APPC Meeting Minutes - (Jan'19 - May'19)

Owned by Takamune Cho
Last updated: May 31, 2019
13 min read

1/2/19 - APPC Project Weekly Minute

Participants:Takamune Cho,  Patrick Brady,  Aaron Hay, Ramya Balaji, Joss Armstrong,  Surendra Reddy, Fari Behi

Agenda

  • Casablanca Mtn Release status
  • Dublin release plan

Action item

  • Casablanca Mtn Release: 1/10/2019 Docker release, 1/24/2019 release note, 1/31/2019 Sign-off
    Issues/Bugs fix: CCSDK new image, DMaap issue
  • Dublin M1 Planning: (draft) 1/17/2019 ( Dublin Release Requirements )
    • New ConfigScaleIn LCM action
    • distributeTraffic support on VM level
    • Runtime: manage a switcher in APPC to know the coming request is LCM action or blueprint TOSCA – R5
    • Design time: CDT/CDS GUI integration
    • ODL upgrade: Fluorine SR2
    • Platform Maturity:
    • ScaleIn
    • Change Management (CM)
    • Controller Design Studio (CDS)



1/9/19 - APPC Project Weekly Minute

Participants:Takamune Cho,  Patrick Brady,  Aaron Hay, Ramya Balaji , Joss Armstrong ,  Lathishbabu Ganesan

Agenda

  • Casablanca Mtn Release status
  • Dublin release plan

Action item

  • Casablanca Mtn Release: CCSDK new image, DMaap issue
  • Traffic Migration Demo by Orange team (they are in Paris, waiting their response)
  • Dublin Planning: (draft)
    • Performance: Level 2
      • Level 1: baseline performance criteria identified and measured  (such as response time, transaction/message rate, latency, footprint, etc. to be defined on per component)
      • Level 2: performance improvement plan created 
      • unzip feature.zip during building docker. - (Patrick)
      • Remove un-used bundles from CCSDK’s odlsli - (Taka)
    • Stability: Level 2
    • Resiliency: Level 2
      • Level 2: support automated failure detection & rerouting 
        • within a single geographic site
        • stateless components: establish baseline measure of failed requests for a component failure within a site 
        • stateful components: establish baseline of data loss for a component failure within a site
      • OOM: move to variable for database’s user/password - (Aaron)
      • CSIT OOM (Integration)
    • Security:
      • Absolute Minimum expectation:
        • CII badging passing level
        • Continuously retaining no critical or high known vulnerabilities > 60 days old
        • All communication shall be able to be encrypted and have common role-based access control and authorization.
      • Desired expectation is full CII badging silver level, if not 75% towards that.
    • Scalability: Level 1
      • Level 1: supports single site horizontal scale out and scale in, independent of other component
      • APPC does not support dynamic cluster configuration in k8s only support static cluster configuration
      • Clustering env with downstream: netconf(Aaron), ansible (Asking Orange team),  -
    • Manageability: Level 2
    • Usability: Level 2
      • Level 2:



NO Recording for this meeting, since ONAP 4 room has been occupied by F2F event in Paris.


1/16/19 - APPC Project Weekly Minute

Participants:Takamune Cho,  Patrick Brady,Ramya Balaji, Joss Armstrong, Fari Behi, J Hartley, Lathishbabu Ganesan

Agenda

  • Casablanca Mtn Release status
  • Dublin release plan

Action item

  • Level 2: support automated failure detection & rerouting 
    • within a single geographic site
    • stateless components: establish baseline measure of failed requests for a component failure within a site 
    • stateful components: establish baseline of data loss for a component failure within a site
  • Level 2:
    • A component can be independently upgraded without impacting operation interacting components
    • Component configuration to be externalized in a common fashion across ONAP projects
    • All application logging to adhere to ONAP Application Logging Specification v1.2
    • Implement guidelines for a minimal container footprint – Taka (low priority by TSC)
    • Level 2:
        • OOM: move to variable for database’s user/password – Aaron APPC-?
        • CSIT OOM – by INT team
      • Security:
        • CII badging passing level
        • Continuously retaining no critical or high known vulnerabilities > 60 days old
        • All communication shall be able to be encrypted and have common role-based access control and authorization.
        • Absolute Minimum expectation:
        • Desired expectation is full CII badging silver level, if not 75% towards that.
        • Stretch goal: Project Level 2
      • Scalability:
        • Level 1: supports single site horizontal scale out and scale in, independent of other components.
        • Clustering env with downstream: netconf,APPC-1258 (Arron) ansible (Orange team?).
      • Manageability:



1/23/19 - APPC Project Weekly Minute

Participants:Takamune Cho,  Patrick Brady, Joss Armstrong , Aaron Hay , Suresh Reddy

Agenda

  • Casablanca Mtn Release status
  • Dublin release plan

Action item

  • Casablanca Mtn Release: 1.4.4 Released
  • Traffic Migration Demo by Orange team - Taka
  • Dublin:
    • ODL upgrade: Fluorine SR2 – APPC-1277
    • Level 2: performance improvement plan created  - Joss APPC-1311
    • APPC Pre-install appc features during docker build. – APPC- 1322 Patrick (DONE)
    • Netconf non-clustering vs clustering.- Patrick/Aaron - APPC-1242 to Gary Wu to test
      • MD-Sal clustering(must have), jolokia (optional: performance measurement), netconf-clustering(must have). – three clustering bundles from ODL.
    • OOM – move k8s env to project level : Mike will be presenting on PTL mtg next week.(Feb 4)
    • Remove un-used bundles from CCSDK’s odlsli – CCSDK- 944 Taka
    • 80% test coverage (APPC: 50% committed)
    • OOM: move to variable for database’s user/password – Aaron APPC-1340
    • CSIT OOM – by INT team
    • Clustering env with downstream: netconf,APPC-1258 (Arron) ansible (Orange team).



1/30/19 - APPC Project Weekly Minute

Participants:Takamune Cho,  Patrick Brady, Randa Maher, Joss Armstrong, Lathishbabu Ganesan

Agenda

  • Casablanca Mtn Release status
  • Dublin release

Action item

  • Casablanca Mtn Release: 1.4.4 Released
  • Traffic Migration Demo by Orange team - Taka
  • Dublin:
    • MD-Sal clustering(must have), jolokia (optional: performance measurement), netconf-clustering(must have). – three clustering bundles from ODL.
    • ODL upgrade: Fluorine SR2 – APPC-1277
    • Level 2: performance improvement plan created  - Joss APPC-1311, Taka will check APPC tenant for Dublin env.
    • APPC Pre-install appc features during docker build. – APPC- 1322 Patrick (DONE)
    • Netconf non-clustering vs clustering.- Patrick/Aaron - APPC-1242 to Gary Wu to test
    • OOM – move k8s env to project level : AAI is chosen for the first project – Taka is going to join OOM mtg and report to here.
    • Remove un-used bundles from CCSDK’s odlsli – CCSDK- 944 Taka (under progress)
    • 80% test coverage (APPC: 50% committed)
    • OOM: move to variable for database’s user/password – APPC-1340 (Taka/Aaron)
    • CSIT OOM – by INT team (FYI)
    • Clustering env with downstream: netconf,APPC-1258 (Arron) ansible (Orange team).



2/6/19 - APPC Project Weekly Minute

Participants:

Agenda

  • APPC VM/VNFC Level HealthCheck LCM API Enhancement

  • Orange has a request to allow APPC LCM API to support VNFC and above.


2/13/2019 - APPC Project Weekly Minute

Participants:Takamune Cho,  Patrick Brady, , Joss Armstrong, Lathishbabu Ganesan, Shubhada Ramkrishna Vaze 

Agenda

  • Casablanca Mtn Release - Done
  • Dublin release

Action item

  • Casablanca Mtn Release: 1.4.4 Released - Done
  • Traffic Migration Demo by Orange team - Taka
  • Dublin:
    • MD-Sal clustering(must have), jolokia (optional: performance measurement), netconf-clustering(must have). – three clustering bundles from ODL.
    • ODL upgrade: Fluorine SR2 – APPC-1277
    • Level 2: performance improvement plan created  - Joss APPC-1311, Taka will check APPC tenant for Dublin env.
    • Netconf non-clustering vs clustering.- Patrick/Aaron - APPC-1242 to Gary Wu to test
    • OOM – move k8s env to project level : AAI is chosen for the first project – Taka is going to join OOM mtg and report to here.
    • Remove un-used bundles from CCSDK’s odlsli – CCSDK- 944 Taka (under progress)
    • 80% test coverage (APPC: 50% committed)
    • OOM: move to variable for database’s user/password – APPC-1340 (Taka/Aaron) – sprint 8
    • CSIT OOM – by INT team (FYI)
    • Clustering env with downstream: netconf,APPC-1258 (Arron) ansible (Orange team).
    • VM/VNFC generic healthcheck LCM – payload format needs to formalized
    • Multiple ansible server support
    • Move Nexus3 to dockerHub
    • Checklist template updated by Catherine





2/20/2019 - APPC Project Weekly Minute

Participants:Takamune Cho,  Patrick Brady, , Joss Armstrong, Lathishbabu Ganesan, Shubhada Ramkrishna Vaze , FariBorz Behi

Agenda

  • Dublin release

Action item

  • Traffic Migration Demo by Orange team - Taka
  • Dublin:
    • MD-Sal clustering(must have), jolokia (optional: performance measurement), netconf-clustering(must have). – three clustering bundles from ODL.
    • https://r.lfnetworking.org/lfn-zoom/ONAP/TSC-Meetings/TSC-2019/tsc-2019-02-14.mp4 starting from 1:15:00, the new structure Helm Chart. if you have time, you could watch the video.
    • https://lf-onap.atlassian.net/wiki/display/DW/ptl+meeting+recordings 2019-02-19 starting from 0:24:00, new CI/CD
    • ODL upgrade: Fluorine SR2 – APPC-1277
    • Level 2: performance improvement plan created  - Joss APPC-1311, Taka will check APPC tenant for Dublin env.
    • Netconf non-clustering vs clustering.- Patrick/Aaron - APPC-1242 to Gary Wu to test
    • OOM – move k8s env to project level : AAI is chosen for the first project – Taka is going to join OOM mtg and report to here.
    • Remove un-used bundles from CCSDK’s odlsli – CCSDK- 944 Taka (talked with Dan, Dan will think about the core bundles in odlsli )
    • 80% test coverage (APPC: 50% committed)
    • OOM: move to variable for database’s user/password – APPC-1340 (Taka) – sprint 8
    • CSIT OOM – in Dublin
    • Clustering env with downstream: netconf,APPC-1258 (Taka/Patrick) ansible (Orange team).
    • VM/VNFC generic healthcheck LCM – payload format needs to formalized – taka
    • Multiple ansible server support
    • Move Nexus3 to dockerHub


Recording:



2/27/2019 - APPC Project Weekly Minute

Participants:Takamune Cho,  Patrick Brady, , Joss Armstrong, Lathishbabu Ganesan, Michael Zinnikas, Randa Maher

Agenda

  • Dublin release
  • Dublin env in k8s

Action item

  • Traffic Migration Demo by Orange team - Taka
  • Dublin:
    • MD-Sal clustering(must have), jolokia (optional: performance measurement), netconf-clustering(must have). – three clustering bundles from ODL.
    • ODL upgrade: Fluorine SR1 – APPC-1277
    • Level 2: performance improvement plan created  - Joss APPC-1311, Taka will check APPC tenant for Dublin env.
    • Netconf non-clustering vs clustering.- Patrick/Aaron - APPC-1242 to Gary Wu to test
    • OOM – move k8s env to project level : AAI is chosen for the first project – Taka is going to join OOM mtg and report to here.
    • Remove un-used bundles from CCSDK’s odlsli – CCSDK- 944 Taka (talked with Dan, Dan will think about the core bundles in odlsli )
    • 80% test coverage (APPC: 50% committed)
    • OOM: move to variable for database’s user/password – APPC-1340 (Taka) – sprint 8
    • CSIT OOM – in Dublin
    • Clustering env with downstream: netconf,APPC-1258 (Taka/Patrick) ansible (Orange team).
    • VM/VNFC generic healthcheck LCM – payload format needs to formalized – taka follow up with Scott.
    • Multiple ansible server support
    • Move Nexus3 to dockerHub
    • footprint


Recording:


3/6/2019 - APPC Project Weekly Minute

Participants:Takamune Cho,  Patrick Brady,  Joss Armstrong

Agenda

  • Dublin release
  • Update from PTL / TSC meeting
  • Daylight Saving Time starts 3/10/2019

Action item


  • Traffic Migration Demo by Orange team - https://docs.onap.org/en/casablanca/submodules/integration.git/docs/docs_vFWDT.html#vfw-traffic-distribution-use-case
  • Dublin:
    • MD-Sal clustering(must have), jolokia (optional: performance measurement), netconf-clustering(must have). – three clustering bundles from ODL.
    • M3 – 3/14
    • Level 2: performance improvement plan created  - Joss APPC-1311, Taka will check APPC tenant for Dublin env.
    • Netconf non-clustering vs clustering.- Patrick - APPC-1242 to Gary Wu to test
    • OOM – move k8s env to project level : AAI is chosen for the first project – Taka is going to join OOM mtg and report to here.
    • Remove un-used bundles from CCSDK’s odlsli – CCSDK- 944 Taka (talked with Dan, Dan will think about the core bundles in odlsli )
    • 83.1% test coverage (APPC: 50% committed)
    • OOM: move to variable for database’s user/password – APPC-1340 (Taka) – sprint 8
    • CSIT OOM – in Dublin
    • Clustering env with downstream: netconf,APPC-1258 (Taka/Patrick) ansible (Orange team).
    • VM/VNFC generic healthcheck LCM – payload format needs to formalized – taka follow up with Scott.
    • Multiple ansible server support
    • Footprint – MariaDB left
    • https/tls support for netconf


3/13/2019 - APPC Project Weekly Minute

Participants:Takamune Cho,  Patrick Brady,  Joss Armstrong, J Hartley

Agenda

  • Dublin release
  • Update from PTL / TSC meeting
  • APPC tenant reassignment

Action item

  • TSC/PTL meeting updates:
  • Dublin:
    • MD-Sal clustering(must have), jolokia (optional: performance measurement), netconf-clustering(must have). – three clustering bundles from ODL.
    • M3 – 3/14
    • Level 2: performance improvement plan created  - Joss APPC-1311, Taka will check APPC tenant for Dublin env.
    • Netconf non-clustering vs clustering.- Patrick - APPC-1242 to Gary Wu to test
    • OOM – move k8s env to project level : AAI is chosen for the first project – Taka is going to join OOM mtg and report to here.
    • Remove un-used bundles from CCSDK’s odlsli – CCSDK- 944 Taka (talked with Dan, Dan will think about the core bundles in odlsli )
    • 83.5% test coverage (APPC: 50% committed)
    • OOM: move to variable for database’s user/password – APPC-1340 (Taka) – sprint 8
    • Clustering env with downstream: netconf,APPC-1258 (Taka/Patrick) ansible (Orange team).
    • VM/VNFC generic healthcheck LCM – payload format needs to formalized – taka follow up with Scott.
    • Multiple ansible server support
    • Footprint – MariaDB left
    • https/tls support for netconf



3/27/2019 - APPC Project Weekly Minute

Participants:Takamune Cho,  Patrick Brady,  Joss Armstrong, Oskar Malm

Agenda

Action item



4/3/2019 - APPC Project Weekly Minute

Participants:Takamune Cho,  Patrick Brady,  Joss Armstrong, Oskar Malm , Lathishbabu Ganesan

Agenda

  • Dublin R4 release
  • Update from ONAP – San Jose
  • Call for idea/evolution/enhancement for El Alto

Action item



4/17/2019 - APPC Project Weekly Minute

Participants:Takamune Cho,  Patrick Brady,  Oskar Malm , Lukasz Rajewski

Agenda

  • Dublin R4 release
  • Draft evolution/enhancement for El Alto

Action item

  • El Alto Planning: Taka presented the draft proposal for El Alto planning


 

4/24/2019 - APPC Project Weekly Minute

Agenda

  • Dublin R4 release
  • El Alto

Participants:Takamune Cho,  Patrick Brady,  Joss Armstrong Lathishbabu Ganesan

Action item

  • El Alto:
    • ODL upgrade?
    • Microservice
    • OOM: move to variable for database’s user/password – APPC-1340 (Taka) 
    • Remove un-used bundles from CCSDK’s odlsli – CCSDK- 944 Taka (talked with Dan, Dan will think about the core bundles in odlsli )
    • Etc..
    • Planning:
    • Backlog:



5/1/2019 - APPC Project Weekly Minute

Agenda

  • Dublin R4 release
  • El Alto
  • Frankfurt

Action item

  • El Alto:
    • ODL SR2 update
    • Backlog:
      • OOM: move to variable for database’s user/password – APPC-1340 (Taka) 
      • Remove un-used bundles from CCSDK’s odlsli – CCSDK- 944 Taka (talked with Dan, Dan will think about the core bundles in odlsli )
      • Etc..
    • Planning:
  • Frankfurt:
    • Microservice
    • Planning:


5/15/2019 - APPC Project Weekly Minute

Agenda

  • Dublin R4 release
  • El Alto R5 release
  • Frankfurt R6 release

Action item

  • El Alto:
    • ODL SR2 update
    • Cleaning Backlog JIRA
    • Cleaning Security JIRA: “assignee = Takamune_Cho AND status != Closed AND status != Delivered” check OJSI ticket
    • Planning:
  • Frankfurt:
    • Microservice
    • Planning:


5/29/2019 - APPC Project Weekly Minute

Participants:Takamune Cho,  Patrick Brady, Lathishbabu Ganesan  Jeff Hartley

Agenda

  • Dublin R4 release
  • El Alto R5 release
  • Frankfurt R6 release

Action item

  • El Alto:
    • ODL SR2 update
    • Cleaning Backlog JIRA:
    • Cleaning Security JIRA: “assignee = Takamune_Cho AND status != Closed AND status != Delivered” check OJSI ticket
    • Planning:
  • Frankfurt:
    • Microservice
    • Planning:

 Discussion: APPC-1617 - Getting issue details... STATUS