13:47:04 <kennypaul>#startmeeting tsc 2018-01-0413:47:04 <collabot> Meeting started Thu Jan 4 13:47:04 2018 UTC. The chair is kennypaul. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
13:47:04 <collabot> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic.
13:47:04 <collabot> The meeting name has been set to 'tsc_2018_01_04'
13:47:20 <kennypaul>#chair phrobb13:47:20 <collabot> Current chairs: kennypaul phrobb
13:48:30 <kennypaul>#topic rollcall14:00:33 <frankbrockners>#info Frank Brockners, Cisco (will be on IRC only for the first 30min)14:01:26 <JasonHunt>#info Jason Hunt, IBM14:01:27 <kennypaul>#info Alla Goldner, AMDOCS14:01:41 <DhananjayPavgi>#info Dhananjay Pavgi, Tech Mahindra14:01:52 <RannyHaiby>#info Ranny Haiby, Nokia14:02:26 <cdonley>#info Chris Donley Huawei14:02:54 <Filipe_>#info Filipe_14:03:18 <Filipe_>#info Filipe Caetano (Coriant)14:03:33 <Zhaoxing>#info Zhaoxing Meng, ZTE14:03:46 <RajeshGadiyar>#info Rajesh Gadiyar Intel14:05:04 <munish>#info Munish, Proxy for Stefen Terrill, Ericsson14:09:19 <kennypaul>#info Xinhui Li, VMWare14:09:46 <kennypaul>#info Lingli Deng, CMCC14:09:53 <jamil>#info jamil for Orange14:11:10 <kennypaul>#topic housekeeping14:11:33 <kennypaul>#info collaboration dates.14:12:03 <kennypaul>#info virtual meeting week of Feb 12.14:12:29 <kennypaul>#undo14:12:29 <collabot> Removing item from minutes: <MeetBot.ircmeeting.items.Info object at 0x2fc7a90>
14:12:42 <kennypaul>#info virtual meeting week of Feb 5th.14:13:06 <kennypaul>#action kenny coordinate VF2F14:13:58 <kennypaul>#info more days rather than longer hours.14:16:05 <kennypaul>#startvote Does the TSC confirm the election of Pam Dragosh as the Chair of the Control-Loop Subcommittee? +1, 0, -114:16:05 <collabot> Begin voting on: Does the TSC confirm the election of Pam Dragosh as the Chair of the Control-Loop Subcommittee? Valid vote options are +1, 0, -1.
14:16:05 <collabot> Vote using '#vote OPTION'. Only your last vote counts.
14:16:16 <cdonley>#vote +114:16:18 <munish>#vote +114:16:20 <RannyHaiby>#vote +114:16:20 <gilbert>#vote +114:16:23 <JasonHunt>#vote +114:16:31 <jamil>#vote +114:16:33 <RajeshGadiyar>#vote +114:16:41 <Ning>#vote +114:16:53 <kennypaul>#vote +114:17:01 <DhananjayPavgi>#vote +114:17:14 <kennypaul>#info my vote representing Alla Goldner14:17:23 <Zhaoxing>#vote +114:18:01 <phrobb>#vote +114:18:23 <phrobb>#info my vote is on behalf of Xinhui14:18:51 <kennypaul>#endvote14:18:51 <collabot> Voted on "Does the TSC confirm the election of Pam Dragosh as the Chair of the Control-Loop Subcommittee?" Results are
14:18:51 <collabot> +1 (12): jamil, phrobb, RajeshGadiyar, DhananjayPavgi, JasonHunt, kennypaul, cdonley, Zhaoxing, Ning, gilbert, RannyHaiby, munish
14:19:57 <kennypaul>#topic multi-cloud confirmation vote.14:20:31 <kennypaul>#startvote Does the TSC confirm the promotion of Liang Ke14:20:31 <collabot> Unable to parse vote topic and options.
14:20:31 <kennypaul> as a committer on the Multi-Cloud project? +1, 0, -1
14:20:58 <kennypaul>#startvote Does the TSC confirm the promotion of Liang Ke as a committer on the Multi-Cloud project? +1, 0, -114:20:58 <collabot> Begin voting on: Does the TSC confirm the promotion of Liang Ke as a committer on the Multi-Cloud project? Valid vote options are +1, 0, -1.
14:20:58 <collabot> Vote using '#vote OPTION'. Only your last vote counts.
14:21:21 <gilbert>#vote +114:21:23 <munish>#vote +114:21:25 <RannyHaiby>#vote +114:21:26 <DhananjayPavgi>#vote +114:21:26 <phrobb>#vote +114:21:30 <cdonley>#vote +114:21:32 <Zhaoxing>#vote +114:21:36 <JasonHunt>#vote +114:21:38 <Ning>#vote +114:21:48 <kennypaul>#vote +114:21:48 <phrobb>#info phrobb vote is on behalf of Xinhui14:21:56 <jamil>#vote +114:22:19 <kennypaul>#info my vore representing Alla Goldner14:22:45 <gildaslanilis>#vote +114:23:10 <gildaslanilis>#info gildas lanilis voted on behalf of Lingli14:23:26 <kennypaul>#endvote14:23:26 <collabot> Voted on "Does the TSC confirm the promotion of Liang Ke as a committer on the Multi-Cloud project?" Results are
14:23:26 <collabot> +1 (12): jamil, phrobb, JasonHunt, cdonley, kennypaul, DhananjayPavgi, Zhaoxing, Ning, gildaslanilis, gilbert, RannyHaiby, munish
14:24:59 <phrobb>#topic TSC Election Process14:30:02 <phrobb>#topic Release Status (Beijing)14:31:06 <phrobb>#info gildaslanilis reviewed the Project Proposal status for new projects wanting to join the ONAP project14:31:51 <phrobb>#info Container Based Network Service/Function Deployment is going back to Arch committee next week14:33:06 <phrobb>#info "Image Manager" project is recommended to put under the A&AI project14:34:08 <phrobb>#info gilbert Notes that we need to ensure that the A&AI project scope is not enlarged by inclusion of this new project14:40:17 <phrobb>#info Run-Time Catalog project Has had advice to talk to SDC project for possible inclusion. They will talk next week14:41:04 <phrobb>#info Certificate and Secret Mgmt Service - This project has outstanding questions still14:42:13 <phrobb>#info ONAP Benchmark project has been approved to be a subproject of 'Integration"14:43:55 <phrobb>#info Open Source Access Mgmt - still need to go back to Arch. committee.14:44:33 <phrobb>#info Distributed KV Store - The recommendation was to join another project. No further info known at this time14:45:47 <phrobb>#info CHAP (Now known as MUSIC) Presented to Arch this week.14:47:51 <phrobb>#info Centralization & Externalization of Parser Distribution - Is being discussed as part of Functional Requirement for Beijing in Use Case subcommittee. This is likely not going to be a separate project request14:48:10 <amir_levy>#info Amir Levy Cloudify14:48:22 <phrobb>#info gildaslanilis reviews the upcoming Beijing milestones.14:50:55 <phrobb>#info Gildas notes that the TSC approved OOM as the main method for ONAP deployment. The question of support, or level of support for Heat Templates is still open.14:52:32 <phrobb>#info gilbert notes that we may be supporting OOM as primary with Heat as a secondary (deprecated) deployment method for Beijing, and have it removed from support in Cassablanca and beyond14:52:53 <phrobb>#info The question is really to the Integration team on what they can support for Beijing testing of deployment methods14:54:27 <phrobb>#info Gildas asks on the regard of upgrading from Amsterdam to Beijing. What is the TSC stance on any support from Amsterdam to Beijing.14:59:28 <kennypaul>#info discussion of approach to driving upgrade approach.14:59:36 <kennypaul>#undo14:59:36 <collabot> Removing item from minutes: <MeetBot.ircmeeting.items.Info object at 0x2faed10>
14:59:43 <phrobb>#info TSC consensus is that no upgrade path will be required from Amsterdam to Beijing. For Beijing and beyond, upgrade mechanisms need to be in place15:00:34 <phrobb>#info the Arch committee is requested to start a sub-team now to create a recommendation on upgrades for Beijing and beyond15:01:39 <phrobb>#info It is noted that OOM has migration capabilities. Hence work on migration needs to include OOM has part of the plans/discussions15:02:38 <phrobb>#info Gildas asks TSC to vote on the request to make the Fix and Affect version fields in Jira mandatory.15:04:53 <phrobb>#info Some questions on the impact to PTLs with this change15:06:11 <phrobb>#info Key point is that at defect creation we don't know if the bug was found in Amsterdam or Beijing and what the request is. Having that info is very helpful, hence the request15:06:56 <phrobb>#info Noted that more should be heard from the PTLs because this impacts them with a level of effort.15:08:31 <phrobb>#info Noted that the Affect field should be mandatory on creation so that the project/PTL knows what is affected.15:11:19 <phrobb>#agree the TSC notes that the Affect field is mandatory for bugs submitted at creation and the Fix field is mandatory at progress/transition15:12:50 <phrobb>#info API Stability - Noted in discussion that the Docs project can oversee a more defined set of guidelines for use/delivery of Swagger in Beijing15:13:56 <phrobb>#info Gildas walks through the Amsterdam bugs fixed that are targeted for SR115:16:31 <kennypaul>#topic Platform Maturity (S3P) Requirements Update15:17:04 <kennypaul>#info JasonHunt reviewed his slides15:18:25 <kennypaul>#info some additional input is required for resiliency & scalability15:20:53 <kennypaul>#info requesting guidance from the Benchmark team on areas such as tooling that can be leveraged by others15:22:53 <kennypaul>#info Manageability is more focused on consolidated logging rather than user experience at this time.15:25:18 <kennypaul>#topic MUSIC (formerly named CHAP) Project Proposal15:25:50 <kennypaul>#info Bharath reviewed the proposal15:26:11 <kennypaul>#link https://wiki.onap.org/display/DW/MUSIC-Multi-site+State+Coordination+Service15:31:47 <kennypaul>#info primary role is to coordinate states across sites.15:32:35 <kennypaul>#info review has been approved by the Arc-Subcommittee.15:33:49 <kennypaul>#info would like to understand what the specific S3P deliverable would be.15:35:38 <kennypaul>#info need to classify as MVP or not15:37:30 <kennypaul>#topic OOM and AAI committer promotions15:38:12 <kennypaul>#info email vote for both Boris [oom] and Venkata [aai] were approved.15:38:24 <kennypaul>#endmeeting
...
Zoom Chat Log
Anchor
zoom
zoom
06:04:50 From Lingli : Hi guys. Happy New Year to everyone! 06:05:01 From Jason Hunt : Happy New Year! 06:05:02 From xinhuili : This is Xinhui, something wrong with my netwok. Can not login IRC 06:05:18 From Dhananjay Pavgi : Happy New Year, All. 06:05:33 From Ajay Mahimkar : happy new year all !! 06:05:33 From PB2317 : Lingli and all, Happy New Year! 06:06:24 From Brian : HNY (for some reason alot of our old telecom folks seem to like acronyms too much :) 06:06:30 From Brian : Happy New Year 06:10:11 From Helen Chen : Happy New Year 06:12:51 From ONAP Meeting 1 : Happy New Year! 06:17:45 From xinhuili : Please help +1 for me 06:17:52 From Lingli : +1 from me, also. Thanks Kenny. 06:21:06 From xinhuili : +1 from me, thanks 06:21:14 From xinhuili : :) 06:21:18 From Lingli : +1 for me, too. 06:22:54 From Lingli : Thank you, Gildas. 06:41:09 From Huabing Zhao : Sorry, got disconnected just now. 06:43:12 From Helen Chen : Benchmark doesn’t change the scope of Integration. 06:58:56 From Brian : OOM is also a natural place 06:59:19 From Brian Hedstrom : Do we have a Wiki page that captures an ONAP Feature Roadmap that looks out several releases (years)? 07:05:33 From Brian : PTLs speak up if you have concerns - this affects your work directly 07:09:08 From Pamela Dragosh : I agree with Randa 07:10:10 From Dhananjay Pavgi : Agreed 07:10:18 From xinhuili : Agreed 07:10:35 From Huabing Zhao : Agreed 07:11:10 From Huabing Zhao : only bug affected version mandatory 07:11:11 From RanPollak : Agreed 07:11:19 From RanPollak : only bug affected