing down whether we need a yaml override of the deployable
docker image tags in the oom repo (understanding is no) - with the integration docker manifest
(manifest is currently a copy of the oom values.yaml tags - not the reverse)
If not - then we need a documented procedure wiki/RTD on running a derived values.yaml override for the entire system before deployment
AAF is only an example here
https://git.onap.org/oom/tree/kubernetes/aaf/charts/aaf-service/values.yaml?h=casablanca#n28
```
image: onap/aaf/aaf_service:2.1.8
```
drives
https://git.onap.org/integration/tree/version-manifest/src/main/resources/docker-manifest.csv?h=casablanca#n11
```
onap/aaf/aaf_service,2.1.8
```
<1-7/2019> Integration team to document the procedure.<01/13/2019> Answer from Integration team: docker manifest under integration repo is the source of truth, and is used by Integration team to override OOM values.yaml when deploying ONAP in Openlab. See the instructions at the bottom of page https://onap.readthedocs.io/en/casablanca/submodules/integration.git/docs/onap-oom-heat.html#onap-oom-heat-template
<1-21/2019> Procedure should include Timers, dependencies, etc.
just need to define all the --set and -f overrides like the following

sudo helm deploy onap local/onap --namespace $ENVIRON -f $DISABLE_CHARTS_YAML -f $DEV0_YAML $APPENDABLE_ENABLED_FLAGS --verbose 
<1-28-2019>: Document how to handle the latest 3rd party image from github.
<2019-02-19>: One over-ride that will be shared, parent over-ride for docker versions, Michael O'Brien to modify TSC-86 to reflect process. Still looking at tool to institute changes for all projects (single commit). Mike Elliott FREEMAN, BRIAN D Gary Wu Sylvain Desbureaux to follow up offline.
It should also consider the problem identified with the Casablanca Maintenance Release:https://lists.onap.org/g/onap-tsc/message/4641
<2019-03-01 - Need a date for the delivery of the procedure >
<update PTL 2019-03-11 in meeting>
Helm Chart Transfer: 4 projects have been identified for trial: A&AI, Log, Policy, APPC, CLAMP and ONAP CLI. Mike Elliott will work with PTL to gather/transfer knowledge and create training materials. Training to be done the week of Jan 14 and PTL to provide their commitment or not by M1 on Jan 24.
<1-7/2019>: Work in progress. Schedule might shift to another week. Michael will follow-up with Mike. Training will be open to everybody. The objective is that each team will take over the management of their Helm Charts.
<1-28/2019>: Meeting is organized on 1/29 with LF. Training will be organized early in February. Additional information on the next PTL call (2/4)
<2019-2-19: Meeting on this topic today - review the process - develop training material. OOM subcharts complete - A&AI this week>
<2019-03-04: Ready to do the first project A&AI; after testing on the first project make video on process flow, several others will follow Jessica Gonzalez Mike Elliott>
What is the plan for the June ONAP Developers Forum - dates/location/etc Kenny Paul
Propose a process for Casablanca security updates Former user (Deleted) Kenny Paul
PTLs - to review TSC Webcast from 2/28 starting from 30th minute - https://r.lfnetworking.org/lfn-zoom/ONAP/TSC-Meetings/TSC-2019/tsc-2019-02-28.mp4

Zoom Chat Log

05:58:52 From Michael O'Brien : fixed the google map link the zoom on the templates
06:02:32 From Keong Lim k00759777 : there are still 2 different zoom brige links on the ptl minutes
06:03:04 From Michael O'Brien(LOG, Amdocs) : I fixed one that was google map ref - checking
06:03:44 From Michael O'Brien(LOG, Amdocs) : the second one is the correct one - any of us can edit the page - I will remove the first one "zoom bridge"
06:04:29 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : @keong in the invite?
06:04:57 From Keong Lim k00759777 : it's fixed now, remnant from previous weeks i think
06:05:09 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : ok thanks.
06:05:18 From Michael O'Brien(LOG, Amdocs) : Yes, was old link - fixed
06:11:02 From Honor : Mike
06:11:13 From Honor : Need your blessings on the Gerrit
06:11:16 From Honor : https://gerrit.onap.org/r/#/c/79319/
06:11:22 From Honor : Seshu here
06:12:45 From Seshu Kumar : There is a blocking issue pending on this
06:19:19 From Michael O'Brien(LOG, Amdocs) : posting these meetings to onap-discuss is good - we can decide to join
06:19:35 From Seshu Kumar : +1
06:21:46 From Michael O'Brien(LOG, Amdocs) : for master - my CD system is OK
06:21:47 From Michael O'Brien(LOG, Amdocs) : http://kibana.onap.info:5601/app/kibana#/dashboard/AWAtvpS63NTXK5mX2kuS
06:22:05 From Michael O'Brien(LOG, Amdocs) : http://jenkins.onap.info/job/oom-cd-master2-aws/217/console
06:22:09 From Michael O'Brien(LOG, Amdocs) : every 6 hours
06:22:59 From Yang Xu : Michael and Seshu, forwarded lab resource assessment meeting to onap-discuss
06:27:12 From Jessica : https://jenkins.opendaylight.org/releng/view/odlparent/job/odlparent-maven-stage-3.1.x/
06:35:27 From Adolfo Perez-Duran : Traveling and need to drop. Please send me any question you may have about containers and footprint optimization.
06:35:49 From Jessica : https://jenkins.onap.org/job/ccsdk-utils-maven-stage-master/4/console
06:39:54 From Taka Cho : @Jess, APPC’s maven-stage jobs failed in different way. I will work with off line.
06:42:16 From Michael O'Brien(LOG, Amdocs) : I can start but I am planning on breaking out my 5 artifacts into separate repos - currently my war, jar(s) jobs all in a single repo
06:45:17 From Catherine Lefevre : prototype is good so we can assess the impacts
06:45:23 From Catherine Lefevre : on the others
06:46:22 From Michael O'Brien(LOG, Amdocs) : release time would be good - It took a week for me to release my artifacts last time
06:46:51 From Michael O'Brien(LOG, Amdocs) : one at atime - not the LF's issue - mine
06:47:34 From Seshu Kumar : So this wouldn't solve the problem you faced isn't it?
06:49:22 From Jessica : Nexus2 migration ticket: https://jira.onap.org/browse/CIMAN-234
06:49:32 From Michael O'Brien(LOG, Amdocs) : the LF time on each release would be reduced - which is good. the goal is to automate ourselves out of a job so we can rise up to the next level
06:51:30 From Michael O'Brien(LOG, Amdocs) : one thing about jira - I think I approved merging my repo change from Jessica in 234 above - just that I don't see the review anymore - which is normal - but it is hard to tell now if a project is missing or already reviewed without manually pasting merged reviews to the ticket
06:55:35 From Catherine Lefevre : I need to drop but i will watch the webcast later. i will provide an update to SECCOM team about the vulnerability management proposal based on TSC vote
06:56:00 From Catherine Lefevre : i still need to update M3 and other templates to include Yang Integration checklist
06:56:11 From Michael O'Brien(LOG, Amdocs) : can we post the recommended oparent version/jira in the wiki
07:03:44 From Michael O'Brien(LOG, Amdocs) : sounds good on aaf - can we get the job name - so we can run the update for customers running the CMR
07:05:12 From Michael O'Brien(LOG, Amdocs) : +1 we need a period before the Dublin and DMR docker releases at the end
07:07:32 From Michael O'Brien(LOG, Amdocs) : logging/pomba is ok for the CMR - just that we are consumers of aaf via dmaap
07:09:07 From Michael O'Brien(LOG, Amdocs) : propose we increase the PTL time to 90 min from 60 - as 1/3 needs to drop off for other meets - and we will need the time as we approach RCx
07:09:08 From Brian : need tsc approved process to create test and release a MR release for Casablanca for the DMaaP DR certificate issue and Security changes (Policy) and perhaps others with security or release breakage fixes
07:10:21 From Michael O'Brien(LOG, Amdocs) : we can move it up - to keep it on 6am not 5
07:15:18 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : https://lf-onap.atlassian.net/wiki/display/DW/2019+Silicon+Valley+Meeting+Proposals
07:15:29 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : link for F2F Subc proposals
07:16:48 From Michael O'Brien(LOG, Amdocs) : helm deploy dev local/onap -f /root/oom/kubernetes/onap/resources/environments/public-cloud.yaml -f /root/oom/kubernetes/onap/resources/overrides/onap-all.yaml -f /root/integration-override.yaml --namespace onap
07:17:31 From Michael O'Brien(LOG, Amdocs) : http://onap-integration.eastus.cloudapp.azure.com:3000/group/onap-integration
07:18:12 From Michael O'Brien(LOG, Amdocs) : https://lf-onap.atlassian.net/wiki/display/DW/RocketChat
07:18:31 From Michael O'Brien(LOG, Amdocs) : I use my personal mac
07:19:17 From Michael O'Brien(LOG, Amdocs) : deleted

the insecure rocketchat page is the goto place for ONAP integration issues - however any links with the LF needed to be deleted today - posting here for word of mouth http://onap-integration.eastus.cloudapp.azure.com:3000/group/onap-integration