Versions Compared

Old Version 2

changes.mady.by.user Xu Yang

Saved on

compared with

New Version Current

changes.mady.by.user Andy Mayer

Saved on

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.
Comment: Added meeting recording and chat log

General Information:

  

View file
namemeeting_saved_chat.txt
height150

Agenda:

  • Agenda bashing - 5 minutes
    • Meeting time change? (DST)
    • ETSI NFV R3 feedback
    • Modeling glossary
  • Modeling Documentation - 0 minutes
  • Model Proposals - 40 minutes
    • PNF instance model
    • license management
    • allotted resource
    • 5G RAN service
  • Modeling Process discussion - 10 minutes

Material:

Minutes:

  • Agenda bashing:
    • Meeting time change
      • check if people would like to move the meeting time 1 hour earlier since the DST has begun in US
      • feedback:
        • both: Andy
        • prefer not to shift: Michela (overlap with ETSI-alignment call)
        • prefer to shift: Ben (to avoid overlapping with the requirement call)
      • AP:
        • Ben to check the requiremnt call will change the meeting time
          • Alla will not change for now (the requirement call will work by UTC time)
        • Michela to check the ETSI-alignment call will change the meeting time
    • ETSI NFV R3 feedback
    • Modeling glossary
      • Xu is working on a review wiki page
  • Modeling Documentation
    • suggestion from Michela: to add relationship documentation in the model (not only in the diagrams), and create Jira for it
      • Q: how to document the relationship classes in the papyrus?
      • will discuss later
    • AP:
  • Model Proposals
    • PNF instance model
      • Jacqueline has generated PNF instance model from A&AI input
      • the problem is the model still doesn't have attribute descriptions
      • Jacqueline suggests to ask Jimmy to re-start the reverse engineering call to solve this problem
      • Andy suggests to reverse engineering from the swagger documents (instead of UMLs)
      • AP: Jacqueline will talk with Jimmy about this issue, Andy will help create a long-term call if needed
    • license management
      • License Model Review Comments
        • #1: discuss how to document relationship classes
          • Xu will create a Jira and update the wiki page
        • #2: add a label to the diagram explaining why the model is refered to only VNFD now
          • will update
        • #3: SPPoolLimit and VendorPoolLimit are not found in the "resource onboarding" page, i.e., no evidence for including them in the model
          • Andy will double check
        • #4: question on how to deal with EntitlementInstance and LicenseKeyInstance in the approval? (suggest to keep "experimental", i.e., not requesting approval, for the current proposal)
          • Xu will create a Jira to discuss how to deal with the experimental classes in the readthedocs
        • #5: there is an attribute marked using "Future" stereotype, suggest not to use the "Future" stereotype
          • is "Future" stereotype needed compared with the "Experimental" stereotype?
            • no "Future" stereotype is defined in the "lifecycle stereotype proposal"
          • Andy will check and remove "Future" if it exists
    • allotted resource
    • 5G RAN service model
      • presentation of the A&AI discussion on this topic
  • Modeling Process Discussion
    • discuss the current status of the modeling process discussion
    • focus on modeling generation and approval process
      • during the process, modeling subcom needs to negotiate with arc, use case and other communities for modeling design
    • suggest to add checklist to M3
      • for use case team and also projects like A&AI, etc. to check the model impacts
    • see Proposed ONAP Release Process Updates for Information and Data Modeling