...

Duration 90 minutes

Zoom Log Chat

Anchor
Chat Chat

05:59:51     From  Bin Yang (Wind River) : #info, Bin Yang, Wind River
05:59:58     From  Margaret Chiosi (Huawei) : #info Margaret Chiosi is proxy for Chaker Huawei
06:00:26     From  Kenny Paul (LFN) : https://

...

lf-onap.

...

Feel free to request your VISA: http://events.linuxfoundation.org/visa-request

Submit your proposal: https://wiki.lfnetworking.org/display/LN/OPNFV-ONAP+January+2019+Session+Proposals

Casablanca Release sign-off on November 30th, 2018

...

...

From Me to Everyone:  02:58 PM
#info, Catherine Lefevre, AT&T
From Bin Yang (Wind River) to Everyone:  02:59 PM
#info, Bin Yang, Wind River
From Margaret Chiosi (Huawei) to Everyone:  02:59 PM
#info Margaret Chiosi is proxy for Chaker Huawei
From Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone:  03:00 PM
https://wiki.onap.org/display/DW/Proxy+List
From Jason Hunt to Everyone:  03:01 PM
#info Jason Hunt, IBM
From Andreas Geissler (Deutsche Telekom) to Everyone:  03:01 PM
#info Andreas Geissler (DT)
From Margaret Chiosi (Huawei) to Everyone:  03:02 PM
But I am proxy for proxy :-) Chaker just happens to be on vacation. If chaker gets voted on as a member, then we can add me as a proxy
From Viswa KSP to Everyone:  03:02 PM
#info Viswa, Verizon
From Ranny Haiby to Everyone:  03:03 PM
#info Ranny Haiby, Nokia
From Srini Addepalli (Intel) to Everyone:  03:03 PM
#info Srinivasa Addepalli, Intel
From Davide Cherubini (Vodafone) to Everyone:  03:03 PM
#info proxy Davide Cherubini, Vodafone
From David Stilwell (AT&T) to Everyone:  03:03 PM
#info Dave Stilwell, AT&T
From Eric Debeau to Everyone:  03:03 PM
#info Eric Debeau, Orange
From Lingli to Everyone:  03:04 PM
#info Lingli, CMCC
From Stephen Terrill to Everyone:  03:05 PM
#info Stephen Terrill, Ericsson.
From Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone:  03:05 PM
#topic thanks to all
From Lingli to Everyone:  03:05 PM
+1
From Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone:  03:05 PM
#topic Release review
From Me to Everyone:  03:08 PM
# topic Review of Casablanca exit criteria
discussion about OOM-1532  will be documented and planned for Casablanca Maintenance Release
From Eric Debeau to Everyone:  03:08 PM
#info OOM documentation ti be finalized
From atlassian.net/wiki/display/DW/Proxy+List
06:01:07     From  Jason Hunt : #info Jason Hunt, IBM
06:01:10     From  Andreas Geissler (Deutsche Telekom) : #info Andreas Geissler (DT)
06:02:20     From  Margaret Chiosi (Huawei) : But I am proxy for proxy :-) Chaker just happens to be on vacation. If chaker gets voted on as a member, then we can add me as a proxy
06:02:54     From  Viswa KSP : #info Viswa, Verizon
06:03:02     From  Ranny Haiby : #info Ranny Haiby, Nokia
06:03:08     From  Srini Addepalli (Intel) : #info Srinivasa Addepalli, Intel
06:03:19     From  Davide Cherubini (Vodafone) : #info proxy Davide Cherubini, Vodafone
06:03:26     From  David Stilwell (AT&T) : #info Dave Stilwell, AT&T
06:03:53     From  Eric Debeau : #info Eric Debeau, Orange
06:04:41     From  Lingli : #info Lingli, CMCC
06:05:07     From  Stephen Terrill : #info Stephen Terrill, Ericsson.
06:05:39     From  Kenny Paul (LFN) : #topic thanks to all
06:05:53     From  Lingli : +1
06:06:00     From  Kenny Paul (LFN) : #topic Release review
06:07:40     From  Catherine Lefevre : # topic Review of Casablanca exit criteria
06:08:13     From  Catherine Lefevre : discussion about OOM-1532  will be documented and planned for Casablanca Maintenance Release
06:08:13     From  Eric Debeau : #info OOM documentation ti be finalized
06:09:02     From  Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) : logging will update the release date - on the RL - thanks gildas - right now
06:09:43     From  Catherine Lefevre : #Info Release note to be completed
06:10:26     From  Catherine Lefevre : #Action PTLs to completed as soon as they can; send a note to Gildas when it is done
06:12:36     From  Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) : I sent a mail about the 6 missing in public, 6 missing in private
06:12:48     From  Catherine Lefevre : #Csablanca Vulnerabilities Review
06:13:15     From  Catherine Lefevre : Log completed
06:13:31     From  NingSo : #info Ning So, Reliance Jio
06:14:44     From  Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) : Logging SDNC-contextbuilder repo clm reports are on master - the component is not released in casablanca - came in 6 weeks ago - so we are good with deferring these specific reports to dublin
06:14:53     From  Catherine Lefevre : SDC-completed
06:15:02     From  Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) to Everyone :   03:09 PM
logging will update the release date - on the RL - thanks gildas - right now
From Me to Everyone:  03:10 PM
#Info Release note to be completed
#Action PTLs to completed as soon as they can; send a note to Gildas when it is done
From https://lf-onap.atlassian.net/wiki/pages/viewpage.action?pageId=16089191
06:15:19     From  Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) to Everyone:  03 : 12 PM
I sent a mail about the 6 missing in public, 6 missing in private
From Me to Everyone:  03:13 PM
#Csablanca Vulnerabilities Review
Log completed
From NingSo to Everyone:  03:13 PM
#info Ning So, Reliance Jio
From Michael the above page needs to be scrubbed and moved to public
06:16:50     From  Catherine Lefevre : # action AAI- Amy to move to public
06:17:11     From  Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) to Everyone:  03 : 14 PM
Logging SDNC-contextbuilder repo clm reports are on master - the component is not released in casablanca - came in 6 weeks ago - so we are good with deferring these specific reports to dublin
From Me to Everyone:  03:14 PM
SDC-completed
From CB is on the lower left
06:17:43     From  Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) to Everyone :   03:15 PM
https://wikilf-onap.onap.org/pages/viewpage.action?pageId=43385152
the above page needs to be scrubbed and moved to public
From Me to Everyone:  03:16 PM
# action AAIatlassian.net/wiki/display/DW/Log+Streaming+Compliance+and+API#LogStreamingComplianceandAPI-ONAPLogStreamingDeploymentView
06:18:57     From  Catherine Lefevre : # action SDNC- Amy to move to public
From Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) to Everyone:  03:17 PM
SDNC-CB is on the lower left
https://wiki.onap.org/display/DW/Log+Streaming+Compliance+and+API#LogStreamingComplianceandAPI-ONAPLogStreamingDeploymentView
From Me to Everyone:  03:18 PM
# action SDNC- Amy to move to public
From Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone:  03:20 PM
#action @gildas to publish release 06:19:24     From  Victor Gao(Huawei)  to  Gildas Lanilis(Privately) : Gildas, can you change the VNFSDK PTL name to me:)
06:20:06     From  Kenny Paul (LFN) : #action @gildas to publish release note status list to the wiki
From Brian to Everyone:  03:20 PM
06:20:18     From  Brian : Helen is adding Use Case release notes to integration
From 06:20:39     From  Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone :   03:20 PM
#topic Integration status
From Brian to Everyone:  03:20 PM
06:20:47     From  Brian : on onap.readthedocs.io
From 06:22:01     From  Gildas Lanilis  to  Victor Gao(Huawei)(Privately) : done. sorry for that.
06:22:19     From  Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone:  03 : 22 PM
https://wikilf-onap.onapatlassian.orgnet/wiki/display/DW/Casablanca+Release+Integration+Testing+Status
From Me to Everyone:  03:22 PM
06:22:48     From  Catherine Lefevre : Quality of Release container sounds great since it only took 1-2 days max to retest all
From 06:23:20     From  Christopher McCray (AT&T) to Everyone :   03:23 PM
@Gildas - Just received response back from Sarat. Release notes will be completed for OOF today Sarat and team are meeting now to review.
From 06:27:44     From  Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone:  03 : 27 PM
VFW-HPA reviewed https://wikilf-onap.onapatlassian.orgnet/wiki/display/DW/vFW+with+HPA+Integration+Test+-+Test+Status
From 06:28:28     From  Gildas Lanilis to Everyone:  03 : 28 PM
Release Management deck uploaded in wiki at https://wikilf-onap.onapatlassian.orgnet/wiki/display/DW/TSC+2018-11-29+Meeting+Agenda
From 06:29:51     From  Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone:  03 : 29 PM
Release notes for VFW-HPA being updated with known issues
From 06:32:13     From  Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) to Everyone:  03 : 32 PM
When Wiki pages are renamed we revert to the DB id - would be nice if we could get a proxy page like we do in JIRA moves - will look into it
From Kenny 06:33:12     From  Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone:  03 : 33 PM
#topic Security Review
From 06:33:31     From  Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) to Everyone :   03:34 PM
bitcoin hackers get in without oauth
06:33:32     From  Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) : https://jira.onap.org/browse/LOG-353
within 24 hours - and can deploy rogue pods
From 06:34:20     From  Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) : within 24 hours - and can deploy rogue pods
06:34:43     From  Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone :   03:34 PM
both secure communications and vulnerability  good - 2 public vulnerability pages to be migrated.
From 06:35:48     From  Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) to Everyone:  03 : 35 PM
RL date, link willdo - logging
From 06:36:53     From  Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone:  03:37 PM
#topic recommendation
: #topic recommendation
06:37:32     From  Kenny Paul (LFN) : Release notes to be updated by tomorrow. We will not sign off today.
From 06:38:29     From  Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) to Everyone :   03:39 PM
azure, aws no issue
06:39:04     From  Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) : deploy scripts updated with Mike's deploy plugin
https://git06:39:04     From  Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) : https://git.onap.org/logging-analytics/tree/deploy
06:39:10     From  Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) : https://git.onap.org/logging-analytics/tree/deploy/cd.sh
06:39:28     From  Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) : versions here
https://git.06:39:29     From  Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) : https://git.onap.org/logging-analytics/tree/deploy/rancher/oom_rancher_setup.sh#n66
From 06:39:30     From  Stephen Terrill to Everyone :   03:39 PM
Kenny, just for clarity; the mtg tomorrow starts at the same time as today right :-)
From 06:39:35     From  Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) to Everyone :   03:39 PM
to match OOM RTD
From 06:39:57     From  Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone:  03:43 PM
@Steve T: @Steve T- Yes, same time 6AM pacific
06:40:44     From  Kenny Paul (LFN) : https://lists.onap.org/g/onap-tsc/viewevent?eventid=376993&calstart=2018-11-30
06:41:47     From  Kenny Paul (LFN) : #topic Edge Coordinator Proposal
06:43:34     From  Kenny Paul (LFN) : Srini reviewed the proposal
From 06:46:27     From  Stephen Terrill to Everyone:  03:46 PM
FYI in case : FYI in case it has flown under the radar.  The current coordinators
06:46:32     From  Stephen Terrill : https://wikilf-onap.onapatlassian.orgnet/wiki/display/DW/Technical+Community+Coordinators
From 06:46:52     From  Murat Turpcu ( Turk Telekom) to Everyone :   03:46 PM
#info, Murat Turpcu, Turk Telekom
From 06:50:12     From  Arash Hekmat (Amdocs) to Everyone :   03:50 PM
The question is: What role does ONAP play as related to Edge? Distrubuted single instance ONAP? Multi-Intstance ONAP? Or, ONAP only a Central service manager managing many Edges?
From 06:50:57     From  Stephen Terrill to Everyone:  03 : 50 PM
https://wikilf-onap.onapatlassian.orgnet/wiki/display/DW/Technical+Community+Coordinators
From Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone:  03:57 PM
https://wiki.onap.org06:54:36     From  Gildas Lanilis  to  Eric Debeau(Privately) : Have u seen my email on the EXTAPI RN?
06:57:23     From  Kenny Paul (LFN) : https://lf-onap.atlassian.net/wiki/display/DW/ONAP+Technical+Community+Document#ONAPTechnicalCommunityDocument-4.4.4Subcommitteevs.coordinator
From 06:57:52     From  Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) to Everyone :   03:57 PM
Acumos integration with ONAP
06:57:52     From  Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) : https://jira.onap.org/browse/LOG-264
From Stephen Terrill to Everyone:  03:58 PM
06:57:58     From  Eric Debeau  to  Gildas Lanilis(Privately) : no
06:58:09     From  Stephen Terrill : https://wikilf-onap.onapatlassian.orgnet/wiki/display/DW/ONAP+Technical+Community+Document
06:58:17     From  Stephen Terrill : 4.1.4
From 06:58:29     From  Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) to Everyone:  03:58 PM
TSC jira for Acumos
: TSC jira for Acumos
06:58:30     From  Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) : https://jira.onap.org/browse/TSC-15
From Me to Everyone:  03:59 PM
06:59:11     From  Catherine Lefevre : TSC vote - +1 approve Edge Coordinator creation ; 0-neutral; -1 no approval Edge coordinator
From Eric Debeau to Everyone:  04:00 PM
Agree with Stephen. We need a description
From Me to Everyone:  04:01 PM
vote performed when description will be provided
agree on the direction to move forward
From Stephen Terrill to Everyone:  04:02 PM
A coordination area is created by sending a request to the TSC via the ONAP-TSC email list.  The email shall have:
-        Email Subject: Creation Request for coordination area: <coordination area name>
-        Coordination Area responsibility description: <Description of the coordination area responsibilities>
-        Reporting Cadence: <description of when reporting is expected to be delivered to the TSC>
-        Area Coordinator: <Name of the area coordinator> (Can be blank)
The decision to create the coordination area is created by a TSC decision (per the TSC voting rules).  A decision can be made with modification, with the modifications captured in the TSC minutes.  Once a coordination area is created, it will be documented in the ONAP Wiki.
For the Area coordinator, see section: 4.2.2.2.
From Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone:  04:05 PM
#action Ramki to send the formal proposal as per section 4.1.4.3 of the Technical community document
From Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) to Everyone:  04:06 PM
Would like to definitely go to the CL meet - but OOM is at the same slot 1000EST Wed
From Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone:  04:12 PM
#topic Control-Loop Sub update.
@Pam reviewed https://wiki.onap.org/display/DW/Control+Loop+Sub+Committee+Dublin+Release+Planning
#topic Prioritization of Dublin
From Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) to Everyone:  04:17 PM
https://jira.onap.org/browse/TSC-55
same as
https://jira.onap.org/browse/TSC-25
or complementary CI/CD
From Viswa KSP to Everyone:  04:17 PM
Is this document available anywhere in ONAP Wiki / or sent as part of mailing list ?
From Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone:  04:19 PM
Concerns raised regarding not harding usecases
From Alexander Vul to Everyone:  04:22 PM
@kenny - the issue raised is that our platform is not generic enough to handle any use case…
@kenny - this would require more than documentation, it would require to have proper component design and modlarity
From Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) to Everyone:  04:24 PM
These docs look to be on (checking) https://jira.onap.org/browse/TSC-45
yes, on attchments to the jira
From Viswa KSP to Everyone:  04:24 PM
Thanks Micheal
From 07:00:29     From  Eric Debeau : Agree with Stephen. We need a description
07:00:40     From  Catherine Lefevre : vote performed when description will be provided
07:01:07     From  Catherine Lefevre : agree on the direction to move forward
07:02:12     From  Stephen Terrill : A coordination area is created by sending a request to the TSC via the ONAP-TSC email list.  The email shall have:

-        Email Subject: Creation Request for coordination area: <coordination area name>

-        Coordination Area responsibility description: <Description of the coordination area responsibilities>

-        Reporting Cadence: <description of when reporting is expected to be delivered to the TSC>

-        Area Coordinator: <Name of the area coordinator> (Can be blank)

The decision to create the coordination area is created by a TSC decision (per the TSC voting rules).  A decision can be made with modification, with the modifications captured in the TSC minutes.  Once a coordination area is created, it will be documented in the ONAP Wiki.

For the Area coordinator, see section: 4.2.2.2.

07:05:22     From  Kenny Paul (LFN) : #action Ramki to send the formal proposal as per section 4.1.4.3 of the Technical community document
07:06:48     From  Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) : Would like to definitely go to the CL meet - but OOM is at the same slot 1000EST Wed
07:07:36     From  Kenny Paul (LFN) : #topic Control-Loop Sub update.
07:09:02     From  Kenny Paul (LFN) : @Pam reviewed https://lf-onap.atlassian.net/wiki/display/DW/Control+Loop+Sub+Committee+Dublin+Release+Planning
07:12:01     From  Kenny Paul (LFN) : #topic Prioritization of Dublin
07:16:43     From  Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) to Everyone:  04 : 26 PM
I recommend we put these on the wiki - so we can link and comment and review history - Word is from the 90s
join our meets - posted on the jira - anytime for CD
https://jira.onap.org/browse/TSC-25
From Gildas Lanilis to Everyone:  04:31 PM
need to drop
From 55
07:16:48     From  Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) to Everyone:  04:32 PM
Thanks Gildas - see you later
Good message - carry over epics that move/span releases
I thought there was only 1 - sorry I missed all the 5 sessions for TSC-45
From Stephen Terrill to Everyone:  04:33 PM
Need to drop.
From : same as
07:16:59     From  Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) to Everyone :   04:32 PM
Thanks Gildas - see you later
Good message - carry over epics that move/span releases
I thought there was only 1 - sorry I missed all the 5 sessions for TSC-45
From Stephen Terrill to Everyone:  04:33 PM
Need to drop.
From Srini Addepalli (Intel) to Everyone:  04:34 PM
Need to drop
From Bin Yang (Wind River) to Everyone:  04:35 PM
+1 to Brain's point
From Helen Chen to Everyone:  04:35 PM
Need to drop. Have nice day / afternoon / evening !
From Kenny Paul (LFN) to Everyone:  04:36 PM
Brian F suggests relabeling some of the usecases. Alex agrees and comments that things need to be more generic
Eric notes that we need to provide tutorials for new features. Also that we need vendors to provide commercial VNF templates.
From Davide Cherubini (Vodafone) to Everyone:  04:38 PM
Need to drop
From Murat Turpcu ( Turk Telekom) to Everyone:  04:41 PM
need to drop
From https://jira.onap.org/browse/TSC-25
07:17:15     From  Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) : or complementary CI/CD
07:17:31     From  Gildas Lanilis  to  Steven Wright(Privately) : Steve, I just sent u an invite to finalize the RN.
07:17:46     From  Viswa KSP : Is this document available anywhere in ONAP Wiki / or sent as part of mailing list ?
07:19:44     From  Kenny Paul (LFN) : Concerns raised regarding not harding usecases
07:21:55     From  Alexander Vul : @kenny - the issue raised is that our platform is not generic enough to handle any use case…
07:22:50     From  Alexander Vul : @kenny - this would require more than documentation, it would require to have proper component design and modlarity
07:23:38     From  Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) : These docs look to be on (checking) https://jira.onap.org/browse/TSC-45
07:24:04     From  Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) : yes, on attchments to the jira
07:24:49     From  Viswa KSP : Thanks Micheal
07:25:43     From  Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) to Everyone:  04 : 42 PM
I can't make the vF2F - will be on customer site
Can we push past the vF2F - echoing comments
from Alex
From Gildas Lanilis to Everyone:  04:42 PM
Li nk to Dublin https://wikiI recommend we put these on the wiki - so we can link and comment and review history - Word is from the 90s
07:26:26     From  Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) : join our meets - posted on the jira - anytime for CD
07:26:26     From  Michael O'Brien(Amdocs, LOG) : https://jira.onap.org/display/DW/Release+Planning#ReleasePlanning-DublinReleasePlanning
From Me to Everyone:  04:42 PM
please send feedback about Dublin Release to Gildas or on the wikibrowse/TSC-25
07:31:00     From  Gildas Lanilis : need to drop

...

Zoom Attendance Log

Anchor
Attendees Attendees

TSC Members Attendance based on Zoom Chat Log: xx% 83%

#info, Catherine Lefevre, AT&T
#info, Bin Yang, Wind River
#info Margaret Chiosi is proxy for Chaker Huawei
#info Jason Hunt, IBM
#info Andreas Geissler (DT)
#info Viswa, Verizon
#info Ranny Haiby, Nokia
#info Srinivasa Addepalli, Intel
#info proxy Davide Cherubini, Vodafone
#info Dave Stilwell, AT&T
#info Eric Debeau, Orange
#info Lingli, CMCC
#info Stephen Terrill, Ericsson.

...

#info Ning So, Reliance Jio

#info, Murat Turpcu, Turk TelekomTurpcu, Turk Telekom

...

TSC Decisions  

2018 TSC Decisions

...

Action items

•  PTLs to complete the Casablanca release note
•  Amy to move A&AI/SDNC Vulnerability reports to public
•  Gildas to publish release note status on the wiki
•  Ramki to send the formal proposal as per section 4.1.4.3 of the Technical community document