Versions Compared

Old Version 10

changes.mady.by.user Xu Yang

Saved on

compared with

New Version 11

changes.mady.by.user Cristina Badulescu [ERI]

Saved on

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

Proposed meeting logistics:

...

  • Bruno:
    • 1) in ETSI-NFV alignment, does the implementation imply no Helm Charts are included? A: no implementation yet
    • 2) how to support cluster selection among several compute resources? A: the helm charts can support them
  • Shitao:
  • Thinh:
    • clarify if the analysis is individual contribution? A: yes
  • Cristina:
    • it's good to have the discussion on the merge, but in principle the 2 approaches are differentin principle the 2 approaches are different, both from modeling and architecture perspectives. VNFD takes an abstract modeling approach for both VMs and containers, and covers subset of resources from native templates. Whereas the ASD complements the native templates only and does not require the NFV-MANO architecture. Each has Pros and cons, but I don't see how the 'merge the models' idea can apply here, these are conceptually different solutions.
  • Bruno:
    • merge of the models and merge of the orchestration methods are seperate topics
    • it would be good if we can have single model and orchestration methods in the industry
    • ask why Thinh is negative on having single model/orchestration method?
      • Marian: philosophy are different for ASD and VNFD
    • whether the info captured in ASD should be added into the VNFD
  • Hui:
    • agree with Bruno that we could have another session to further discuss the proposals, involving more ETSI delegates
    • there are many commonalities between the two models, not suggesting ONAP to copy the models while just changing the names
  • Kuno:
    • Because network information as Virtual Link is very important for telecom application, how to describe these network information by ASD and how/who can connect VNF to operator network which had several issue in past in ETSI-NFV? What is different concept between ASD and VNFD when consider these network aspects ?
    • What/How ASD can ensure backward comapatibility concept or mechanism?
  • Bruno:
    • suggest to use the gotomeeting bridge for another session
    • 4. Is the ASD really technology independent? there are several references to K8S in the IM
    • 5. You said ASD will support the CNF direct model. Can you elaborate on this?
    • 6. Will the changes made to SOL004 be proposed to ETSI? Will the new 5G non-MANO-artifact be registered?