TSC 2018-04-19

Date

19 Apr 2018

IRC Minutes

Recording

Full IRC Log 

Zoom Chat Log

Discussion items 

Full IRC Log 

13:46:36 <kennypaul> #startmeeting tsc-2018-04-19
13:46:36 <collabot`> Meeting started Thu Apr 19 13:46:36 2018 UTC.  The chair is kennypaul. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
13:46:36 <collabot`> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic.
13:46:36 <collabot`> The meeting name has been set to 'tsc_2018_04_19'
13:47:14 <kennypaul> #chair phrobb, SteveT, gildaslanilis
13:47:14 <collabot`> Warning: Nick not in channel: gildaslanilis
13:47:14 <collabot`> Current chairs: SteveT gildaslanilis kennypaul phrobb
13:47:29 <kennypaul> #topic rollcall
13:59:04 <SteveT> #info Stephen Terrill, Ericsson
13:59:10 <RajeshGadiyar> #info Rajesh Gadiyar Intel
13:59:43 <cdonley> #info Chris Donley Huawei
14:00:13 <EricDebeau> #info Eric Debeau, Orange
14:00:17 <frankbrockners> #info Frank Brockners, Cisco
14:02:17 <JasonHunt> #info Jason Hunt, IBM
14:02:26 <RannyHaiby> #info Ranny Haiby, Nokia
14:02:30 <davidsauvageau> #info David Sauvageau, Bell
14:04:22 <DhananjayPavgi> #info Dhananjay Pavgi, Tech Mahindra Ltd
14:04:50 <Xiaojun> #info Xiaojun Xie, China Telecom
14:06:29 <SteveT> #topic Housekeeping
14:06:54 <SteveT> #info Meeting change requests, please use the template
14:07:18 <SteveT> #info There is community feedback page, open to feedback and additions.
14:08:23 <SteveT> #info - TSC attendance tracking is avaible.
14:09:26 <xinhuili> #info Xinhui Li, VMware
14:13:46 <SteveT> #info The June developers event is posted on the onap wiki.
14:14:28 <kennypaul> #info murat Tupcuu Turk Telecom
14:15:59 <SteveT> #info Still seeking feedback on whether there is value in colocating OPNFV & ONAP developer event.
14:16:16 <kennypaul> #info Lingli Deng, China Mobile
14:17:06 <Bf1936> Info brianFreeman
14:17:44 <kennypaul> #info Suggestion to push Dublin Release F2F to January rather than december
14:17:45 <Bf1936> Info proxy brianfreeman, at&t
14:18:04 <kennypaul> #topic Known Vulnerability Analysis update
14:18:31 <kennypaul> #info SteveT presented his slides
14:18:31 <ningso> #info Ning So, Reliance Jio
14:20:10 <kennypaul> #info [policy] will be addressed today.
14:21:10 <kennypaul> #topic APEX PDP in ONAP Policy Framework
14:21:33 <kennypaul> #info Liam Fallon shared his slided
14:22:38 <kennypaul> #info Policy is the decision making component of onap
14:23:30 <kennypaul> #info other components responsible for enforcing the rules policy provides to them
14:23:43 <kennypaul> #info technology agnostic
14:24:09 <kennypaul> #info supports moltiple PDP types
14:25:35 <kennypaul> #info PDP-X for XACML, PDP-D for Drools
14:26:24 <kennypaul> #info PDP-x best for fine-grained policy, PDP-D best fot stateful policies
14:26:46 <kennypaul> #info APEX is a new code contribution for ONAP
14:28:47 <kennypaul> #info APEX extends the policy framework in design time and runtime
14:29:18 <kennypaul> #info runtime requires a single JSON file to be pushed
14:29:50 <kennypaul> #info Other plugins can be written
14:30:29 <kennypaul> #info supports large deployments. policy monitoring
14:31:07 <kennypaul> #info Q- multiple policy engines ?
14:31:40 <kennypaul> #info A- captured via policy modles and then translated.
14:32:44 <kennypaul> #info discussion od implementation
14:33:40 <kennypaul> #info main take away here is that there is a new code contribution coming in that the community needs to be aware of
14:35:24 <kennypaul> #info please attend the policy meeting or offline
14:35:41 <kennypaul> #info request preso to Arch Sub meeting
14:36:21 <kennypaul> #info Beijing RC0 Review
14:37:16 <kennypaul> #info gildaslanilis shared his slide decl
14:38:23 <kennypaul> #info healthchecks OOM 9done, Heat 16 done, WIP- OOM 16, Heat 8
14:39:18 <kennypaul> #info CSIT 19 projects pass, 4 WIP, 1 no plan
14:40:11 <kennypaul> #info ~ 30 pending commits to be reviewed
14:41:48 <kennypaul> #info clamp good
14:42:26 <kennypaul> #info ccsdk no heat/oom needed
14:43:10 <kennypaul> #info dmaap had met M4 delioverabes
14:43:25 <kennypaul> #info holmes passed M4
14:43:42 <kennypaul> #info modeling good
14:44:00 <kennypaul> #info msb good
14:44:16 <kennypaul> #info multicloud
14:44:38 <kennypaul> #undo
14:44:38 <collabot`> Removing item from minutes: <MeetBot.ircmeeting.items.Info object at 0x28dc810>
14:46:02 <kennypaul> #info vid cist is wip, oom healthcheck is now passing
14:47:06 <kennypaul> #info appc csit 1 failure coce coverage now > 50%
14:47:31 <kennypaul> #info aai oom now passing
14:47:57 <kennypaul> #info vulnerability will be asddressed by RC1
14:49:08 <kennypaul> #info multicloud, so, vfc, oom, integration, vnfrts, doc all palss
14:49:25 <kennypaul> #info policy should padss my today
14:49:59 <kennypaul> #info vnfsdc healthcheck should be complete today
14:51:07 <kennypaul> #info dcae - eta for oom apr 26
14:52:35 <kennypaul> #info cli - oom patch submitted eta tomorrow, heat healthcheck passing
14:53:17 <kennypaul> #info healthchecks need to be run by the person submitting the patch first.
14:54:49 <kennypaul> #info music at this stage only libraries. passes in heat, N/A for OOM in this release. embedded in portal
14:55:30 <kennypaul> #info portal - csit and oom wip- blocker for integration
14:55:59 <kennypaul> #info csit passing now.
14:57:16 <kennypaul> #info cassandra dependencies. issues identified and being worked on
15:00:43 <kennypaul> #info cassandra fix has been submitted - need updated version of Kubernetes 1.8.10
15:03:20 <kennypaul> #info extapi - cist still failing - fix applied to be tested, heat now working
15:03:39 <kennypaul> #info oom heralthcheck apr 26
15:04:05 <kennypaul> #info sdnc- csit now passing and heat. oom still failing
15:05:38 <kennypaul> #info oom issues unknown. will contact james for debuggin assisatance
15:07:34 <kennypaul> #info sdc- heat heat by tomorrow, oom april 26?? code coverage- code broken fixed
15:08:59 <kennypaul> #info will be back to 30% by end of week, other is passing internally, but not with onap
15:09:16 <kennypaul> #info eta RC1 for 50% code coverage
15:10:32 <kennypaul> #info aaf- code coverage not met - 2 people assigend
15:13:17 <kennypaul> #info working on heat first priority, eta tomorrow - marco assisting
15:13:47 <kennypaul> #info oom eta april 26
15:15:28 <kennypaul> #info priority working system, heat, oom and then code coverage
15:16:49 <kennypaul> #info oof- 17 jiras that should have been addresses are still open, healthchecks fialing
15:17:33 <kennypaul> #info heat eta tomorrow, oom reviewing eta apr 26
15:18:55 <kennypaul> #info 17 pending jiras will be addressed by RC1
15:19:21 <kennypaul> #info so is dependent on oof - no testing of this yet
15:20:16 <kennypaul> #info requesting help with oom
15:23:41 <kennypaul> #info asking for expedited reviews of optf-has commit - sastry ooo
15:25:20 <kennypaul> #info catherine will provide resources to oof team, so team will also provide help
15:26:36 <kennypaul> #info vvp passes m4 noe, says Heat is an N/A item
15:28:48 <kennypaul> #info logging - no Heat n/a . code coverage blocked by a shared java/python pom file
15:30:25 <DhananjayPavgi> Exit
15:30:49 <kennypaul> #info no csit plan- no library now, casablanca deliverable. Michael O to write something.
15:33:18 <kennypaul> #info usecase-ui M4- not finding codecoverage and FOSS
15:33:54 <kennypaul> #info shentow needs to provide an update
15:37:30 <kennypaul> #info no longer at quorom, but consensus of those on call all pass m4 and are approved for RC0
15:37:42 <kennypaul> #topic integration
15:39:05 <kennypaul> #info helenchen shared her status page - most pairwise testing not done.
15:40:09 <kennypaul> #info request to review again on PTL meeting.
15:41:59 <kennypaul> #info suggestion that we have NOT passed M4
15:43:43 <kennypaul> #info discussions of checklists
15:44:55 <kennypaul> #info gildaslanilis recommends that any runtime projects that pass oom healthcheck pass RC0
15:47:21 <kennypaul> #info need more stringent enforcement as we move from Rc0 -> Rc1 > Rc2
15:51:01 <kennypaul> #info need to agree what each gate specifically means
15:54:18 <kennypaul> #info brian f recommends that no one cuts a beijing branch until they pass oom healthcheck
15:55:14 <kennypaul> #info "unless the jira ticket comes from helen folks shouldn't be working on it at this point"
15:57:59 <kennypaul> #info ptls should check with helen on status of pairwise testing
15:58:35 <kennypaul> #info mazin suggests clear definition of RC0 for Beiging, may be different for Casablanca
15:59:18 <kennypaul> #info mazin would like to see pairwise testing included as an RC0
15:59:56 <kennypaul> #info helen points out critaria set at santaclara
16:03:38 <kennypaul> #info much discussion over deliverables / requiorements
16:04:11 <kennypaul> #info chris recommends an email vote on RC0
16:04:46 <kennypaul> #info mazin concerned over changing the dates
16:05:31 <kennypaul> #info action gildaslanilis to send email on what projects passed from his perspective.
16:08:56 <kennypaul> #info Will review again at next week's meeting and then present options to the TSC.
16:09:37 <kennypaul> #info helen reviewed S3P requirements we committed to
16:13:13 <kennypaul> #info correction - gildaslanilis to present status at the next PTL Meeting - NOT via email.
19:27:52 <kennypaul> #endmeeting

Zoom Chat Log 

07:02:57 From Gildas Lanilis - Huawei : @Michael. Do it mean u r happy?
07:02:59 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : However openlab - running now seeing better but ~2mb/sec still have 81 after 4 min - usually down to 60 by now left - will post results in 20-40 min
07:03:30 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : outside network = very good, inside intel lab - half speed?
07:03:41 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : but we are better - thanks
07:06:16 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : kenny - very much thank you for the link URLs
07:06:31 From Susana (VF) : Sorry, i cannot connect to the IRC. But connected
07:07:42 From Lingli : me too
07:11:42 From Murat Turpcu : me too
07:13:30 From Lingli : It is not accurately reflecting our presence from the table. Rarely login on to the IRC for TSC calls.
07:16:43 From Kenny Paul (Linux Foundation) : Murat/Lingli I’ve logged you
07:19:30 From Pamela Dragosh (AT&T, Policy, CL) : Policy - will have everything addressed today.
07:20:27 From Pamela Dragosh (AT&T, Policy, CL) : :)
07:20:40 From Pamela Dragosh (AT&T, Policy, CL) : Will do, thanks Steve.
07:26:34 From HZ : Is xcaml used in ONAP? what's the relationship with AAF?
07:26:43 From Pamela Dragosh (AT&T, Policy, CL) : Yes XACML is used.
07:27:13 From Pamela Dragosh (AT&T, Policy, CL) : AAF is a coarse-grained security for application level access. XACML provides fine-grained, it can be used on in addition to AAF.
07:27:46 From Alexander Vul : why do we need so many different ways to specify policies?
07:28:09 From HZ : Which project is using xacml?
07:28:09 From Pamela Dragosh (AT&T, Policy, CL) : Because policy decisions and enforcement has different scenarios. One PDP engine cannot do everything.
07:28:13 From Alexander Vul : Would we be better off having one normative way for policy specification?
07:28:19 From Pamela Dragosh (AT&T, Policy, CL) : HZ - the Policy Framework is using XACML
07:28:49 From Pamela Dragosh (AT&T, Policy, CL) : Alex, it isn’t about specifying policy. Its about how does it get enforced. Some PDPs do a better job than others in different situations.
07:29:01 From Pamela Dragosh (AT&T, Policy, CL) : If it was clear that one PDP engine could do it all, we would use it. But it isn't.
07:29:24 From Pamela Dragosh (AT&T, Policy, CL) : Specifying policy should be completely independent of the technology used to implement it.
07:30:01 From Vimal Begwani -- ATT : Use of XACML is somewhat limited, Drool is well suited for stateful policiesi, APEX colud support some scenario better than Drool
07:30:08 From HZ : Policy is using xcaml for access control of itself?
07:30:27 From Pamela Dragosh (AT&T, Policy, CL) : For ONAP no it is not yet. But that functionality is available for the community to use if they want.
07:34:41 From Alexander Vul : I think we need to start thinking of policies from a command and control perspective - as marching orders sent to specific ONAP components and based on which they operate. this was the "mother, may I" conversations would be limited to exception conditions, when a given component does not know what to do
07:35:22 From Eric Debeau : We need to prioritize RC0 topics and problems
07:36:58 From Kenny Paul (Linux Foundation) : @Liam please upload & linke the slides on the meeting agenda page
07:37:44 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : Healthcheck 26-27 out of 34
07:37:45 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) :

http://kibana.onap.info:5601/app/kibana#/dashboard/AWAtvpS63NTXK5mX2kuS?_g=(refreshInterval:(display:Off,pause:!f,value:0),time:(from:now-7d,mode:quick,to:now))&_a=(description:'',filters:!(),options:(darkTheme:!f),panels:!((col:1,id:AWAts77k3NTXK5mX2kuM,panelIndex:1,row:1,size_x:8,size_y:3,type:visualization),(col:9,id:AWAtuTVI3NTXK5mX2kuP,panelIndex:2,row:1,size_x:4,size_y:3,type:visualization),(col:1,id:AWAtuBTY3NTXK5mX2kuO,panelIndex:3,row:7,size_x:6,size_y:3,type:visualization),(col:1,id:AWAttmqB3NTXK5mX2kuN,panelIndex:4,row:4,size_x:6,size_y:3,type:visualization),(col:7,id:AWAtvHtY3NTXK5mX2kuR,panelIndex:6,row:4,size_x:6,size_y:6,type:visualization)),query:(match_all:()),timeRestore:!f,title:'CD%20Health%20Check',uiState:(),viewMode:view)

07:37:46 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : for oom
07:38:16 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : 26/34 for OOM this morning - http://jenkins.onap.info/job/oom-cd-master/2720/console
07:38:46 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : Healthcheck lockdown jira
07:38:47 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : https://jira.onap.org/browse/OOM-960
07:40:01 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : some of these are cassablanca level
07:40:13 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : the pending commits I mean
07:44:03 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : The highs are specific to the last 7 healthchecks for OOM - should be
07:44:49 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : I see them working
07:44:50 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : 13:17:03 onap dev-vid-74c5bb5d69-ld5nn 2/2 Running 0 1h
13:17:03 onap dev-vid-mariadb-9bbff4865-j2pkl 1/1 Running 0 1h
07:44:57 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : http://jenkins.onap.info/job/oom-cd-master/2720/console
07:45:42 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : 13:23:37 Basic VID Health Check | PASS |
07:47:36 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : pass
07:47:37 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : 13:21:30 Basic A&AI Health Check | PASS |
07:48:09 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : 13:21:33 Basic Policy Health Check | PASS |
07:48:13 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : on my lab
07:48:56 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : policy up ol
07:48:57 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : 13:17:03 onap dev-pap-bd6f978c5-rwm5w 2/2 Running 0 1h, 13:17:03 onap dev-pdp-0 2/2 Running 0 1h, 13:17:03 onap dev-pdp-1 2/2 Running 0 52m, 13:17:03 onap dev-policydb-5dbb9b54df-jfhch 1/1 Running 0 1h
07:49:09 From Pamela Dragosh (AT&T, Policy, CL) : Thanks Michael!
07:51:41 From Liam Fallon (Ericsson) : @Paul Kenny I have just uploaded the slides and links for the presentation to the agenda
07:52:13 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : https://gerrit.onap.org/r/#/q/status:open+project:+oom+cli
07:59:09 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : Mandeep found we needed Kubernetes 1.8.10 - upgraded
08:00:32 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : https://gerrit.onap.org/r/#/q/status:open+project:+oom+portal
08:00:53 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : make sure your "kubectl version" says 1.8.10 on both client/server
08:03:55 From Catherine Lefevre : not sure people can hear me - externalapi m4 ok?
08:05:00 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : James'
08:05:00 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : https://gerrit.onap.org/r/#/c/43453/
08:06:32 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : sdc pods are good - agree how HC is run
08:06:33 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : 3:17:03 onap dev-sdc-be-5db548fcd8-4z9cc 2/2 Running 0 1h
13:17:03 onap dev-sdc-be-config-backend-cc459 0/1 Pending 0 27m
13:17:03 onap dev-sdc-cs-56bf4b4747-tv96m 1/1 Running 0 1h
13:17:03 onap dev-sdc-es-5ff48cc798-plphr 1/1 Running 0 1h
13:17:03 onap dev-sdc-fe-7fc94ff5d9-9bwtw 2/2 Running 0 1h
13:17:03 onap dev-sdc-kb-64884d65f4-dw8cz 1/1 Running 0 1h
13:17:03 onap dev-sdc-wfd-5b5d4f58f6-6zp76 1/1 Running 0 1h
08:26:15 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : Logging HC just needs a merge -
08:26:16 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : https://gerrit.onap.org/r/#/c/43593/ .  https://gerrit.onap.org/r/#/c/43589 .  https://jira.onap.org/browse/OOM-914
08:26:49 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : For Logging code coverage -
08:26:51 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : fixed sonar oparent blocker -   https://jira.onap.org/browse/LOG-189
but issue running python and java in the same repo/pom - investigating if ciman work required
08:27:27 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : Note: logging HEAT Healthcheck will be n/a because the ELK stack is only in OOM by design since amsterdam
08:31:56 From Catherine Lefevre : can we get status regarding projects that did not get previously their m4 ? are these all good now? thanks
08:31:59 From Catherine Lefevre : i need to drop
08:33:05 From Michael O'Brien (Log, Amdocs) : need to drop for log spec meet - sorry
08:40:56 From Susana (VF) : also disconnecting\