...
- Committer diversity - prefer 3 or more companies represented; if only 2, then need diversity in companies contributing
- S3P requirements not considered as gating for "mature" phase
- "Mature" phase criteria are more about projects being "active"
Presentation shared at TSC meeting.
| View file | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Recordings of the working group meetings:
maturity_rvw_working_group_20200721.mp4
maturity_rvw_working_group_20200722.mp4
maturity_rvw_working_group_20200812.mp4
| Project Name | Recommended Disposition on moving from incubation to mature (approve, decline, revert) | Comments (for approve: improvements that could be made, for decline: steps needed to get to approve, for revert: information needed for recommendation) | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AAI | approve | recommend improving committer diversity where possible 4/16/2021 The sub project ESR is now unmaintained - Project State: Unmaintained | ||||||||
| CCSDK | approve | continue improvements in code coverage, S3P, etc. | ||||||||
CLAMP | TBDdecline | strong project, but need to improve company diversity in both committers and contributors 4/16/2021 The functionalities of this project are now merged with the Policy project - | ||||||||
| CLI | decline | need participation in the most recent release; need to document architecture review | ||||||||
| DCAE | approve | continue improvements in code coverage, S3P, etc. | ||||||||
| DMaaP | approve | recommend improving committer diversity where possible; recommend an updated architecture review | ||||||||
| External API Framework | approve | improve wiki documentation on release content; continue improvements in code coverage, S3P, etc. | ||||||||
| Holmes | decline | need participation in the most recent release; need to increase contributor and committer diversity; need recent architecture review | ||||||||
| Modeling | approve | |||||||||
| MSB | revert | please add information on contributors/committers/companies by release; please add information on deployment/use of MSB by operators or others | ||||||||
| MultiCloudrevert | ||||||||||
| ONAP Portal | TBD or revert | decline | need to improve company diversity in committers; please add information on review by architecture subcommittee; please add information on deployment/use of ONAP Portal by operators or others 4/16/2021 The Portal project is now unmaintained - Project State: Unmaintained | |||||||
| OOF | approve | recommend improving committer diversity where possible; recommend an updated architecture review for any components not already reviewed (CMSO?) | ||||||||
| Policy Framework | approve | |||||||||
| SDC | approve | conduct a more current architecture review with a focus on overlap of DCAE-D with DCAE-MOD. | ||||||||
| SDNC | please update the wiki page with the new committers, | |||||||||
| SO | approve | please add information on test coverage; please add information on deployment/use of SO by operators or others | ||||||||
| Usecase UI | approve | recommend improving committer diversity where possible | ||||||||
| VFC | recommendation for future is to avoid bulk commits and & focus on steady contributions and commits. | |||||||||
| VNFSDK | revert | please document the review with the architecture subcommittee; please ensure that all committers are active | ||||||||
| VVP | decline | need to improve company diversity in committers; please add information on review by architecture subcommittee; |