Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

...

maturity_rvw_working_group_20200722.mp4

maturity_rvw_working_group_20200812.mp4


Project Name

Recommended Disposition

on moving from incubation to mature

(approve, decline, revert)

Comments

(for approve: improvements that could be made,

for decline: steps needed to get to approve,

for revert: information needed for recommendation)

AAIapproverecommend improving committer diversity where possible
CCSDKapprovecontinue improvements in code coverage, S3P, etc.

CLAMP

declinestrong project, but need to improve company diversity in both committers and contributors
CLIdeclineneed participation in the most recent release; need to document architecture review
DCAEapprovecontinue improvements in code coverage, S3P, etc.
DMaaPapproverecommend improving committer diversity where possible; recommend an updated architecture review
External API Frameworkapproveimprove wiki documentation on release content; continue improvements in code coverage, S3P, etc.
Holmesdeclineneed participation in the most recent release; need to increase contributor and committer diversity; need recent architecture review
Modelingapprove
MSBrevertplease add information on contributors/committers/companies by release; please add information on deployment/use of MSB by operators or others
MultiCloudrevert  approve (updated Aug 12, 2020)please add information on contributors/committers/companies by release; please add information on deployment/use of MultiCloud by operators or others
ONAP Portaldeclineneed to improve company diversity in committers; please add information on review by architecture subcommittee; please add information on deployment/use of ONAP Portal by operators or others
OOFapproverecommend improving committer diversity where possible; recommend an updated architecture review for any components not already reviewed (CMSO?)
Policy Frameworkapprove
SDCapproveconduct a more current architecture review with a focus on overlap of DCAE-D with DCAE-MOD.
SDNCrevert  approve (updated Aug 12, 2020)please update the wiki page with the new committers, add information on test coverage and contributors/committers/companies by release; please add information on deployment/use of SDNC by operators or others
SOapproveplease add information on test coverage; please add information on deployment/use of SO by operators or others
Usecase UIapproverecommend improving committer diversity where possible
VFCrevert  approve (updated Aug 12, 2020)recommendation for future is to avoid bulk commits and & focus on steady contributions and commits.  please address all questions in the comments; also ensure that all committers are active
VNFSDKrevertplease document the review with the architecture subcommittee; please ensure that all committers are active
VVPdeclineneed to improve company diversity in committers; please add information on review by architecture subcommittee;

...