• Zoom bridge: https://zoom.us/j/283628617
  
• PTL Recordings
• AntiTrust Message

Agenda

START RECORDING

Sharing Best Practices

Duration	Agenda Item	Requested by	Notes / Links
1 hour	Cross-project discussions	Pamela Dragosh	New Policy API  Update on discussion with Dan Timoney and Seshu Kumar Mudiganti
	LF IT Support	Jessica Gonzalez	roadmap for pylint implementation Try to align pylint for all the projects It has been prototyped by several projects Not blocking the code but it provides information to the PTLs regarding the quality of submitted code It will be part of the Jenkins verify jobs ACTION: pylint will be implemented in all the projects as an informational tool (similar to checkstyle for JAVA) for the PTLs/Committers about the quality of submitted code.It will be part of the verify Jenkins job but it will not return verify -1 by default except if PTL will raise the request to block the code. No action for the TSC. IT-18078 integration/xtesting Jessica says e-mail sent to TSC mailing list. Waiting for TSC approval. ACTION: Kenny to review issue and determine need for TSC vote. Issue (IT-18144) with the Frankfurt Maturity Matrix - Frankfurt Release Platform Maturity v1 When trying to update then getting the following message I have tried to create v1 to fix the issue but the problem re-occurred. ACTIONS: #1 Seshu will create a ticket to fix v1 Platform Maturity - done IT-18144 #2 Jess will fix the current wiki page which is a current blocker for PTLs to complete their M1 #3 Jess will send a notice to onap-release, onap-tsc mailing list to provide guidelines in order to avoid this behavior in the future (not discard update?) ONAP JIRA issue - RELENG-2517 -ONAP JIRA has invalid resolution type resulting in confusing behavior        Old issue - maybe let's remind the ONAP Community about this limitation? IT-17739/RELENG-2422 - new open ticket to address the template changes for docker tagging. Its pending on LF update.
	Testing Environment	Morgan Richomme	Report on status of integration weather board for Frankfurt. 0: Integration Weather Board for Frankfort Frankfurt Release => Wiki page for PTLs to track their pair-wise testing, health checks, etc 1: Frankfurt Release Integration Test Blocking Issues => 1 Blocker & 10 Non Blockers already reported on Master by the Integration Team 2: Frankfurt Release Integration Testing Status => Integration Lead will need to update this wiki page depending on PTL M1 commitments
	Testing Improvement	Morgan RichommeLasse Kaihlavirta	Currently few failing jobs - please direct attention to getting these tests functioning correctly. Will continue to review here (ptl mtg) Useless CSIT test elimination ACTION: Morgan will send a notice to the PTLs to remind to review their CSIT jobs - if no action then clean-ups will be performed on Dec 3rd, 2019 - after the final review on PTL call (12/2)
	ToolChain Improvement	David McBride Sofia Wallin	El-Alto Retrospective - please submit your feedback by Nov 15th - these will be reviewed during the PTL Call on 11/18. Release Note Template
	Other Improvement suggestion	Paweł Pawlak Krzysztof Opasiak Amy Zwarico	S3P Security maturity update proposal: Add at least 2 sections: vulnerabilities remediation  (OJSIs management + known vulnerabilities) and increased tests code coverage (example could be increase by 5% for each project). Known vulnerabilities management - PLEASE complete your analysis, respond to comments for El Alto release. Table Current OJSI performance Analysis Still 38 OJSI tickets related to HTTP open while we expose only ~20 HTTP ports. We can close almost half as soon as we get the commit hash-id Worst performing projects CLI 4 OJSI tickets open 1 ticket with CVE No activity at all Logging 9 OJSI tickets open 1 ticekt with CVE Very limited activity MSB 11 OJSI tickets open 1 ticekt with CVE No activity at all Could be improved APPC DMAAP INT SDNC SO Please follow them CLAMP Average response time ~1 day More advanced fixes provided in less than a month Policy Prompt response Following the procedure No open issues. Portal Recognition for the hard work Not everything fixed yet but good progress made OOM Helm charts password removal Heads-up: Information (not the code) requested by the SECCOM must be provided as part of the Frankfurt release. Otherwise the component and its associated use cases/requirements will be descoped from the ONAP Frankfurt release. SECCOM will provide a proposal to the TSC on 10/31.
	Subcommittee Updates for PTLsSharing Best Practices	cl664y@att.com	TSC El-Alto Demo Contest - DEMOS - R5 El-Alto Demos Submission open till Nov. 8th, 2019 EAUG/TSC review/vote: from Nov. 11th to Dec 4th, 2019
IF TIME ALLOWS ....
20 min	Release status	David McBride Paweł Pawlak djhunt Alla.Goldner Stephen terrill Hui Deng  Andy Mayer Pamela Dragosh	El Alto OOM Tagging status? Any other issues? Frankfurt Schedule Frankfurt M1 Milestone Exception Process proposal TSC Prioritization Platform Maturity form on wiki
	Incoming Events	Kenny Paul	PTL call is now planned @3pm CET, 9am EST, 6am PST, 8am CST, 10pm China Time, 7.30pm Indian Time ONAP/CNTT F2F Event in January 13-16th, 2020 - Prague - Registration https://events19.linuxfoundation.org/events/lf-networking-ddf-plugfest-2020/ ONAP 2 day event before or after ONES North America (April 20&21) - Los Angeles (TBC) ONAP DDF planned in June - under planning ONAP 2 day event before or after ONS North Europe - Antwerp (TBC) Survey coming from LFN for Dec OR Jan for steady-state full DDF meetings to all LFN communities & locations
10 mins	Remaining Action Items	Former user (Deleted)	PTL Weekly ONAP12, Mon UTC 13:00

Zoom Chat Log 

Anchor
chat chat

06:04:27 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : working on my audio
06:18:01 From Eric Debeau : Example of pylint configuration in multicloud: https://git.onap.org/multicloud/openstack/tree/ocata/tox.ini
06:19:07 From Morgan (Orange) : and in integration https://git.onap.org/testsuite/python-testing-utils/tree/robotframework-onap/tox.ini
06:21:43 From Pamela Dragosh : -1 to blocking code
06:22:21 From Sai Seshu : -1 many false positive 
06:22:29 From Sai Seshu : Need to provide explanation 
06:25:06 From Tony Hansen : flake8 incorporates pyflakes and pep8 together and is a reasonable addition to pylint
06:27:20 From Pamela Dragosh : David - forgot to mention at the beginning. But due to DST a lot of team meetings moved up an 1 hour. Some now fall at 5am PST. Can/Should they be updated?
06:31:59 From Jimmy Forsyth (AT&T) : Adding to Pam’s question, I am trying to update the calendar in groups.io per the wiki (https://lf-onap.atlassian.net/wiki/display/DW/Calendar+and+Bridge+FAQ#CalendarandBridgeFAQ-HowdoIchangeameeting?) and I am getting “sorry, that group does not exist” when I click on my meeting.
06:35:17 From Pamela Dragosh : Kenny - you can add me as a moderator for snap-discuss.
06:39:57 From Catherine Lefèvre : Team - just FYI- I am attending the SPC meeting in 20 mins, representing TAC team on behalf of Jason
06:40:07 From Kenny Paul (LFN) : @jimmy looking -
@pam thank you
06:42:00 From Taka Cho : One more very tiny issue I found for updating wiki: when I was trying to update wiki page with an "emoji". I got "wiki has communication error with server". when I took out emoji, the server communication error was gone and wiki can be updated...
06:44:41 From Sai Seshu : @pam I'm finding difficult to open up the support Linux page... Can you please help to raise the ticket for the page
06:45:00 From Vijay Venkatesh Kumar (AT&T) : IT-17739/RELENG-2422 opened to address the template changes for docker tagging. Its pending on LF update.
06:47:35 From Jessica W - LF : @Vijay.. Tony and Chris commented on RELENG-2422..can you please comment back?
06:49:08 From Catherine Lefèvre : @Jess, Vijay - I have added to the PTL wiki page so we do not forget it
06:49:23 From Pamela Dragosh : @sesh - IT-18144
06:49:33 From Catherine Lefèvre : thanks seshu
06:49:48 From Sai Seshu : @thanks pam
06:49:48 From Catherine Lefèvre : i guess it is to cover paltform maturity wiki
06:50:01 From Sai Seshu : Yes
06:50:30 From Catherine Lefèvre : thanks pam
06:51:06 From Vijay Venkatesh Kumar (AT&T) : @Jess - yes,  Tommy and Chris were clarifying the original ask for LF; this is still pending action though.
06:54:38 From Catherine Lefèvre : @Kenny, what's the e-mail subject regarding IT-18078 e-mail sent to the T
06:54:46 From Catherine Lefèvre : sc - can't find it - thanks
07:00:55 From Catherine Lefèvre : @Team - leaving the call - if any question then raise them to David - i will follow-up later with him - mailbox pretty full so response can be delayed - sorry
07:24:21 From Manoop Talasila - AT&T : I have to drop for another meeting. Thanks.

Action Items 

Anchor
action action

•  Kenny Paul determine whether TSC vote is required for IT-18078. See email sent to TSC mailing list.
•  Morgan Richomme send email notification to list to warn community about Dec 3 deletion of disabled Jenkins jobs
•  Krzysztof Opasiak setup separate meetings with MSB, Logging, and CLI projects (In that order) to discuss security maturity and open OJSI tickets.