30 May 2019	2019 TSC Recordings	Zoom Chat Log	Zoom Attendance Log	2019 TSC Decisions

Duration 90 minutes - https://zoom.us/j/661303200

@4pm CET/10am EST/7am PST/10pm China Time/7.30pm India Time

Agenda Items	Presented By	Time	Notes/Links	JIRA Tasks
Dublin Release RC2 Review	Former user (Deleted)	35 mins	TSC approved Sonar Waiver requested by AAF, SDC and Multi-Cloud (13 "Approve All", no other votes cast) DCAE-DS – 52.6% - https://sonar.onap.org/dashboard?id=org.onap.sdc.dcae-d.dt-be-main%3Adcae_dt_be_main%3Amaster. This repository is used by SDC and is part of the Waiver request MUSIC – 53.3% -https://sonar.onap.org/dashboard?id=org.onap.music%3AMUSIC Latest "Release" Images? Security Feedback - Vulnerability Tables, CII Bagding, Release Note, OSJI, etc. - 26 CVE issued, pushing updates of release notes - please merge ASAP Pair-wise Testing: Integration Weather Board for Dublin Release - Integration Weather Board for Dublin Release Current Completion Status: Portal (77%) and S0 (89%) Integration Blockers: Dublin Release Integration Test Blocking Issues Remaining Highest/High Defects: Defect Status for Dublin Integration Tests Status: Dublin Release Integration Testing Status 34 use cases/functional/non-functional requirements require E2E testing. 14 out of 34 are completed (including N/A) 10 out of 34 are at >=70% test completion 10 out of 34 <70% test completion Documentation Tickets: Documentation Status for Dublin Projects: Project Status in Dublin Release 30 projects 14 out of 30 are completed 14 out of 30 are in progress - blockers and/or documentation 2 out of 30 no information - Integration, MUSIC Dublin release branch NOT created – Long list to the right.... except Documentation since 5/15 (so cherry-pick) RC2 TSC Recommendations - NO GO Review Marketing Messages - https://lists.onap.org/g/onap-discuss/message/17065 Please update JIRA bugs, tasks, user stories, etc, but do not close tickets when the work is not done JIRA Query - Remaining 692 Items status != Closed AND status != Done AND project != "Sandbox Project" AND project != CI-Management AND project != "ONAP TSC" and fixVersion = "Dublin Release" ORDER BY key ASC, priority DESC, updated DESC No Medium, Low, Lowest defect to be fixed at this stage on Dublin branch - only High/Highest Remaining Timeline: Release Sign-Off: June 6th, 2019 (TBC)	Repos missing Dublin branch: aaf-authz aaf-cadi aaf-inno aaf-luaplugin aaf-sms aaf-sshsm aai-aai-config (dormant/deprecated) aai-aai-data (dormant/deprecated) aai-aai-service (dormant/deprecated) aai-eis (dormant/deprecated) aai-enricher (dormant/deprecated) aai-gap (dormant/deprecated) aai-tabular-data-service (dormant/deprecated) aai-test-config (dormant/deprecated) ccsdk-platform-blueprints ccsdk-platform-nbapi ccsdk-storage-esaas ccsdk-storage-pgaas dcaegen2-analytics dcaegen2-analytics-flink dcaegen2-analytics-pnda dcaegen2-analytics-tca-gen2 dcaegen2-collectors dcaegen2-platform dcaegen2-platform-cdapbroker dcaegen2-platform-registrator dcaegen2-platform-servicechange-handler externalapi-nbi holmes-common holmes-dsa holmes-engine-management holmes-rule-management integration integration-benchmark integration-devtool integration-seccom logging-analytics logging-analytics-pomba logging-analytics-pomba-pomba-aai-context-builder logging-analytics-pomba-pomba-audit-common logging-analytics-pomba-pomba-context-aggregator logging-analytics-pomba-pomba-network-discovery-context-builder logging-analytics-pomba-pomba-sdc-context-builder logging-analytics-pomba-pomba-sdnc-context-builder modeling-genericparser modeling-javatoscachecker modeling-toscaparsers msb-apigateway msb-discovery msb-java-sdk msb-service-mesh msb-swagger-sdk multicloud-azure multicloud-framework multicloud-k8s multicloud-openstack multicloud-openstack-vmware multicloud-openstack-windriver music-distributed-kv-store music-mdbc music-prom oom oom-offline-installer oom-registrator oparent oparent-cia (no changes during Dublin) optf-cmso optf-fgps optf-has optf-osdf policy policy-core policy-gui policy-pdp portal portal-sdk sdc-onap-ui sdc-sdc-be-common sdnc sdnc-adaptors sdnc-architecture sdnc-core sdnc-features sdnc-parent sdnc-plugins testsuite-properties ui ui-dmaapbc university usecase-ui usecase-ui-server vfc-gvnfm-vnflcm vfc-gvnfm-vnfmgr vfc-gvnfm-vnfres vfc-nfvo-catalog vfc-nfvo-db vfc-nfvo-driver-ems vfc-nfvo-driver-sfc vfc-nfvo-driver-vnfm-gvnfm vfc-nfvo-driver-vnfm-svnfm vfc-nfvo-lcm vfc-nfvo-multivimproxy vfc-nfvo-resmanagement vfc-nfvo-wfengine vid-asdcclient vnfrqts vnfrqts-epics vnfrqts-guidelines vnfrqts-requirements vnfrqts-testcases vnfrqts-usecases vnfsdk vnfsdk-compliance vnfsdk-dovetail-integration vnfsdk-ice vnfsdk-model vvp vvp-ansible-ice-bootstrap vvp-cms vvp-devkit vvp-engagementmgr vvp-gitlab vvp-image-scanner vvp-jenkins vvp-portal vvp-postgresql vvp-test-engine
Any Infrastructure Improvement/Plan	Linux Foundation	15 mins	One release request PER helpdesk ticket - once it is acted upon and closed, further transactions are ignored. Jenkins/gerrit service outages review Cause massive https pulls from gerrit rather than SSH Considered disabling https access however some companies block SSH Infra team look at throttling https requests to gerrit Can always use github CLA enforcement starts July 1st - emails distributed yesterday to official LFN contacts - these require a response by June 14th Any LF showstopper Open Completed #75732: Issues after gerrit upgrade #75728] Jira & Wiki account #75873: Creating a new repo under SDC #75883: Please add Ram and Jim as Policy Committers #75896: Enable per patchset sonar scans for CLAMP #76125: SO released artifacts 1.4.2 #75479: Release of OOF RC0 artifacts - the re-release request over a week after ticket was closed #75986: Please release SO libs artifacts #76249: Gerrit server still flaky
PTL Update - CIA	Adolfo Perez-Duran	35 mins	Alpine upstream packaging changed - breaking the ONAP build - CIA team to review and recommend long term strategy Managing the Life Cycle of ONAP Common Base Images
Subcommittee Update - Security	Lincoln Lavoie abdel.rabi	15 mins	CVC discussion for El Alto TOSCA VNF progress and plan for El Alto report guochuyi NOT covered move to next week -must be covered next week to drive the discussions at the DDF
PTL Update - Integration	Alexis de Talhouët Brian Freeman	10 mins	In ODL, for instance, during release time-frame a few folks are granted “Supercommitter” rights, empowering them with merge rights on all repos. That way, when version number changes, or bug fix validated but no one to merge, etc., these set of people can take care of merging the needed patches and getting the release forward. Given our current structure in ONAP, where the integration team as to “vouch” for the state of ONAP before its release, it could make sense having Integration’s committer given such right.
Frankfurt Release	cl664y@att.com Former user (Deleted)	10 mins	Frankfurt Activity's plan proposal from M0 to M1 ONAP Frankfurt (from M0 to M1) Proposal_V1.xlsx NOT covered move to next week
TSC Activities and Deadlines	cl664y@att.com Kenny Paul	5 mins	Nomination(s) for Strategic Planning Committee (SPC) representative - Alla Goldner, Timo Perala - Ballots Distributed yesterday - voting ends 14:00 pacific on June 3 https://lists.onap.org/g/onap-tsc/message/5008 Email vote for approval of license exceptions will be sent today.
Incoming ONAP Events	cl664y@att.com Kenny Paul	5 mins	The next DDF event will be organized in Stockholm from June 11th to June 14th 2019 jointly with other LFN Open source communities i.e. OPNFV, Tungsten Fabric, etc. https://lists.onap.org/g/onap-tsc/message/4906 ONAP Joint SubC Meetings Europe (September, Belgium) - Vote in progress before or after ONS Europe https://lists.onap.org/g/onap-tsc/message/5062 Decision on Nov 18th, 2019 for next ONAP DDF Event

Zoom Chat Log

06:56:05 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #topic rollcall
06:59:04 From Murat Turpcu,Turk Telekom : #info Murat Turpcu,Turk Telekom
07:00:50 From Yan Chen : #info YAN CHEN，China Telecom
07:00:52 From bin.yang@windriver.com : #info Bin Yang, Wind River
07:01:04 From ALLAGO : #info Alla Goldner, Amdocs
07:01:06 From John D'Elia : #info John Proxy Viswa, Verizon
07:01:12 From Catherine Lefevre : #info, Catherine Lefevre, ONAP TSC
07:01:20 From Ofir Sonsino (AT&T) : #info Ofir Sonsino, AT&T
07:02:09 From Prudence Au : #info Prudence Au, Amdocs
07:02:29 From Adrian O'Sullivan : #info Adrian O’Sullivan Proxy, Huawei
07:02:38 From Stephen Terrill : #info, Stephen Terrill, Ericsson
07:03:05 From Lingli : #info Lingli, CMCC
07:03:05 From Alexis de Talhouët : #info, Alexis de Talhouët, Bell Canada
07:03:43 From Yipan Deng (Intel) : #info proxy Yipan Deng, Intel Corp. (Proxy for Srinivasa Addepalli)
07:04:52 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #topic RC2 Milestone
07:05:35 From Milind Jalwadi : #info Milind Jalwadi, TechMahindra
07:05:53 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : @Jim - code coverage waivers approved
07:07:44 From Pawel Pawlak (Orange) : #info proxy Pawel Pawlak, Orange
07:08:37 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : @Shankar - results may be because have not branched.
07:08:56 From Atul Purohit (Vodafone) : #info Atul Purohit, proxy Vodafone
07:09:07 From Sitharaman : #info Sitha, IBM proxy for Jason Hunt
07:09:35 From Yang Xu : Brian Freeman will delegate Integration team today
07:09:39 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #ACTION JB to put forward a waiver vote for MUSIC
07:11:19 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : @Catherine reminds PTLs to notify the Integration team when blocker bugs are closed
07:13:03 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #SECCOM - @Krzystof - documenting vulnerabilities in release notes - expectation is that these will be fixed in El Alto
07:13:48 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #some projects will lose CII badging due to hard codes passwwds
07:14:19 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #JIRAs submitted for missing reports
07:14:31 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #26 CVEs issued.
07:15:19 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : ##Pairwise testing
07:15:39 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #all done except SO and Portal
07:15:53 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : ##INtegration test blockers
07:16:49 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #@Brian - behjind from an RC2 perspective. new blockers still being opened.
07:16:57 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : ## bugs
07:17:21 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : # ~6 High/Higest open
07:17:41 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : ## Integration test status
07:18:34 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #vCPE w/ TOSCA marked green but only at 50%
07:19:41 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #Scaleout under 70% @Scott Blandford will not be able to address in next few days.
07:20:33 From Timo Perala (Nokia) : #info Timo Perala, Nokia
07:20:41 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #@Brian we need better alignment on colorcoding - a 50% should be red not green
07:22:08 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #CCVPN - @Yan issues with lab - powered off due to move - 2 remaining test cases - currently at 70%
07:22:15 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : ##Docs
07:22:23 From Manoop Talasila - AT&T : #Portal team should be able to wrap up on vulnerability table remaining 30% by May 31st EOD.
07:22:41 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #@Jim does not feel warm and fuzzy
07:23:12 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : ##Project Status Board
07:24:01 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #still a lot of yellow - only half complete, half blocked by integration r docs
07:24:27 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : ##Dublin branch
07:25:28 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #Many repos without a Dublin branch
07:26:12 From Keong : it might be difficult to explain how to correctly pull the dublin branch consistently
07:26:24 From Keong : if a dublin branch doesn't exist in the repo
07:27:06 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #ccsdk, dcae have had no updates to the repos listed. Will not cut new branch, policy repos listed are read only
07:27:29 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #ACTION JB to rerun tool and discard readonly repos
07:31:03 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : ##JIRAs - please keep in mind that el-alto is for non-functional content. All functional content should be moved to Frankfurt
07:32:20 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : @Terrill - there can be soem gray area between functional and non-functional in a technical debt context
07:34:12 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : # https://lf-onap.atlassian.net/wiki/display/DW/El-Alto+Release+Requirements
07:34:36 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : ^^ contains the release priorities
07:35:01 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : @JB there will be a session at DDF to review content
07:35:29 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #JB Recommends not approving RC2 content.
07:36:52 From Brian : Use onap-discuss to notify integration about release requests
07:37:24 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #topic LF RelEng/Infra
07:38:25 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : # IMPORTANT Only one ticket per release - do not keep adding additional requests to a closed ticket.
07:38:59 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : ##jenkins/gerrit issues
07:39:30 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #@Jessica - swamped by calls to HTTPS vs. SSH
07:39:39 From Brian : the following projects have had updates in the last 2 weeks so everyone else's release dockers are older than 2 weeks
onap/policy-pap <none> bd442f5d9e87 6 days ago 387MB
onap/org.onap.dcaegen2.services.son-handler 1.0.2 8ce1d06c7792 9 days ago 787MB
onap/org.onap.dcaegen2.deployments.tca-cdap-container 1.1.2 ac14bef876b9 10 days ago 2.72GB
onap/org.onap.dcaegen2.deployments.k8s-bootstrap-container 1.4.18 b50e14211588 10 days ago 628MB
onap/org.onap.dcaegen2.collectors.datafile.datafile-app-server 1.1.3 9fa547737f9c 10 days ago 171MB
onap/vnfsdk/refrepo 1.3.0 c367a21b32c7 10 days ago 848MB
onap/org.onap.dcaegen2.services.son-handler 1.0.1 c18bc2225d44 13 days ago 787MB onap/org.onap.dcaegen2.deploy
07:40:06 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #teams need to double check that jobs are using SSH unless absolutely necessarry.
07:41:46 From Brian : ssh is blocked by corporate firewalls
07:41:56 From Sai seshu : @Brian so 1.4.2 is released :)
07:42:21 From Brian : @seshu - have you submitted a change to oom ?
07:42:55 From Sai seshu : Was waiting for the merge from lf... Gotcha... Thanks
07:43:31 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #@Bengt looking at throttling https
07:44:13 From Keong : would it help to do anonymous pulls from the github clone instead of from gerrit?
07:44:34 From Jessica W - LF : yes it will
07:45:20 From Jessica W - LF : using github when possible is a good idea...but might not be a good idea if you want to contribute back to the code unless you add the proper remote to push to gerrit instead
07:47:15 From Catherine Lefevre : #action Catherine to collect information from companies about their needs to pull code from github
07:47:18 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #ACTION Cathering will compile the information on which companies block SSH to gerrit
07:49:49 From Brian : @Melliot - when do you plan to branch oom for dublin - seeing folks trying to add El Alto stuff
07:53:23 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : ## CLA inforcement is coming on July 1.
07:54:39 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #will accomodate both domainbased whitelists, named user whitlisting and independent contributors
07:55:15 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #topic Common ONAP Base images
07:55:45 From Keong : if they are all on common starting point, how will upgrades to the next version be coordinated? there may be blocking inter-dependencies
07:55:56 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #@Adolfo reviewed the content linke in the wiki
07:57:41 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #ACTION @Adolfo to upload the pdf of the preso to the wiki minutes
07:58:56 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #concerns regarding upstream updates impacting ONAP dev teams
07:59:28 From Keong : what is the target figure for reusability % ?
07:59:56 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #a common alpine distribution could help that issue
08:01:19 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #have a stabel OS mirror so that buuilds do not break
08:15:06 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #Catherine recommends SECCOM input on which version to use. Also role of the Integration team needs to be taken into account
08:16:38 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #@Pam thinks is it is a good plan - needs to take late issues into account
08:17:33 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #ACTION @Adolfo meet with SECCOM on a recommended version and work with PTLs
08:18:19 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #@Terrill where does the consens get made?
08:19:14 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #@Adolfo responsibility fo the CIA team to consolidate input
08:21:17 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #@Adolfo existing images for ONAP is the baseline
08:23:08 From Brian : Looks like good idea; worth pursuing with PTLs and SecCom
08:23:14 From Keong : how can it be "normative' if nobody is forced to use it?
08:25:54 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #No objections on the approach - in line with SECCOM's thinking.
08:26:13 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #AGREED PTL meeting meeting is the place for approving version
08:27:49 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : #topic Not covered items
08:28:10 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : Frankfurt Release Planning
08:28:36 From Brian : Please shutdown VMs and stop using console on horizon portal if you can
08:28:48 From Brian : to reduce load on windriver
08:29:02 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : CVC update not covered
08:29:15 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : move to next week
08:30:52 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : TSC Activities list reviewed
08:32:17 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : upcoming event items covered
08:34:18 From Stephen Terrill : Kenny, just to note that "BCC" emails (such as vote) causes interesting effects to the "email filters" that people use
08:37:30 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : understood but that is the only way to cut cross talk
08:38:52 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : I guess I could try locking the topic in groups.io as soon as I send it.

Zoom Attendance Log

TSC Members Attendance based on Zoom Chat Log: 89%

Ascension Day in Europe on May 30th, 2019

AMDOCS	1	Alla Goldner
AT&T	1	Catherine Lefevre
Bell Canada	1	Alexis de Talhouët
China Mobile	1	Lingli Deng
China Telecom	1	Yan Chen
DT		Andreas Geissler
Ericsson	1	Stephen Terrill
Huawei	1	Adrian OSullivan, proxy for Chaker Al-Hakim
IBM	1	Sitha, proxy for Jason Hunt
Intel	1	Yipan Deng, proxy for Srini Addepalli
Nokia	1	Timo Perala
Orange	1	Pawel Pawlak, proxy for Eric Debeau
Reliance Jio		Ning So
Tech Mahindra	1	Milind Jalwadi
Turk Telecom	1	Murat Tupcu
Verizon	1	John d'Ella, Proxy for Viswa Kumar Skand Priya
Vodafone	1	Atul Purohit, proxy for Susana Sabater
WindRiver	1	Bin Yang

TSC Decisions

2019 TSC Decisions

Action Items:

30 May 2019 Former user (Deleted) Rerun tool and discard readonly repos from branch list
30 May 2019 Former user (Deleted) to put forward an email waiver vote for MUSIC

El Alto M3 checklist improvements for the security questions. Paweł Pawlak
(SECCOM): Review Vulnerabilities that require significant rework, architecture change as "TSC MUST Have" candidates for El Alto
Brian, Jess, Paul) to create a timeline considering our ONAP release roadmap including steps required for the multi-arch pipeline

Browser not supported