Page Comparison

Communication patterns

• Intra-Component communication (e.g. between so-bpmn-infra and so-sdnc-adapter)
• Inter-Component communication (e.g. between onap-cli and so)
• External communication (e.g. user → sdc-ui)

Assumptions (to be agreed)

• AAF will be removed
  • → No Container port encryption
• Services must not use NodePorts 
  • → external communication only via Ingress
• Ingress is the default for external communication
  • Istio IngressGateway
  • Nginx Ingress ?
• Inter-component communication can be 
  • directly (as today)
  • via Ingress (Seshu's proposal) ?
• Communication encryption can be done:
  • on Ingress level (adding certificate to Gateway)
  • on SM (e.g. Istio sidecars)
  • on Kernel Level (using eBPF via Cilium)

To be supported options in ONAP

1. No ONAP internal encryption:

   1. Intra-Component: unencrypted
   2. Inter-Component: unencrypted
   3. External: unencrypted/encrypted
2. Inter-Component encryption:
   1. Intra-Component: unencrypted
   2. Inter-Component: encrypted
   3. External: unencrypted/encrypted
3. Full encryption:
   1. Intra-Component: encrypted
   2. Inter-Component: encrypted
   3. External: unencrypted/encrypted

Implementation proposals

Option 1 (no ONAP internal Encryption)

• External communication:
  • Components expose (external) interfaces to Ingress 
  • Encryption on Ingress (optional)
• Internal communication: 
  • No service Mesh
  • No TLS port encryption on pods
  • Direct unencrypted inter-component communication

Option 2 (inter-component encryption)

• External communication:
  • Components expose (external) interfaces to Ingress 
  • Encryption on Ingress (optional)
• Internal communication: 
  • No service Mesh
  • No TLS port encryption on pods
  • Inter-component communication via Ingress (encrypted)

Option 3 (full encryption)

• External communication:
  • Components expose (external) interfaces to Ingress 
  • Encryption on Ingress (optional)
• Internal communication: 
  • Service Mesh enabled
  • No TLS port encryption on pods
  • Direct encrypted inter-component communication (via sidecars)

Solution using Istio:

Solution using eBPF via Cilium:

https://cilium.io/blog/2020/11/10/ebpf-future-of-networking/
https://ebpf.io/